Seems like the heart of Fable's dya defense.

@Vaimes what do you make of this, as someone who deals with a pretty heavy meta expectation in games?

@Fable I'm not sure I understand the first bolded, tbh. Could you unpack it for me?

 

Also with the highest chance of also allowing a reevaluation if it's wrong.

 

Hum.

I guess, then, I have to ask you, what do you think the chances are that Cuth/Shadow are v/v this game?

 

Like if you really need me to explain more I can do it tomorrow but I'm working past the deadline tonight so I can't do it right now.
--- Post automerged ---
Like real quick I feel like she would have TMI'd yeti super hard if wolf.

 

Pretty low. Or rather, that means we majorly screwed up, and I don't see a ton of indications of that.

Also like. I'm still living in Cuth Tunnel Land right now.

 

Ehhhh.

Vote: Cuth

Still feels like a punt, but I'd like Fable to get a chance to actually spool out his Dya meta thing. In the world where dya's town, myself and her thunderdoming is one of the few things that could conceivably snatch victory from the jaws of defeat for a "wolves are in the PoE" world.

@mods, VC?

 

I was looking for something else but found this too.

 

A Bear's Even Lazy(er) 1H To EoD Votal.

Cuthalion (6): Fontisian, Stanari, Jarizok, Fable, Dyachei, Newcomb
Dyachei (2): Shadow, Cuthalion.
Not Voting (3): Everyone Else.

With 9 alive, it is 5 to soft lynch, and 7 to hard lynch.

 

This is the post I originally wanted to dig up.

I'm not 100% sure on D2 because most of the stuff I have is D1 but pretty sure Scott read is fighting consensus a lot. Having Vira/Miner/Tsaiah as nulls does generally match the observed D1 reads of Scott and Miner, and also Cuth.

Mrrrrrrr.

I should probably look for Vira and Tsaiah's D1.

 

Vote dya

 

Because I don't think dya can replicate mistakes she makes as a villager like that.

 

Kinda want to parrot Newcomb's "I hold no ill will against dya personally," but like. The whole "woe is me nobody is reading my posts lynch me I don't care anymore" is like. An IRL drag of a significantly high degree, because then it feels like you're purposefully making the lynch a personal matter when it never, ever is. It's a game.

But I also think that we're being duped by someone. I don't think it's Newcomb. I don't think it's Stanari. I don't reeeally think it's Fable or font. I just really feel like Cuth is a mislynch. I really have no words for it besides I don't think he's acting like long-since-caught scum, whatever that might look like.

But yeah, literally every time someone suspects dya, she pulls out the "you're not / nobody is reading my posts / lynch me I don't care" which like. I want to know if /that/ is an alignment indicative thing, because if she did that all the time as a villager I feel like Fable would have at least mentioned that.

@dyachei Newcomb is being about as fair as he possibly can with you, and then some, so if you find him intolerable or something then I'm sorry you've been suffering for so long.
--- Post automerged ---
Also Fable, no offense, but if you can't give better reasons than that then I'm not convinced.

I'm not saying "never trust Fable because he whiffed on Vira" but like. Understand that I'm hesitant to take your word for things and run with it.
--- Post automerged ---
I guess my main issue with dya above all is that her retorts feel incredibly manipulative.

 

......

She does but it's usually NAI but to this degree I only see her doing it as a villager.

 

Oh, and that she's also trying to keep the Newcomb lynch open, which ??? I'm pretty sure I'd lynch Jarizok over Newcomb.
--- Post automerged ---

Okay, because?

 

The thread collective doesn't agree though so.

 

@Fable

If you’re wanting me to take your dya meta read to the bank, here, what makes you unwilling to take Vaimes’ meta read of me to the bank?

Like, this isn’t a trap question, I’m genuinely curious.

 

Seriously do not lynch the only lifeline I have in this game.

 

I also disagree that how Cuth is currently acting can't come from scum.

 

I mean already said I'm willing to put it off until later.

 

Unvote, vote Cuth

If he flips Town Messenger, I'm coming after dya, NK be damned. No brakes.
--- Post automerged ---

Who is the thread collective and have they considered getting good?
--- Post automerged ---
idk man, if Newcomb somehow ends up being mafia, I need to know where he's been getting his WIM hits because goddamn
--- Post automerged ---

Why?