View Full Version : [Oneshot] Desires of a Hallow by Zenzao - T
11-28-2011, 11:00 PM
Title: Desires of a Hallow
Published: January 15, 2011
Library Category: Dark Arts/Alternatives.
Summary: There is an allure, a seductive gulf and destructive nature entwined about the wand, the stone, the cloak. It is an corruption that bleeds through them and taints all before their path. For James Potter, the will to overcome that corruption may be to much
Link: FFN (http://www.fanfiction.net/s/6655657/1/Desires_of_a_Hallow)
Stupid? Yessir, yes'm, going against the grain and contributing my own story for review.
Reason? It's done. I'm never going to turn this into a lengthy, multi-chapter story, or even really expand upon it any further than I did just about fifteen minutes ago with some quick corrections.
I wrote this back around the time that January was supposed to have been the Dark Arts contest, as memory serves, and it received pretty positive feedback in WBA, so here we are.
Have at it, and thanks for reading.
Checked by Minion, Nov. 25, 2012
I liked it when you wrote it and I still like it now. I can't say that for a lot of fics that I read 10 months ago.
11-29-2011, 07:42 AM
I like this and wouldn't mind seeing it expanded.
11-30-2011, 02:12 AM
I liked it, though I noticed that you had James as a seeker, when he was actually a chaser.
11-30-2011, 12:16 PM
I don't know, something seems lacking.
The idea about the allure is newish (there was something about it, but I haven't seen much of it, so there - an original idea.) The taint of powerful objects however is older than radio (probably not ;D) but it's done kind of correctly.
The best part was the ending, where James speaks to his heir, signifying the inheritance of both power and drawbacks.
The other stuff, I don't know, it feels slightly too short. There is also something that I feel is lacking for me to like it. It's good, I understand that the writing is solid, the idea has a start and a finish, but it still doesn't work for me. I don't know why. It's slightly maddening, even. Was it the too simple way of Lily falling into the flames? Was it the forgotten possible challenge of the Gaunt Ring's hidden soul?
It should have been a page longer and maybe it would have more impact. Then, perhaps not, sometimes less is better. Usually less is better.
So, I don't know. 3/5?
Maybe I'll vote after I think about it again.
11-30-2011, 03:13 PM
I'll say like Naura, there is something lacking. Maybe it's the lack of details of how James acquired the ring or the wand. Maybe it's how the Lily's death happened. I'll give it a 3/5 because of the original idea and of the decent writing, but it needs more to reach 4+
12-01-2011, 09:44 PM
Even though the writing was excellent and there were no grammatical mistakes, I felt as if something was missing as well.
Although the fight between Dumbledore and James seemed entirely too difficult to believe. Dumbledore not being able to defeat a wandless James, despite having time to cast four spells, which ended up being pretty much forth year spells at that and no awesome shit at all? Come on dude, when have you read a Dumbledore scene in the books where he casts a spell and its not awesome or at least mysterious?
Yet, that's not what bothered me the most.
What did was the fact that you only tell us of the change in James' character and explain that it was slow and gradual, but you do not really show it. We don't even get to see the beginning of this metamorphosis, and instead we're immediately thrust near its very end, show casting the final product. Thus, the Hallows' seduction doesn't deliver any emotional impact, seeing as we don't even have a comparison between Normal!James and HallowsCrazy!James. And lacking that emotional impact renders your one-shot almost meaningless.
So, -1 for the lack of epic!Dumbledore, -1 for the lack of character transformation, but +1 for your writing style, which I very much like. So all in all, I think a solid 4/5.
Cheers and keep writing.
12-04-2011, 02:04 AM
I really like Master of Death stories, and this is one of them. As a oneshot, it's good, but if you ever change you mind and expend upon it, then it could be something of epic propertion.
Seriously, you should definitely make it novel-lenght. I would fanboy the shit out of it. :awesome
On a completely unrelated note, Teresoul, when are going to update Principia Princeps? It was going so well... :(
12-08-2011, 09:48 AM
I didn't find it particularly enjoyable, nor gripping in any way. Not library worthy.
vBulletin® v3.8.9, Copyright ©2000-2015, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.