Ok, I'll read (instead of skim ) the wall posts just because I envy you for having the time to write so much.

Post #341:

What do you mean exactly here? Why does this suggest an anti-align?

Regarding the shade-y section, you wrote a lot of words saying which posts you count as shade, but I don't really understand what your conclusion is from all of them. You and Rubicon throwing shade is ok? But fluff/kai aren't? I don't understand how your conclusions follow from the previous section.


Post #348:
There's a lot of talking about stuff for the sake of talking about them so far. It's nice to have written out his opinions on basically everything he considers important so far, but stuff that he ends up deciding is NAI for example kinda just feel like padding to me.

Can you possibly explain why you've put kai as your scummiest read? I realise a lot of people disagree with you partly based on meta but what exactly are the "sketch" things he's done?

Need to actually go home and eat and sleep and stuff now, so will check back in ~12 hours when I wake up. Maybe before if I feel like phone posting.

TL,DR reads so far (no particular order):
Town: dC, owner, Rubicon, Vaimes? (need to go hunt down that game I was talking about to check for sure)

Scum: Jari, miner, tom

People I should probably have an opinion on already but don't yet: dyachei, Fable (not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing yet)

Everyone else is null.

---------- Post automerged at 07:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:03 PM ----------

Actually thinking about it, I think Beru and kai should probably be in the third category too.

 

Jokes on you, it's my birthday today so I /totally/ can't be lynched

But real talk I'm actually looking forward to dying one way or another because I'm really curious about my secret pokemon identity

---------- Post automerged at 01:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:08 PM ----------

Why do you think that and/or I look awful?

 

Happy birthday Citrus!

---------- Post automerged at 20:36 ---------- Previous post was at 20:35 ----------

Sux for you that your birthday wil have come and gone by the time day end.

 

Just FYI I start a new job today so I'll be around more later tonight.
dyachei could you answer my thing thanks:

Berurutolto:

I forget if you've actually even played with DC since mafia history's started blending together but he's self-admittedly /bad/ at shiposting. How's that affect your read?

---------- Post automerged at 02:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:57 PM ----------

Weiyaoli:

Can you explain more why you think this makes him town?

 

Thanks! It's probably for the best that it doesn't in all honesty heh

 

1) I guess if you weren't expecting jokes it would be easy for you to fall down that rabbit hole, but it`s just the usual jokes to me...

2) It's amusing that after I posted my post about him not posting any posts, Jari made an actual effortpost. One (1) effortpost. Very nice.

3) I'm evaluating this less on "what scum!dC is like" and more on "the proper thing to do as a witch". He`s actually trying when he could be coasting and nobody would care, so that means he`s town.

 

Okay for real have you actually played with him before? <-Not snark.

 

Fable is null currently and I have no idea what to do with rubicon yet.


Citrus - your pressure vote was announced, which I find not great. Your vote on me as a null when you have a scum read also doesn't seem great. Seems like a wolf trying to get someone lynched.

 

I resent this accusation! I haven't ever put effort into things all my life sir!

 

It's a different and much less smooth opening than Vaimes' usually has as town. I think this is an area he struggles with as scum.

 

Yeeeeees...........

You guys are conflating shitposting with low effort content, imo.

 

True, though it was announced because I was specifically asked about it (and I didn't want to end up down a rabbit hole of 'Im not explaining right now' 'he wont explain it' as has wasted multiple people's lives with me before).

What do you mean by a wolf trying to get someone lynched? I don't actually see your logic below a surface-level. You're saying that you think that:
A) I profess that Tom is a scum-read
B) I profess that you are a null-read
C) I am explicitly choosing to vote you
D) I have subsequently declared this vote to be a pressure vote

And thus that I'm trying to get someone (presumably you in this situation) lynched? What about my posts is 'trying to get someone lynched'?

Also, what's your level of mafia experience?

 

I have been playing for years on different sites - forum mafia for ~8 years. The thing is, there are enough people here that could say "you know what? I don't know this new person and they are null. Let's lynch them!" and get me lynched. It was very low effort and easy for people to vote. That's what made it appear that way.

 

Does anyone else feel like tom claimed way too easily?

 

He's claimed like 4 roles.

 

Wait I only saw ranger lol.

 

ISO him. He's claimed a lot of roles.

 

Hmm, I actually had the impression you were new to mafia in general. What do you know about mafia games on DLP, in terms of the level and style of play and such?

 

I was told to expect wallposts. I don't know all your specific terminology here so maybe that gave you the impression? Also this is my first witch hunt game.

 

Oh good he's decided to make reading him a nightmare (read:tom is being tom).