1. DLP Flash Christmas Competition + Writing Marathon 2024!

    Competition topic: Magical New Year!

    Marathon goal? Crank out words!

    Check the marathon thread or competition thread for details.

    Dismiss Notice

  2. Hi there, Guest

    Only registered users can really experience what DLP has to offer. Many forums are only accessible if you have an account. Why don't you register?
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Introducing for your Perusing Pleasure

    New Thread Thursday
    +
    Shit Post Sunday

    READ ME
    Dismiss Notice
DLP Story Competition Guest User Registration Nag SPS + NTT

Search Results

Search Again
Page 1 of 2
  1. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    The line between confidence and arrogance is very fine.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 28, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  2. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I agree with Kai - I mean, yeah, I was frustrated when Jon posted his list because he got all of the Knights correct, which meant that there was a decent chance his other guesses were right too. But it also made me nearly positive that Jon was scum, so I took his scum reads with a bit of salt. The way I see it, most people were mad because he revealed town roles, which normally doesn't happen. People make lists of who they're suspicious of all the time, but no one ever outs the other...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 28, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  3. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I had you targeted, but was roleblocked :/ Sorry. On improvements, I think the Knights are pretty good as-is. My protection ability isn't all that useful because it runs the risk of being redundant on any of the power roles provided that Forthill is still alive and/or the role I target still has a life left. It's moderately useful for protecting the other Knights, but only if you're trying to track Namshiel. But as was pointed out, any increase in strength for the town has to also equal...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 27, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  4. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I'm already doomed - I'm White Court tainted (as of Night 4). I can't purify myself due to the roleblock, Snowflake died last night, and Moridin derped today. But even if he hadn't, he used his purification last night on someone else, so it's unavailable tonight to save me. The Merlin can't help me. Actually, I'd be a good target for the Merlin to switch in for someone who's likely to be targeted since I'm going to die anyways. Provided he doesn't already have some scum ID'd for that...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 25, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  5. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    The thing is, if Seratin isn't Susan (and he'd still be town at this point since I mixed up how the role works), then Susan is dead (day 3 or night 3) or is a derpy mcderpinstein and hasn't posted any night actions since night 2. The people who died in day 3/night 3 are: guljons (Dracula), Jon, Fenreallis, and Schrodinger (Lindquist). Jon claimed a different town role and revealed a bunch of town players - I'm pretty sure he was scum, though I don't know which one. Susan as a town...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  6. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Oh...apparently I misread Susan's role - she doesn't join a court until she's actually killed. Whoops, sorry about that. Which means that Castiel is scum - the Red King/Lara Raith maybe, since he checked as town? But why would he claim WC taint after someone already had?
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  7. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Whatever they are, they're not on the same scum team as Kalas, who can't be a Denarian. Plus, there aren't enough dead people for the real Dresden/Morgan to be dead. There are 14 dead players, and 10 roles that we KNOW are dead, plus one or two that might be depending on mod derps and who you want to believe. If you consider that Azira and Jon both claimed Archive, they can be ruled out (what motivation would Dresden and Morgan have to fake-claim another town role other than each...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  8. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    We have no confirmation that Jon was Lara. I'm not sure who he was if he wasn't Lara, but if we go by seductions alone, he wasn't. Hell, for all we know, he could have actually been the Archive. I will point out that we had two Seduction claims for last night, so one (or both, I suppose - but that would be stupid) are lying. My money's on Seratin due to the convenient timing of his first seduction claim and the silencing of Susan. But you make a good point about Castiel and Lara....
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  9. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Smile: just save comments like that for after the game. I'm not quite sure what you just said (and don't explain it - you shouldn't have said it in the first place), but whatever it was has the potential to change the game based on whatever bullshit interpretations people make. Actually, it would probably be best if someone just removed the post.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  10. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Confused on why you didn't mention Stojil when you first revealed your checks on page 38. At that point, you said your checks were Castiel, dhulli (who's been changed to the result of a mistaken communication with Smile), Jon, and Krogan (not necessarily in order).
