1. Another story competition is beginning! (Q1 2018)

    "You're bleeding on my floor."

    We've moved to a quarterly format, so you really have no excuse not to participate this time.

    So check out the new thread discussing scoring, rules, and other such matters in the in the Story Competitions forum and get cracking.

    Dismiss Notice

Harry/Hermione without bashing and other annoying tropes

Discussion in 'Story Search' started by Stan, Jun 17, 2015.

  1. Sesc

    Sesc Slytherin at Heart Moderator

    Dec 20, 2007
    Hbg., Germany
    brad: I just deleted lots of words when I realised I had written way too much in response.

    The TL;DR is that you are wrong (on an objective account), but it's useless trying convince shippers (and especially H/Hr shippers). Feel free to consider Ginny and Harry "nasty" and Hermione the most perfect being to ever walk the earth, just don't bother other people with it.

    And this includes posting in this thread, which is a story search thread, not the millionth shipping thread.
  2. Atomicwalrus

    Atomicwalrus Fourth Year

    Mar 20, 2011
    How about we just go back to nominating cool fics instead of having a pointless shipper bitch?

    I rec Midnight Blues. The story is hardly a romance but Harry and Hermione's relationship is interesting. There are some nice interactions between the two and while it hasn't happened yet I expect the two to bang by the end of the fic.

  3. Astaphta

    Astaphta First Year DLP Supporter

    Aug 22, 2015
    The Continent
    Wow, this discussion wandered impressively off topic. Not entirely sure that one is allowed to "revive" such a completely shot thread as this, but, hoping against hope that some people might still have a few actual recommendations to make, let me put forward a few of my own. First off, let's all agree that writers such as robst, canoncansodoff and chem prof belong firmly back in the 2000s, along with Lynney, Gabilian, schlamboozle, Full Pensieve and madscientist (enjoyable in a nostalgically portkey-ish sort of way though these last may be) and are, besides, full of formulaic and derivative rubbish. Good H/Hr is an absolutely rare narcotic and must be savored; let's please everyone from now on refrain from posting such vulgar recommendations.

    I don't care so much about plot when reading about Harry and Hermione; what's important to me is the prose, the atmosphere and the respect paid to their respective characters. In that spirit, here are the very few I would unequivocally urge you all to read:

    -Stanrick is an absolute joy to read, his most enjoyable stuff probably being Thresholds and Hearts on Detour. He's a florid and extravagant writer, whose characters sound more like books than like people, so no points for realism, and his characters are a little too mature for their age, but sometimes it's nice to read about people who allegedly think a lot from someone who actually does appear to think a lot. Geniuses written by nitwits and trolls are somehow off-putting.

    -Potato19, also thoroughly enjoyable though her plots oftentimes stretch the limits of credulity: particularly liked the WIP called I'm Not the Only One, but she's written a whole stock of good stuff

    -Taliesin19 and her A Memoir, written as a sort of companion to canon from Hermione's point of view. It's comparable to Annerb's A Changeling, in that canon is strictly respected but you never one have the slightest feeling of canon-rehash: it's so well thought-out and planned-out that it just fleshes canon out in an incredibly satisfying way. unfortunately it was abandoned just as it was running out of canon, which is a bit of a pity. Not really romance either, I should point out, now that I think of it. Or at least not yet.

    -Lorien829, actually of portkey, but she writes really well and, though Hermione is often thrust centre-stage to the detriment of Harry, her stories are all very well-paced and -plotted. This is older stuff.

    -Obsidian Warlock's The Meaning of Father, which is totally un-DLP in that it features a clearly super-powered Hermione, but also a uniquely mesmerising relationship between the two, which I haven't seen elsewere. Should warn that it goes completely off the reservation at the end though. Also less recent than the first three.