Isn't it fun?

 

I am also going to eat Regfan, thanks.

Unvote

---------- Post automerged at 09:07 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:05 AM ----------

The deepwolf comment about me is kind of interesting and I think it might be town but it might just point to a team comp.

 

I thought sheep weren't carnivorous?

 

I swear, Regfan, are you just misunderstanding or misrepresenting me?

I came into this dayphase thinking 5 scum (with daychat) was too much and with only 2 scumreads (miner, Regfan). Furthermore miner<->Regfan is probably not a thing (well it might be a thing now from Regfan->miner with the way Regfan is pushing against the miner-lynch toDay, despite it resolving his reads same as any other lynch, but what is miner doing since basically D2? Only distancing from Reg?)
So yeah I consider 4 scum more likely, and if it is 4 scum Regfan is just much more likely, also because he is actually doing something to win in this case, miner isn't.

But I am NOT 100% sure, Regfan's quoted Newcomb post has Newcomb saying daychat is worth near an entire scumteam member so it could be 5, so yeah, maybe it is 5 scum, doesn't fit with my reads as much, but it's the careful thing to do anyway.

Meanwhile Regfan is totally sure it's definitely 5 scum without daychat, because *reasons* (I had originally written here "because he needs to scumread dC", but I finally skimmed dC's D3/D4 content and can sorta see where he's coming from, and also since I am considering miner+x cases and miner+dC is on top of them, I would be kinda hypocritical, too)

So yeah, I am FOSing solo!scum Reg, but willing to resolve miner first, because miner teams are just so much more likely:

miner/dC > Reg/dC (see Reg => dC toDay)
miner/Fable > Reg/Fable (same)
miner/pienyan > Reg/pienyan (Reg/pienyan is just lol)
Stanari is a wash maybe, Vaimes is basically mechanically confirmed town.

---------- Post automerged at 11:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:16 AM ----------

And, yeah, I am kinda being a lazy fuck and avoiding doing a full dC reread (so long....), it's just, I have already suggested a lynchtree that would defeat all of the following:
solo!miner
solo!Reg
solo!blab
blab/dC
miner/dC
miner/Fable

so, I am not sure what Reg is doing here.

 

Okay I laughed but please remind me who I am sheeping here cos I seem to have forgotten.

 

Nobody knows what Reg is doing, despite him going into nitty-gritty detail about everything he's thinking?

Man.

 

I mean they are can eat meat if they have the opportunity.

 

Wait correct me if I'm wrong but as long as we can clear one person in blab/Reg/Miner/dC don't we always win?

 

If you're assuming that Stanari is town then sure.

 

Yes.

Even if there are two mafia left, correctly clearing one person guarantees we can lynch the other three.

Losing to Stanari would be >_> but I can't really justify lynching her beyond that. She's done what she's done and based on scum interactions it's best to just let it go.

 

Who do you think looks the most clear then out of that group?

 

Fables post about me is pretty fucking awful and super misrepresenting of what I've actually done today and what um staging, the fact he's gone that approach instead if explaining his Blab town read which uve consistently asked him for is pretty uh, not great.

Blab similarly agreeing with logic saying 5 scum but only having 1 team of 2 and not thinking that may mean he's wrong somewhere us similarly pretty hard to fathom.

---------- Post automerged at 04:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:58 PM ----------

Hope you realise this is just being said by the person I'm voting and the person I'm trying to state think had a chance I'd being mafia that everyone else is town reading.

 

Torn between dC and blab.

Right now I get the feeling that blab is being made to look bad rather than being bad, and I don't feel great about lynching there first anymore. Even if it is a 50/50 fmpov. Eh.

blab/dC
blab/Miner
blab/Reg
Miner/Reg
dC/Miner
dC/Reg

Reg/dC doesn't really work because Reg went from pushing a mislynch (Miner) to his buddy (dC) when he could have easily hammered the Miner lynch home. Possssible he thought he'd get too much flak for Miner flipping town and it'd end up a 1v1, and moved to dC a bit to distance and look for a lynch elsewhere (blab). Feels too convoluted, and they've been interacting mostly with each other toDay, so if this is scum theatre then oops, ya got me.

blab/dC
blab/Miner
blab/Reg
Miner/Reg
dC/Miner

So obviously, the best thing to do here is to lynch blab or Miner. They each clear three worlds.