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  11. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    -.- So many people leaving makes it really fucking difficult to get reads... ---------- Post automerged at 11:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:42 PM ---------- And given what happened to dhulli, you're not going to get one.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  12. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Was I seriously the only person who caught that both Seratin and Castiel claimed White Court taint today? One is scum, and my money's on Seratin (as Susan). He posted that he'd been seduced on Day 3, right after the last night that Susan whored. The only other possibilities for Susan are Eternity Lost and Fenreallis, but they fit other roles better. Plus, I now have fairly solid trust in Big Z, and he checked Castiel as town.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  13. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    This makes no sense. I mean, it's assumed that Kincaid is dead because he hasn't come forward to back (or denounce) anyone claiming Archive, but there are several options. Ashaya springs to mind - she was killed the first night as well. He could also have been Evan Tide (with Schro fake-claiming Lindquist), or Eternity Lost. If Kincaid were alive, you still wouldn't know who he was unless he came forward. Furthermore, the only reason that I can see for stating that jwlk was Kincaid...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  14. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Smile, you probably shouldn't post things like that in the thread - keep in in the QTs. ---------- Post automerged at 10:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:41 PM ---------- I sees a derp. Seratin, you're Susan.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  15. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I agree with Kalas being scum, but I have my own little tidbit of information to throw out. I actually caught this yesterday, right at the last second, but by the time I verified everything, Smile had made his end-of-day post already. Remember this statement Lungs? Funny thing is, the Archive DOES NOT KNOW KINCAID's IDENTITY. And honestly, I have no idea why you claimed a role that had been claimed twice already.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 24, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  16. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Whoops, missed that. So there is still a Denarian out there. ---------- Post automerged at 09:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:57 PM ---------- Also, just remembered that Big Z originally said that he checked dhulli and returned town, but later, he said that he was 99% sure dhulli was town. What's the meaning of that?
    Post by: coleam, Jan 23, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  17. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    He checked Jon on Night 1 and found that he used his action. if Jon was Lara, he would have seen "No Action." This of course assumes that Lungs is the Archive. I'm still not entirely convinced for reasons expressed in one of my earlier posts. ---------- Post automerged at 08:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:39 PM ---------- Last minute analysis. Scum roles still alive: Thomas - if Big Z's claim is true Susan - last whoring was Night 2, so only possibilities are Eternity Lost...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 23, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  18. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    He checked you before Jon shat all over the thread. ---------- Post automerged at 08:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:20 PM ---------- I know - I was still confused though. New avatars tend to do that to me. I keep thinking Vash is Lutris because for some reason that Ninja Turtle looks like Lutris' old Rayquaza avatar out of the corner of my eye.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 23, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  19. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Inorite? Also: Why you change your avatar on me?!?!? I was so confused for a second.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 23, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  20. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    The only problem I have with your Archive claim Lungs is that it requires Azira to be significantly more forward-thinking and scheming than I think he actually was. He set the whole thing up with a request for a replacement (that wasn't honored) during the Jon fiasco, and included an unspecified massive derp on Smile's part relating to him as one of the reasons. Sure, he could have set that up deliberately, but it seems completely at odds with his playstyle the next day, which, as you put...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 23, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  21. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I believe that Susan last whored on Night 2. I'm guessing that Fen was the Blackstaff though since there should have been a Blackstaff kill on Night 3. Unless Mavra used her one kill on Night 1? No way of knowing that though.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  22. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    It's not an issue of risk. It's that you have absolutely no way to verify anything you've claimed AND you've had your one "scum check" shat all over by Krogan. You just made yourself completely useless to the town over one little sniff of potential scum - not even confirmed, no matter how suspicious it looked. When you claim a role as big as Dresden, you have to have solid, concrete, irrefutable evidence. Not "my infocheck was blocked, so he must be scum". Hell, you didn't even wait to...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  23. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    If he really is Dresden, he's just going to get role-blocked to hell and back.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  24. