Only 6k words so far, but rather interesting. 4/5

 

There's only three chapters, but it seems to be off to a good start. It's much better than the other one...what-it's-name, Darkness something, and I think it's going to be much more interesting.

4/5

 

Very good start and much more original than many stories I've read. It's too early to rate acurately, IMO, but I'd give it a 5/5 so far.

Recommended

 

I liked it. Hope he gets control soon. Rampid dementor chaos!

 

Interesting, good start. I liked it: 5/5 so far...

Recommended

 

This is a very original idea. Not many stories have Harry become a dementor, even fewer are written well. I think this is the first one that I have read in which he has trouble learning to use the Dementor abilities. Recommended.

 

I liked this too. I think Snape's level of assholity was perfect.

Recommended 4.5/5

 

I liked it, and feel that this is a good show of a cannon Harry. My only concern is the rating of the story. Something as dark as being a Dementer, I figured would warant at least a T rating, O well.

4/5

 

I did love it. Snape is as bad or even worse than in the books. Fantastic.

But Harry was good too... yes, he cried but now he's beginning to do something and to learn. I hope, we have a cool new Potter when he's again in Hogwarts.

4.5/5

 

I've been reading this one. It's awesome and original. The amount of angst for the situation is just right.

4.5/5

 

It's short and still in the begining parts of the story but I like what I see so far. I've only encountered one Dementor!Harry thats worth reading. The descirpition of the effects of the patronus charm on the affected was a bit lacking in my opinion. But since there is no precident for the affect its still a job well done. I think that the angst was a tad much but its wasn't sufficating. I'm definetly going to be following this one.

4/5

 

WARNING, WARNIG! I read her profile and she likes Snape and in her favourites I found a few SLASH fics. Other than those warning signals, good fic
4/5

 

Good news then, it looks like Harry just killed Snape. Maybe not, but I can hope.

 

Well... it's actually not bad to start. Although I am a tad worried about those potential "sl--h" tendencies, so far Harry seems pretty interesting, and his powers could certainly become quite kickass. However, if there's any "finding peace with Snape" going on, I'll be quite angry. So far, well-written, but not fantastic - a solid 3/5.

-J

 

So far its been good. The crying scene did annoy me but hey it fit into the story pretty well. The effects of the Patronous is a little lacking in description. But overall I like it so far.

However the slash warning makes me a little cautious.

4/5

 

And how would he kill snape with these new powers? Seems like a set up for Harry to make out with Snape. Oh well; lets hope not.

 

I just read it and it's not too bad. I like it. The slash issue isnt too big of a concern for me if it is in the background however if it becomes a large area of focus or part of the storyline, I will most likely drop it.