Let's see. This was in reference to Vaimes, his fluffiness and Jarizok answering dyachei's "what is the oracle role" question.

Not sure if there is anything alignment indicative here.

I guess I'm wondering if he would be more like to bring up words like town cred more as scum or as town. But yeah, that probably wouldn't be the easiest thing to figure out at this point.

 

It says like zero about silver's alignment but I agree with almost all of this, fwiw.

---------- Post automerged at 11:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:20 PM ----------

Off the cuff and perhaps mistakenly drawing a line between this and his RWBY mafia QT but this feels like town!dC. Ish? Need more than just this data point I think.

 

I guess the only problem that I might still have with you off the top of my head would revolve around how you are constantly talking about the dynamic of agents and little witches.

Or I guess I'm not overly use to people talking so much in detail about mechanics that I can't necessarily always follow where they are going with all that they mention or say about mechanics and the roles in play.

 

Man the fact that Mal was widely scumread before I jumped on him I feel super mixed about.

On the one hand, at least that's a lynch that can almost certainly happen.

On the other, bleh consensus. If Mal's a witch here, I get some major postgame cred for getting him off like 3 posts like 30 minutes after I replaced in.

Anyone townreading Mal, by the way?

Because there's also the "well this is a little /too/ consensus-y" thing and absent Mal being around and Doing Things to make me revise my read on him, I'd settle for someone defending him to add something to the stew here.

 

Fluff's concern is so of fake here, but it is still early, when this was posted.

 

Vaimes and Citrus have basically done zilch since I replaced in but this also reminded me that that fact in and of itself is kind of unusual.

 

Why I asked you about Fable last night was having to do with this post; I felt like you might be more in favor of lynching Fable because he claimed something you didn't list. But what do I know?

 

With Rubicon, whenever he posts about things that aren't me I'm like 'wow this is Rubicon as town!'. And then he posts about me and accuses me of not being spicy enough or missing my essential essence (my phrasing, to be clear) and I'm like what is this even?

I'm just going to ask you straight up: Are you sure you actually know what you're doing here? You've never not been a Witch in games with me so this is new territory for you - I think you ought to rethink your assumptions here.

(My pet tinfoil world is that Rubicon is a witch and he thinks it'd be the toppest kek to mislynch me)

 

Gonna need you to explain that one for us kids in the cheap seats.

 

I mean, Elders already knew 'em and I'm not sure that the -EV of potentially informing the LW who the Agents are is worse than the +EV of potentially informing the Agents who the LW are and/or informing the town of one of the groups.

Also hang on. You had a townread on owner through the lurking and you're just dropping it NOW?

It's kind of a necessity to actually catch two of the scum, you know :V

 

The problem is that if you do that and go "well bussing is a thing" you're kind of missing the step where you actually look at those two people and consider the v/w permutations and get a chance to actually re-evaluate your reads but that's neither here nor there.

Like, this entire game is about either confirming, or getting snapped out of the narrative that you're slowly building in your head, and realizing you're voting with someone you're calling a wolf is a pretty big opportunity to do the latter.

 

Owner falling off could be anything. Owner going back to WH8 style random posting is scummie. One following the other is a bit ???, but with Owner, ??? /is/ scummie.

 

Why? 10 char

 

Hum.

What's your most recent wolf game, Citrus?

 

Well, you know you.

A random claim in and of itself doesn't have to be witch play, but it is (and was) -ev town play.

Like, there's certainly /reasons/ to claim there as a witch and if Fable thought he was very likely to get lynched there then it's easier to see. Without knowing Fables assessment it's a NAI thing that's bad for town (and asking is just wine).

 

Yep, the mystery is kind of nice sometimes. Other times, it is less welcome.

 

It's late, you might have already said it recently, but Mal and who else?

 

HPmafia! Shudda read the 1st page.

 

Since people are around now: Thoughts?

 

But why would I try to lynch a potential teammate if that were ever ever a case?

---------- Post automerged at 02:42 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:41 AM ----------

It's kind of funny how dead the thread was until I showed up.

But I'm probably the only one laughing though.

---------- Post automerged at 02:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:42 AM ----------

Technically though, we need to catch more than two scum. Or do you have a different agenda in mind?