Town!Miner > scumteam is blab/dC or blab/Reg > lynch blab > ??? > good luck in F3.
Town!blab > scumteam is Miner/Reg or Miner/dC > lynch Miner > ??? good luck in F3.

Vote Miner

---------- Post automerged at 17:03 ---------- Previous post was at 17:02 ----------

I'm pretty sure nobody has been following a lot of your logic or explanations, except maybe dC.

Let's lynch Miner. We might hit scum, and if we don't, it'll tilt font as a bonus.

 

Miner [3]: Blab, Pienyan, Vaimes.
Blab [2]: Reg, DC.
DC [1]: Fable.
Reg [1]: Miner.

Not Voting [1]: Stanari.


I can't justify staying up all night for this, so in case I get lynched:
Shockingly you will be exactly where I am toDay, in that any probable scumteam of 2 includes miner.
Lynch him, if he flips town and the game goes on lynch Regfan.
If he flips scum, and we haven't won, you're probably going to decide between dC and Regfan, I lean dC right now, but you'll have more interaction until then and nobody will remember this post anyway, so whatever.

Night

 

I don't disagree that lynching Blab/Miner hits 1 scum, I think it hits just the 1 though in that a Blab!Mafia Lynch clears Miner and a Miner!Mafia Lynch clears Blab. Inside the two I think I'd call Blab the more likely hit? And hitting today is pretty crucial, I don't think we come back from a miss here.

Also um, Pie might scum read me but pretty sure she'll vouch that she can at least understand my play today too?

 

RWBY Mafia Votal 5.6.

Miner [3]: Blab, Pienyan, Vaimes.
Blab [2]: Reg, DC.
DC [1]: Fable.
Reg [1]: Miner.

Not Voting [1]: Stanari.

With 8 votes alive, it will be 5 votes to soft lynch and 6 votes to hard lynch.

 

Okay so Fable, I've brought up why I don't understand your confidence level in Miner/DC over Blab/DC, I've explained how we are reading Blabs posting today very differently. I've asked you to explain said read, you said you would. Then just... Never did and have moved to "icsnt understand Regfan today" like uh?

 

No reg what's fucking awful is you shading me all of a sudden just because I don't agree with you on blab.

 

Vaimes at least read the following posts and put yourself in my shoes for just 2 minutes. Fable has a very strong town read on me coming into today, everyone else in the game scum reads me, Fable is doing or did what? to convince people they were wrong? He makes a post stating I'm only with Blab, then doesn't comment on me again until I prod him about why he's not doing so where he goes he would if people were pushing me...but they are? and him not realsing 6 of 6 other people were scum reading me feels impossible? it's a pretty huge miss of the game state and then when I bring him up he starts reversing his read on me?

Like stop and think from where I am. How does this match how Fable has treated his prior reads throughout the game? How does this match what he's trying to get across? How does his flip on me work when it's based on me pushing Blab and him saying I can only be with Blab?

---------- Post automerged at 04:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:35 PM ----------

Like level with me here, this looks AWFUL from where I'm sitting and what I know to be true.

---------- Post automerged at 04:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:37 PM ----------

He has spent significantly more time defending Blab than myself and he supposedly had a stronger town read on me then Blab and thinks I can only be scum with Blab.

Like WHAT

---------- Post automerged at 04:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:38 PM ----------

Like I'm left in a position where I'm looking at this and thinking is he trying to make himself look obviously aligned with Blab so that we mslynch there or is he actually mafia with Blab and knows he can't take this down to a F3 and guarantee a win with how the reads are turning so he's going for the win in his Miner push and reversing his read on me to have the game winning lylo mslynch? Like how the fuck am I meant to assess this.

---------- Post automerged at 04:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:39 PM ----------

Pleas please please please actually read that post in it's entirely Vaimes.

 

Reg I've said all fucking day I think it's probably miner/dC so please point to the part where I said "let's lynch reg" because you're just making shit up atm. And yes I'm getting annoyed because you shading me out of fucking nowhere doesn't make any sense.