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I want to believe you, but the I have literally zero read on the people you checked. No one can ever get a read on Jon (and it's better than 50/50 that he was the Archive, after Azira's derpiness yesterday), and Castiel and dhulli have both been lurking the whole game. What was your reasoning for checking Castiel and dhulli? They aren't exactly power players. Honestly, if you really are Dresden, it was a very poor idea to reveal now. You only had one scum check, and the scum aren't in...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  25. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Great idea...except Lindquist is already dead. Unless Schro was fake-claiming and the real Lindquist chose not to come forward? I highly doubt it. We're into day 4 since Schro claimed, and we haven't even had a hint that he was lying. For now, Rescind Vote. We'll see what happens. ---------- Post automerged at 10:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:47 PM ---------- To add, I'm curious about whether anyone else was tainted last night or contacted by Namshiel. Also, who got...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  26. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Why not reveal the rest of your checks then? It seems a bit fishy for you to role-reveal without revealing the rest of your info. I don't necessarily doubt you, given Jon's track record, but why only reveal the info in the guy you're angling hard to kill? ---------- Post automerged at 09:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:56 PM ---------- Deadline Vote: Krogan
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  27. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Statements like this set off my scumdar. The only way you could know Jon's role is if you are Lindquist, who was already claimed with no objections, so if you're going to claim that role, you'd better have a damn good reason for not stepping up during the three days that Schrodinger was claiming Lindquist. And why do you think Krogan is scummy? Because he was white-knighting Jon so hard? Seems like a really poor scum tactic to be taking, especially after he knew Jon was going down at the...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  28. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    So onto analysis: no kills last night. Very interesting. Either the reds are getting role-blocked, they're all dead, or they had the misfortune of hitting a NK-protected player. And there was only one kill the night before, when there should have been two. I suppose that the King could be dead and that the Duchess used her second in a row the night before - thus having to take a night off last night. That would suggest that last night the Blackstaff was either dead, role-blocked, or hit...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  29. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Wouldn't it take 10votes for a majority? 9 votes is a 50/50 split. ---------- Post automerged at 08:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:46 PM ---------- Also, I was seduced. In my defense, she seemed like a nice girl at the time...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 22, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  30. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Is that supposed to mean Night 2? Or are you sticking by your Night 3 statement? If you're claiming to actually have checked Zenzao on Night 2 (after saying that you forgot to do a check that night), who did you check on Night 3? And if you're sticking by your Night 3 statement, Smile's response to me boiled down to "Read the priority list, you idiot." There's no way he fucked that one up.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  31. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Vote player: Aziraphile I have confirmation from Smile that an Archive check on a player that was killed/cleansed the same night would return nothing. You derped hard. ---------- Post automerged at 04:20 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:18 PM ---------- That would be Aziraphale. Sorry about misspelling your name ^^
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  32. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Oh, missed that. The rest of the infochecks were cut off on my screen I guess. ---------- Post automerged at 01:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:24 PM ---------- This does not compute.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  33. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    So then that means that Zenzao was Namshiel - Namshiel communication is the only Denarian night action that occurs before cleansing. Good to know. Only one problem: jwlk died on Night 1, so if Smile derped, you should have taken over on Day 2, not Day 3 (side note: curious phrasing, "jwlk didn't use his Archive powers on Night 1 and Night 2" - of course he didn't, he was dead before he had the chance to activate them). And Kincaid isn't given the option to die for the Archive....
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  34. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    To add to Snowflake's list: 7) Was anyone Denarian'd last night? Namshiel can die by lynch or NK, so it would be awesome if he got picked off already and the two cleansed Denarians were Nicodemus and Tessa. ---------- Post automerged at 09:21 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 AM ---------- Also, Azira, if you are the Archive, what are the results of your checks?
