1. DLP Flash Christmas Competition + Writing Marathon 2024!

    Competition topic: Magical New Year!

    Marathon goal? Crank out words!

    Check the marathon thread or competition thread for details.

    Dismiss Notice

  2. Hi there, Guest

    Only registered users can really experience what DLP has to offer. Many forums are only accessible if you have an account. Why don't you register?
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Introducing for your Perusing Pleasure

    New Thread Thursday
    +
    Shit Post Sunday

    READ ME
    Dismiss Notice
DLP Story Competition Guest User Registration Nag SPS + NTT

Search Results

Search Again
Page 1 of 2
  1. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Well, great job Fontisian. Hopefully I can do better my next game. Also, why did it take so long to finally get around to lynching Luckylee?
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 21, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  2. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I think you're reading into this a little too much, Font. I used the words to describe you because they are applicable. Exactly - I wasn't attacking you for pushing a lynch with conviction, just pointing out that the fact that you did isn't necessarily a point of towniness. @Proph - I agree with nearly all of your analysis. I would readily be today's lynch, if Vira gets killed tomorrow. Also, it would be better to just regular lynch us, so we can keep Moridin around as a townfirmed hammer...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 16, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  3. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, seeing as I'm going to be traveling all day tomorrow, I thought it would be prudent to get things down now. I don't think Font would be careless enough to try to kill Proph. If she is scum, she would have taken his role into account, checked his reads, and likely as the last one left, decided against it. She's too damn competent to take the risk of killing him. That said, by process of elimination, only Vira is left. I think Font's case on her D3 hit some good points (minus the Bill...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 15, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  4. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Yeah, I was going to start attacking you again, but you made a pretty damn good point about Proph being killed to get a 2 for 1. ---------- Post automerged at 21:53 ---------- Previous post was at 21:52 ---------- Of course, scum could have just hit Proph early, so he would have the maximum number of people to choose from when arranging his DOB kill. ---------- Post automerged at 21:54 ---------- Previous post was at 21:53 ---------- But that also brings into question why they didn't hit...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 14, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  5. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Yeah, but he also told us that lynching Moridin to get that effect should be a point of last resort. ---------- Post automerged at 21:48 ---------- Previous post was at 21:46 ---------- If Zeit's telling the truth (which I am inclined to believe), we have plenty of room to figure things out ourselves.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 14, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  6. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    You have to admit, they were good croissants. And yes, that would be appreciated.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 13, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  7. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Also, to answer your question, I don't think I'm misinterpreting anything. ;) ---------- Post automerged at 00:30 ---------- Previous post was at 00:29 ---------- . . . Low blow, that.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 13, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  8. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Well, I didn't expect it from you, but I had come to think highly of Proph.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 13, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  9. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Um . . . guys, you know we still had over 12 hours from when Proph used his extension. - Originally Posted at 22:03 EST on the 10th. (03:03 Zulu on the 11th) 60 hours from that post comes out to 10:03 EST on the 13th. (15:03 Zulu on the 13th) But since everyone's getting bent out of shape over it: Lynch: Luckylee
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 13, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  10. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    It probably got overshadowed by everything else that happened early D3, like Zeit's roleclaim. How am I doing that? I don't think they would have discussed it because a Luckylee lynch did not look probable going into D3. ---------- Post automerged at 00:31 ---------- Previous post was at 00:29 ---------- Crap, meant to say D4.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  11. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Oh, crap. How did I miss that? And no, I didn't get far enough down the thread to read the other two posts. Nothing would prevent them from adding to the wagon, but they wouldn't do so in a coordinated fashion. They wouldn't all get the same idea (regular lynch Luckylee because he'll survive) independently.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  12. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Because it doesn't tell us anything. If we accept that there was no scum plan to keep Lucky alive, it doesn't discount scum on the vote wagon for normal purposes of distancing. Or there might not be any there at all. As to the second question, they wouldn't be able to coordinate a move like that (ie. Lucky's self-hammer).
