Why the strong townread on DC?

 

Also Tom is dead. Acio has been replaced. If I'm at the bottom why isn't your vote on me?

Like if you are really trying to convey your reads, you aren't matching your actions with your words.

Could you tell me more about your beru and dc reads?

 

To be fair, I did raise this as the reason I bumped you down my townreads back when I did that. It was kinda buried in a bunch of stuff though, I think.

---------- Post automerged at 12:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:49 PM ----------

...also hilariously dyachei is more town than Vaimes himself which seems questionable :V

 

I can't really fathom any reason for Fable to have claimed when he did as scum.

 

I know one reason.

 

Fair to whom?

Yes, that I can agree with.

 

What's that?

 

I still missed the claim wherever it is.

 

The thread-state at large?

 

owner,

This post.

 

Or agent, I guess.

---------- Post automerged at 07:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:55 PM ----------

By the way, we never did reach a consensus about whether or not Rubi should reveal Tom's role.

 

Really? You're griping about tom and Acio? Red is for confirmed mafia, switch mal's name where Acio should be. Easy.

The orange tier isn't really organized. You should probably be yellow, but oh well.

beruru is a townread, and I think dC is town for the swing onto tom.

 

Also also also also, if someone could actually super fill me in on Fable/Jari meta? Seriously please do it, it's something I need to know.

 

If tom was an Elder, is there any way revealing helps witches?

 

...Maybe, beru. But if the claim was calculated for that purpose, it should really have come later?

 

Citrus: I've decided to talk about the thing I'm not sure holding on to my theory is the right play when people might be building worlds based on [Beru N/K/A/W tom] + [Beru not a LW or Agent] There ~should be~ enough wine in the following that it doesn't give them any additional information.

Hypothetically speaking, if an agent says "I do not have communications with (non-LW person)" and a Little Witch says "I think Agent is an agent" that signals to the Elder Witches that the Little Witch is a Little Witch.

Conversely, a Little Witch might say "I do not have communications with (non-LW person)" to signal to the EW that they think (non-LW person) is an agent and an actual agent who knows they are wrong could say "I think Little Witch is an agent" to make the Elder Witches *think* the first thing happened and get them to recruit the agent.

There's also variations like, the hypothetical players are actually Little Witches and/or Agents together who arranged the events on purpose to make sure one of them gets recruited over the other team (mad props if so), or a chance that what you said first was right and the second person isn't even on the list.

-------------

Rubicon: I haven't really looked at fluff / Kai yet, to be honest. I wouldn't be upset if the lynch landed on one of them but right now I'm trying to decide if I reeally think there's definitely scum in Fable/Citrus because I don't think I do anymore.

-------------

Unvote

I would lynch Beru.

I would lynch MalThug even though immediately lynching replacements is shitty... But I think the Acio slot is probably scum.

I could probably be persuaded to lynch Fable, but I'm not sure I really think he's scum anymore.

I don't think I want to lynch Citrus anymore.

I could be persuaded to lynch in [Cobalt / fluff / Kai] but I don't really have strong feelings about any of them yet.

-------------

Going to go read Kai and fluff, then put my vote back.

@ me if you want me specifically for something.

 

...huh.

LW claiming lets Elders know that role is gone if the LW flips, which is particularly good for Zealot since that role is part of the halftime blowout (so revealing lets elders now not to bother Zealot hunting and possibly that holy claims are a little safer than they were). On top of this Agent claiming lets Conspirator know player is an Agent which is risky b/c Conspirator might be scum, which means Agent!Fable probably WOULDN'T claim.

 

One role won't magically make JWs PoE all roles. I guess if Tom's role was important, we should know? Earlier I was thinking about posting a post where we sort roles into boxes or whatever and then Rubi picks a box but that's too... weird and unhelpful. Idk.

Wasn't Fable about to go afk or whatever? He might have been like "shit guys, i'm important for coven. keep me alive. peace" or something.

 

True.

What is your interest in Tom's role?

 

So I guess I'm gonna be trying to reread the whole thread to see where that puts my reads.

I'm not sure how I feel about Fable's claim. I don't know what to make of his recent thought to lynch someone other than mal.

I might be thinking about moving Vaimes null over scum read.

Dc, I'll probably be looking into some of his stuff. But he might make it over to nulls as well. We will see.