I mean, you are right I guess. Like, the way that he is saying that I am mafia but if I was a manipulative person then maybe I could be town is just gross on every level to me. But yes the angle he is taking where he can't come up with any reasoning for why I am mafia so he is just trying to discredit townreads on me in a super slimeball way is totally fine and I don't really have an issue with that in itself. What posts were you wigged out by though?

I mean I know I made that really stupid post about us day 1 that I immediately regretted, I shouldn't have posted that and it was an emotional thing that made no sense and wasn't even relevant to the game. I didn't feel like there was anything else that crossed the line though so if you did I would really like to hear what/why, if you feel like saying? You don't have to and you can leave it to post-game if you like.

I think the way we interacted here is probably extra weird because we just came out of a hydra game together and it's like we were still both just in that mode. Or I was anyway. I don't know. Day 2 was better balanced probably and I think it is just an experience thing where we are feeling out our dynamic with each other in mafia.

 

Moderator Note:

Day ends in 15-20 minutes or something.

I will try to get day end up as soon as I can.

 

Can confirm next game with someone after hydraing is very strange.

 

Like, tell me if I am wrong Newcomb but imo this post is basically identical to the post you caught that guy with in that other game that you linked in the mentor QT. The difference is that fonti isn't alive anymore so it's not underhanded in the same way but it's still underhanded, i.e., he's trying to get other people to see fonti/me being masons as scummy rather than trying to get fonti to see us being masons as scummy. He's phrasing the question in a certain way to insinuate that I am manipulative and therefore even if the logic points to me being town, it still makes me look bad because manipulative is a scum thing.

The relationship thing is completely NAI and nothing about the way were playing together was AI either. That's the part that I reacted to as strongly as I did and where I think he overstepped the line.
--- Post automerged ---

Sanity. Thank.

 

Day ends.

There is no lynch!

Except a giant mallet of doom swings down from the sky and kills Waco Kid.

Night ends in 23.5ish hours.

 

Day Four Begins.

Glass Case of Emotion soups dichtomousCreator as the Judge, but incorrectly matches Asmodeus to Clown!

With 6 alive it is 4 to soft lynch and 5 to hard lynch.

You have 72 hours.

 

oh thank god I'm free

 

HAHAHAHAHA YESSSSSSSS
--- Post automerged ---
@Newcomb out with result.
--- Post automerged ---
So pumped atm, sucks that I gotta dip out to drive an hour but I literally had to jump for joy a few times before posting LOL
--- Post automerged ---
@Gemma For the record, (idk if you actually misinterpreted or not) I never said you "could be town if you were manipulative". My implication was that I didn't think you were manipulative, and that making posts that require others to answer for you (as scum) sort of was. Obviously, as dC said, this is all in a "magic circle", but my read was more that a big caveat / problem I had with my scumread on you was that I DIDN'T think you possessed the manipulative ability to make the posts you made if you were scum. It doesn't say anything about you, we all play Mafia for a reason. It's just that I didn't think you *could*, which is a valid source of a read.

Hopefully the indignation was all faked and you never had a problem with me. If you did, though, hopefully that clears it up.

 

Wait what?

Shadow/waco/gemma?
--- Post automerged ---
If there's two witches alive we should go for the other one since gemma used her soup, right?
--- Post automerged ---
(Loltom)

 

"and Gemma doesn't seem heartless from what I've read."
Hence this thing in the post you reacted negatively to. My point was always the opposite of what you understood it as. I wouldn't ever say "the only reason this person could be town is if they were manipulative". I do use the inverse for reading, though.
--- Post automerged ---
k gotta run. I'll be back later, but glad that all worked out
Sometimes, playing mechanically *does* work. How's that for redemption?

 

Haaa, Gemma.
--- Post automerged ---
He’s Oracle, silly.
--- Post automerged ---
Why wasn’t Newcomb souped?

 

Fake news.

You went from townreading me to scumreading me because _____ ? You are obviously mafia, sir.
--- Post automerged ---
Y'all can feel free to concede whenever, btw. You're not going to get my partner.

Like, sure, maybe because he's dead and all. But still.

 

Cobalt is town, shockingly.

If Gemma is the last witch, just concede IMO.

I’d guess this is the case and Waco was her partner.

If her partner is alive, it’s mechanically either Vaimes or Asmo, which.... I mean, no.

But in that world we should a), not out people’s roles, Cobalt, and b) lynch one of them.

 

Btw, I'm /pretty sure/ mafia killed fonti because I was softing that I was her Acolyte. Which confirms me as town.
--- Post automerged ---

You concede first poopoo face.
--- Post automerged ---
Lynch Vote: Newcomb

Gutread.

 

:thinking:
This narrows it down to either Newcomb or Vaimes. I told myself I wouldn't consider a Newcomb scum world because of the inherent risk of him claiming before he could possibly know whether priest or acolyte were around to CC. This is endgame, though, so I want to be sure before dropping votes or anything. Kindly all give me a few hours to get home and consider before voting.
-phonepost

 

Gemma is lolcatting, pretty sure she’s conceding

@Gemma you seriously didn’t pick up on all the Cassandra talk?

 

Cobalt, do you think scum!Newcomb ever outs D2 with a guilty on his partner without any possible knowledge that either the priest or acolyte was dead? Give me a percentage, please

 

Ok so it's
Tom/cobalt (and jan/fonti/dc) confirmed town
Newcomb unCCed cop
Jari/stan/waco/shadow already dead
Gemma outed

And vaimes/asmo in question.

If anyone has info we only have 1 witch left, they can safely out because it's gemma.

Otherwise we lynch one of the question marks since gemma is out of soup.


Guess I'm waiting for info. Really don't want to have to even look at gemma/asmo interactions if I don't have to. Nor do I want to tinfoil on vaimes.

 

Tom, answer that question too