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  13. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    No, I hadn't gotten that far. But after reading this, I did take a look at it, and I don't see this interaction mentioned at all.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  14. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Think about it - if you were scum, you would be looking at each and every post that your partner makes, trying to make sure that you don't align yourself with them, or trying to distance yourself from them. A scum player would not simply "confuse" his scummate with someone else, as they would be aware of them at all times.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  15. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I also found these: It reads like Font is making excuses for Luckylee. Additionally, the wording about "the pros and cons of bussing" puts her entire altercation with Luckylee following Zeit's reveal into question. In one sentence, she attacks him, while still casting doubts as to his competence, all without calling him scum.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  16. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    So since the thread was not very active today, I read through most of Days 1 and 2, and found this: I think this might be enough to justify an unaligned pair between Probellum/Blab and Rubicon, as scum would have been overly aware of their teammates. I did. In fact, when Luckylee survived, my first thoughts were "there must be scum on the wagon, laying the foundation for him to survive." But then I remembered that scum don't have daychat, and they probably wouldn't have anticipated this...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  17. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Because having a lynch would give us more information from which to find his remaining scummate(s), such as votals and reactions. Additionally, it confirmed his role.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 12, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  18. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Mainly satisfaction that we were finally going to kill him. We seemed to have reached a consensus, and I had put him down as the judgekill as well, in case we didn't reach majority. 1. Because I'm town. 2. You're looking pretty good right now. I have you down as an unaligned pair with Luckylee, and seeing as he was courteous enough to scumfirm himself, means that despite your reveal antics, you're probably town.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 11, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  19. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    So knowing Luckylee is scum, would he have lied about Bill Door's alignment?
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 11, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  20. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, I put the order down to judgekill Lucky in case something screws up. Vote: Luckylee At this point, I very much doubt that ChocoPi is scum. It would be too much trouble for him to go to the trouble of building an entire lynch case on me, and then refute that very case just to townfirm himself.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 10, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  21. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Probably Vira, because that would work in both a Luckylee or Zeitgeist scum world.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 9, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  22. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    So seeing as the consensus is that I should claim, I will. I am the Town Judge. There was never a day which ended without a majority, so I never used my power. ---------- Post automerged at 11:35 ---------- Previous post was at 11:21 ---------- And in the interests of giving town more information before I am lynched, Readwall: Moridin and Fontisian are both town reads. I've had Moridin there ever since that pregame readwall and the controversy that came with it. Font's attacks on Zeit...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 9, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  23. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I don't know about ChocoPi. He has cemented himself in a leadership position and galvanized the town very quickly, though. His case on me, as misguided as it is, seems sincere. But as for me, I hope you enjoy the taste of hat.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 9, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  24. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    No, that's not what I'm trying to say. I mean that Luckylee isn't aligned with Zeit because of that D3 defense. Right now my assumptions are using one of two possibilities: 1. Zeit is scum. 2. Zeit is not scum. In a scumZeit world, Luckylee would be extremely aware of him, and wouldn't make such an obvious move linking himself with his scummate. However, because of Luckylee's connections with Rubicon, in a world where Zeit is town, he would probably be scum.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 9, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  25. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I haven't been holding him at arm's reach, I was trying to punch him. Perhaps because it was a justifiable reason. I thought I had a good chance of getting him lynched, especially after he racked up four votes Day 1, before the Aekiel lynch was settled upon. Additionally, how was my case a defense of Bill Door? I'm comparing what we both did in the outlined cases: we presented information that was considered "fact" in order to outline thought processes and conclusions for the rest of the...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 8, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  26. