Meant talk me through coven thoughts mb

 

I'm not going to claim/not claim unless there's a consensus for me to do so.

But if you're actually town, you need to totally re-evaluate the game, because your current world is just incorrect.

 

Town or I will eat one hat shaped chocolate,
can't be Coven because Tom unless Planned Bus Coven,
If Wei is Coven then Fable can be Town unless Wei was setting himself up to lynch a JW over him which is... really bad play imo?,
can't be Coven because Tom unless Planned Bus Coven,
probably Coven due to everyone else not being Coven,
I don't think he's Coven,
not Coven,
because of everyone else not being Coven, the PoE brigade is here.

I mean, you could suggest X/X/Tom coven with Jari/Wei LWs.

... but I don't think we're living in that world. It wouldn't make sense.

---------- Post automerged at 03:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:29 PM ----------

Current Votal, Beru Finally Figured Out How To Put Deaths In The Machine Edition:

his fluffiness (1): newcomb (#3761)
kaiDASH (2): vaimes (#3718), fable (#3726)
citrus (2): dichotomousCreator (#3720), his fluffiness (#3779)
fable (2): kaiDASH (#3736), weiyaoli (#3763)

Abstaining (1): beruru (#3716), citrus (#3716), owner (#3716)

6/8?

 

Things like what you've been doing basically all game are why I'm SKEPTICAL about you.

Like, you're town... I'm almost sure of that. but we aren't getting TOP QUALITY BERU this game. I guess you're out of practice or something.

 

Claim not assassin.

Am I helping?

 

I haven't played in two years. It's been a bit scattershot as I remember my memories. Give me a while to warm up, lmao.

---------- Post automerged at 04:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:58 PM ----------

(shoutouts to KC Green, who is probably the funniest person on the internet.)

---------- Post automerged at 04:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:02 PM ----------

It worked in image preview! Whyyyy.

(it's the I Guess panel from that too many cats strip in Gunshow.)

 

Ok so problems in your view/valuation:

There's no reason to think that Wei -> Fable isn't an intentional hard bus / anti-align. Like, Witch Hunter leaves Fable alive basically 100% regardless of Fable's alignment. Then Wei is still committed to lynching Fable based on previous days, he can't really just say "well I guess we don't kill fable now lul".

Even with no assassin, there's no reason to not lynch Wei if we think he's the last Coven: There's only benefits really. We stop transfer of info from Coven to LW, LW are now able to be Priest checked (lul demons) and the game will end when we kill all the Witches. That's a big one, because otherwise we'd be effectively lynching blind with just a plan to lynch wei 'after'. Also it sucks to keep someone alive to lynch them literally last.

I don't think hard-alignment for Wei / Jari is that likely: Wei instantly knew what I was talking about yesterday and Jari didn't do it.

I think you're right that IK was used N2, but it's like 90% used, 10% not used. Ruling it out completely and going on autopilot later is a good way to jump off a cliff.

 

I don't want LWs to join the Coven.

 

They're going to do it at halftime??

Like given your current world we've killed 2 elders and 0 LW. We'd have to lynch LW today and tomorrow to actually prevent the join.

And if we lynch any of the +kill roles we're doing it today anyway.

 

... I mean, that's why I wanted town!Assassin to assassinate Wei.

And then we lynch a LW?

Then.... ? I mean, one joining coven is okay, I guess.... hm.

... I mean, this is assuming a specific thing.

 

I'm really not sure what the issue is.

Like if we lynch Wei and it's a forced join tonight because all elders are dead, what is the problem?

---------- Post automerged at 10:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:15 AM ----------

Just made this for myself, it's current livelist and gamelog.

Beruru
Citrus
Newcomb (Cobalt)
dichotomousCreator
Fable
his fluffiness
KaiDASH
Owner
Vaimes
Wei

-

D1 Lynch: Tom
N1 Kill: dyachei

D2 Lynch: mallorean_thug (Acionyx)
N2 Kill: Rubicon

D3 Lynch: Jarizok
N3 Kills: Silver (jwlk) + Miner

 

How many of Mal, Jarizok, Silver, Miner need to be witches for us to be in a relatively good spot?
Vaimes

---------- Post automerged at 06:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:14 PM ----------
Fable are you still thinking Vaimes is a witch here? Still not seeing the case on him.

---------- Post automerged at 06:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:26 PM ----------

I think there has to be one, at least, in dC/Kai/Citrus but it's pretty damn muddy in that group.

 

I lock cleared Vaimes near EoD yesterday?

 

Right, your EoD burst thing. Short reason why?

 

For reasons probably related to why miner and silver were killed.

This probably clears beruru too.

 

You're gonna have to explain that one to the class.

 

It's amazing, I know what Fable is saying without him having to actually say it.

Magical.

 

You're a witch.

 

Thanks, Fable.

 

Yeah.

...

Wei lacks something that everyone else has... is a probably a better way to write what I've been trying to say.