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  35. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Why would you need purification if you were tainted by the Black Court? Unless Aekiel derped massively, the Black Court is gone.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  36. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    To clarify: I'm assuming that someone wouldn't waste a NK on the chance that Schro was going to be purified.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  37. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Right, but Schro was set to die by seduction last night.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  38. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Well, since neither Moridin nor Zennith placed a vote for Stojil/Xantam (both had voted for guljons and were switched), they can't be Dracula. That means that either guljons was Dracula and Mavra was already dead or Aekiel is Dracula (and guljons was Mavra?). If it was guljons, then he did it on the off chance that it could save his ass, and to cause confusion, and just to use his power. I don't see much sense in Aekiel revealing himself in a failed attempt to save Mavra, though he did...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 20, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  39. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Guljons didn't give off a scum vibe to me (apart from not posting much), so I'm not going to pile on. Not that it matters, since he already has 14 votes.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 19, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  40. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    So then I could say, "Jon really was sleeping, but he's just using that as cover for not voting." You're just shooting yourself in the foot. I'm not defending Lungs - as you said, he's been lurking, and I haven't seen enough to get a read on him - but you need to come up with better evidence before you start accusing people. Claiming that someone is using a legit reason to not be paying much attention to the thread as cover for a scum role, with that as your only evidence, is a bit rich...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  41. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I thought we'd agreed not to doubt peoples' real life excuses. There's no way to verify one way or another, which is why most of the games have it explicitly stated in the rules. If you call his debate tournament bullshit, then you lose your defense about not voting on day 1. /just sayin'
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  42. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    I actually have no idea what you'd do if you were town, since I can't recall a game off the top of my head where you were, but I agree that it fits with your general view towards mafia. It's more the fact that you spend half your post harping about being pro-town, then turn around and say "If you vote for me, fuck you." It's not a particularly good way to win people over. And as I said later in the same post, you're smart enough to know that, which to me suggests that you just don't give...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  43. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Curious about your reasoning for this. Unless you're Forthill, Merlin, a Red, or a Denarian there's no way you could be certain, though Stojil did come off as pretty aggressively pro-town on Day 2, and he was the only one who did. Reason to suspect that it was him I suppose, but why make such a definitive statement? Good point, though hard to prove. He's definitely playing aggressively - which can be either a scumtell or a town tell, but he's gone after people before based on fairly...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  44. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Good question; the only limitation on the Duchess's powers is that she can't use the night kill that she inherits from the Red King more than two nights in a row. The role list says nothing about limiting her auction ability. You do make a good argument about Jon, and he has a history of playing highly devious scum. That said, the players that he's pointed to have been suspicious for one reason or another. I definitely thought Eternity Lost was scummy, and LochNess had only posted the...
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  45. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Yes. I got a message saying so.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  46. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    No, I was purified.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  47. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    No. Role-claiming is really only useful if it will save your ass and you have important info to share. You were't too much at risk on Day 2. I suppose it would have made believing you today easier, but who knows how the night actions would have swung with your reveal?
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  48. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Actually, it might be. You are right about the Merlin's power acting first, but if Forthill's targeting works like NK targeting, then his protection would go to the swapped in target (Schrodinger in this case). So would anything else targeted at the swapped out player, like, say, Denarian coins. And Schrodinger would have made a good swap target since he was probably going to die the next night anyways.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  49. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    and ninja'd again. Fuck, I'm bad at this auto-merging stuff. ---------- Post automerged at 10:30 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:30 PM ---------- Goddamnit! I'm just going to stop before I look like more of an idiot.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
  50. coleam
    Post

    The Struggle For Dark Hallow | Everybody (But Kalas) Wins!

    Damn, ninja'd by...everyone. I think you meant Purified. Unless you're actually a Denarian and just slipped up? Cleansing is what the Knights do to Denarians and Fae.
    Post by: coleam, Jan 18, 2012 in forum: Little Italy
Showing results 1 to 50 of 70 Next >
Search Again
Page 1 of 2