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Not quite. It still gives more information, which can be used to look over past behavior and make sense of motivations.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 8, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  27. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I am neither the Dirty old Bastard nor the Benevolent old Dame. If you think a full claim would be good, I will provide one.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 8, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  28. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, concerning the case that has been built on me: I don't see how you could think I would be scum with Luckylee. In fact, I have been attempting to get him lynched for most of the game by now. If anything, I'm probably guilty of confirmation bias, and not readily looking elsewhere. If you're going to call me scum based on “tone,” please tell us what tone you see and how that would make me scum. At the time that was posted, I wasn't under a lot of pressure. I had gone back and forth...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 8, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  29. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I still want to lynch Zeit. Especially now after Sesc was killed, it's obvious that revealing the Archangel card's use did no favors for the town, and he pushed his reveal into giving himself more towncred. I'm feeling better about Luckylee, though, because I don't think that scum would blatantly buddy and defend one another like those two have been.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 7, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  30. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, the gravedigger plan sounds good, but I see one glaring problem. What if the gravedigger role got assigned to a witch? How would we be able to tell?
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 7, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  31. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, after going back through Zeitgeist's post-reveal posts and especially Moridin's comments on him, I can see very little way his reveal could have helped the town, especially if the priest is dead. It does come off as a way to try to get himself towncred for very little risk. If we can't lynch Luckylee, I suppose Zeit would be better than Bill. Vote: Zeitgeist
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  32. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Font: I am much more comfortable lynching Luckylee than Zeitgeist because Zeit hasn't done quite as much linking himself to Rubicon before his death, as well as Luckylee's active defense of Zeit. However, Zeit does look scummier than Bill Door.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  33. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, I can't decide if Luckylee's defense of Zeitgeist reads like a scumteam or not. If they are scum together, why connect themselves like that? What do you think, Font?
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  34. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Luckylee: You forget that the Oracle is notified when there is only one Witch remaining. Zeit's role is far from useless, unless he somehow wouldn't want to reveal that sort of information.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  35. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Um . . . I'm still here, Vira. I wasn't for most of Day 2, but that's because I was preoccupied with outside activities. Sesc already called me out on my indecisive language after the Rubicon/Kalas clusterfuck, and this is how I responded: The reason I was indecisive and "idled" after Rubicon killed Kalas is because it blew my case, reads, and assumptions out of the water as well. At that point, I was scrambling to adjust to new assumptions, and didn't want to close off my thoughts.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  36. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Luckylee: I'm don't know if you somehow missed post #526, where I responded to you. Zeitgeist: How does your roleclaim in any way eliminate you from the "list of suspects," since Oracle is not a holy role?
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 5, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  37. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Luckylee: The reason I am suspicious of you is not for your vote on Rubicon, but for how long it took you to call him out, after he said that he would "compromise" with a lynch on you. You weren't at all concerned with Rubicon actually joining and pushing a lynch on you because as your teammate, you thought he probably wouldn't do that. Additionally, most of my suspicion falls from your unsupported switch of vote from Rubicon to Kalas, whereas you had made no case before that. Also, what...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 4, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  38. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Sesc: I was wrong about a Rubicon/Kalas sucmteam. I know that now. Unfortunately, that doesn't just leave only one option, however glaring that option may be. After reading the last hunt, specifically where Kai claimed judge and was killed for it, I am not going to exclude any possibility from my thoughts, no matter how slight. ---------- Post automerged at 20:17 ---------- Previous post was at 20:08 ---------- Also, Font: I would put Caesar a bit higher because despite his lower...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 4, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  39. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    @Font: Between TyphoVira and Zeitgeist, Zeit is definitely more scummy. However, most of that rests on his associations with Luckylee. Even so, in post #420, he expresses the notion “either Luckylee is innocent or Rubicon is,” before placing a vote on Luckylee. Also in the same post, he is closely tying Luckylee to Kalas, probably to increase Luckylee's town-cred. Further down, he says that “[Luckylee's] brand of logical fallacy is something that you'd find with potential witches or holy...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 4, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  40. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    @Font (since the question about her readwall was addressed to everyone) For the most part, I agree with your wall. However, I would have flipped Caesar and Probellum, as well as Moridin and Bill Door. I'm curious - what led you to rank Moridin so lowly? Also, concerning summarization, I don't see any reason why explaining my thoughts and assumptions would be a bad thing. I will also look at Vira and Zeit.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 4, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  41. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, so that blew the Rubicon/Kalas scumteam theory completely out of the water, and given the way in which Rubicon used his ability not just to control the lynch, but also to end discussion, leads me to tentatively assume that he is scum. So under these assumptions, Sesc is most likely town, since Kalas wouldn't have lied if he were the priest. Luckylee, however, looks bad. His initial D2 vote was for Rubicon: This came ten posts after this: However, during that ten-post time...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 3, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  42. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok guys, just letting you know that I'll be out for oral surgery for the first part of Day 3. Should be posting by tomorrow afternoon US East Coast.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 3, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  43. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I am aware of that. I am looking back through the thread to find more evidence of Rubicon/Kalas complicity, and I would like to vote for one of them. Since there's nearly no one on Rubicon ATM, Lynch Vote: Kalas More evidence to follow. ---------- Post automerged at 01:46 ---------- Previous post was at 01:28 ---------- The first part of Rubicon's case vs. Kalas concerns the questionwall which was prompted by Stojil. However, I followed this line of questioning with Kalas and brought it...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 1, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  44. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    The tone of Kalas's #434 pushes me to think that he's attempting to come off as “outraged” in order to play off of Rubicon's “carefree” attitudes from posts such as this one: Additionally, their near complete focus on one another makes me believe the two of them could possibly be attempting to lead wagons on the other, thus showing everyone else the strength of their “conviction” if one of them eventually ends up being lynched. As for Luckylee, most of my suspicion is residual from Day 1,...
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 1, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  45. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    P { margin-bottom: 0.08in; } Ok, so looking back through the thread, this is what I have. Zeitgeist has not answered the question I posed to him near the beginning of the Day: However, I was not around to follow up on it, and he has answered a lot of others which were posed to him (albeit in a tone which strikes me as odd). I would still like an answer, though. There is at least one scum in Rubicon/Kalas, though I agree with Font: both of them is a distinct possibility....
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 1, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  46. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, I'm back and reading through the thread. Shouldn't have left it this long. Will post things shortly.
    Post by: Dermon, Jan 1, 2014 in forum: Little Italy
  47. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Ok, that escalated quickly. Zeit: What was your original rationale behind voting for Aekiel? Also, if you were watching the thread between then and his lynch, how did his subsequent posting affect your thoughts? Or were you just not watching the thread?
    Post by: Dermon, Dec 28, 2013 in forum: Little Italy
  48. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    Stojil surviving does not mean that Aekiel was town, Luckylee. There are enough roles which grant survival that it cannot be reasonably assumed. Stojil surviving says nothing except that scum attempted to kill him.
    Post by: Dermon, Dec 26, 2013 in forum: Little Italy
  49. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    In response to your question, Luckylee, right now my second highest scumread (discounting the lurkers) is Aekiel, for hypocritical posting, switching votes without explanation or justifications, and using roles in order to keep himself from contributing. And even though I would like very much to lynch you today, I doubt that we are going to get another extention. Therefore: Vote: Aekiel
    Post by: Dermon, Dec 22, 2013 in forum: Little Italy
  50. Dermon
    Post

    ~/* Witchhunt Game 3 *\~ (DRAW)

    I don't like how much Aekiel has been talking about roles. In fact, I think that that reaction from Luckylee was exactly what he was trying to illicit from the above post, allowing him to remain comfortably silent where Zeitgeist is concerned. I will pose the same challenge to Luckylee, as even since being prodded (in the form of three votes) the little content he has contributed looks like a half-assed attempt to justify his actions. However, he still has a point in this post. It...
    Post by: Dermon, Dec 22, 2013 in forum: Little Italy
Showing results 1 to 50 of 64 Next >
Search Again
Page 1 of 2