...uh

wait a sec

tom, the post you quoted has me implying that scum would have to be inexperienced to make the mistake of not killing Newcomb.

As in, it implies I knew it was a mistake.

As in, why would you hypothesize me as one of the lolwitches? Like, yomi/wine play I could understand but I'm signaling actual true knowledge that invalidates the hypothesis that I made the mistake.

If we didn't probably know what they were going for thanks to Newcomb's thing, then yes.

As for fonti, her sudden dump on me near dayend re: me apparently TMI-ing Jari just looked like mislynch setup the more I looked at it. It didn't seem to match other progression on me from her etc.

Kind of a moot point now anyway unless we're in-

oh god it's technically possible that Newcomb/fonti is the scumteam and fonti was vigged and the actual NK was angel saved

(note: if the above is the world then Newcomb will be eating CC from the vig today, so I'm not considering it)

anyway yeah kind of a moot point since fonti was NK'd.
--- Post automerged ---

Like to be clear, the answer to this question is "I made the post you just quoted" so I'm not sure why you asked it at all.

 

You/asmo team still played it wrong if true imo, so I'm gonna say it's still valid.
--- Post automerged ---
That blank is probably me vig that thought it would be more fun to lynch you.

Still probably would have shot asmo though.
--- Post automerged ---
Whoah I automerged back in time
--- Post automerged ---
If I keep posting will it keep going before Newcomb's post?

 

Worlds where a living Vig who got a shot last night would shoot fonti instead of me:

__________ (insert X files music here)

 

Yes, and in MY opinion too. As evidenced by the post you quoted.

Which begs the question: If this was in my opinion the wrong scumplay, why did I make it? And if your entire scum case on me now hinges on me thinking this WASN'T the wrong scumplay, why would you not specify that you think I'm lying about thinking that?

I said technically, not realistically :v

 

It doesn't

 

I'm going to go ahead and WIFOM the shit out of softing my check by asking the following question:

@Cobalt reads list with 1-2 sentences for each player, please.

 

Okay, so how does it hold up if I legitimately think last night's kill was bad play?

 

Sorry, are you asking me to clear you because of opinions expressed in thread about nightkill logic I don't know based on a team I'm unsure of in a game with no flips?

 

Looking for @Vaimes and @Waco to step up and start dropping some thoughts.

 

I'm asking you to state that your position is I'm lying about thinking last night's kill was bad play. If it's NOT, I'm asking you to explain how last night's kill happened with me as scum.

 

Especially waco
--- Post automerged ---

Umm.
No.

 

In that case I'm asking everyone else to ignore your position because it is incoherent.

 

Vote count from eod:


shadow (8) ~ Newcomb, tom, Cobalt, Vaimes, dC, asmo, waco, fonti

Not voting (3) ~ shadow, lump, gemma

Dead (3) ~ Jan, jari, stan
--- Post automerged ---

What position is it you think I've taken?

 

That I'm probably scum, and as a corollary that I did something I knew at the time to be stupid for no reason (since you refuse to explain otherwise)

 

Kinda doubting there's anything useful to glean from a VC from a day there was an outed wolf.

 

...

Ok first of all I have no opinion as yet on who might have killed fonti. Or why. I may think about that at some point but if I do so I would likely preface the post with "nightkill analysis is garbage, but..."

All I've said that is that if asmo is scum he should have souped in my opinion. He has not flipped, Newcomb has not died, we don't know what fonti was, and I don't think my opinion on what witches should have done is gospel or even relevant.

My scumread of you has not changed in the slightest.
--- Post automerged ---

I mean, no.
I just wanted to color something and that didn't exist yet.

 

dC, fonti started pushing on you because I started pushing on you.

Want to stop talking to tom for a minute and talk to me about where you're at with reads? Would appreciate a take on me in particular since you haven't really talked about me this game and I'm really vain, starting to get jealous etc.

 

I mean, you've been notably quieter this game than Princess but it feels more like it was because you're kinda lost than-

Wait, back up a sec. When were you pushing on me? I don't remember that at all.

Start a lynch then, smart guy.

 

Near EoD before I got distracted. And, please don't use Princess as what you're basing my towngame off? I hated how I played there so so so so much. Trying to metaread someone when you've only played one game with them is stupid anyway.