nooo I just got back when are you getting back?

 

If Vaimes/Gemma were literally going to guess, why put Asmo->Clown second? Why not first? That way if they guessed wrong they don't out a witch.

If Asmo was in a position to fakeclaim Oracle, why not just claim Gemma was the last one, watch everyone drop their pants probably, and soup into the sunset?

Important questions.

Okay now I’m really going to bed.

 

oh there's not much new. nvm. I'm down to wait for Vaimes. Pretty confident that Newcomb is town so I'm just chilling super excited. I don't see a problem with massclaiming @Newcomb but wait for Vaimes to claim first please.
--- Post automerged ---

This doesn't really make sense though. You mean, why not put me third, right?

 

I think the reason I’m struggling so much right now is that in both worlds, the only reasons I can come up with for things having gone the way they’ve gone is basically “witches made some pretty big errors” while at the same
time not having a clear idea of who the last one is in a literal 50/50.

Like I’m sure it seems pretty obvious in preemptive hindsight because the wrong option is /so obviously not the world/, but like...

 

These two posts presented adjacent to each other prove that tom is liar.

And we all know what happens to Liars.

 

I didn't even know souping wolves was possible until you guys started talking about it today and I did some more research and figured out it was. I got so excited at day start because I thought I was 100% clear and your action would narrow down the options to you and the person you didn't read.
This is NAI at this point, but there's no WAY I ever not soup you if I was scum and knew you were town. I even based my whole oracle action on the assumption that you'd get souped lol. The only thing I can thing of is they were so sure I was clown that the order didn't matter. Or WIFOM. Or lolwolves. Maybe all 3.

 

tom (1) ~ Gemma

Abstaining ~ a bunch of losers

 

Lol I may be new, but I'm not stupid. I claimed clown well enough to get them to missoup me, I think I'd know to soup you. It's a bit odd that I have to even argue this considering everything, but I guess it's understandable considering I had to process before I could be confident enough that you were town to think "ok it's Vaimes we're good let's end this"
--- Post automerged ---

Hey fam, I voted Vaimes, put me in there please.

 

tom is my partner.

Please lynch him before me.

 

Imagine if Jarizok and Stanari were exactly the priest and acolyte and it’s Shadow/Gemma/Newcomb

It isn’t, but imagine.
--- Post automerged ---
Anyway I too will discount Gemma/Asmo because of how grimy that interaction was so lol Vaimes
--- Post automerged ---
Are we reasonably sure there’s a living vigi?

What if we lynch Vaimes and if it’s incorrect vigi shoots Gemma to level the parity and then we just snaplynch Asmo

If it’s correct and no vigi kill we snaplynch Gemma and it’s game over

 

Newcomb, please don't sleep?

Let's go over our reads together.

I think tom is mafia. Just look at how hard he hedges earlier:

Town don't need to say that they are "sorta" here. He is trying not to commit to being here because he is mafia.

What do you think?

 

I thought Vig does nothing because we didn't lynch yesterday?

(I'm asleep now I start driving way too soon)

 

Oops, derp, yeah. Judge lynch doesn’t count for Vig activate.

Man, Vigi /never/ goes off in TH.

Okay now I’m really going to bed.

 

ohhhhh, right.

So we get zero info at all from vigi here. Swell.

 

Look, this is a blatant lie.

If tom were actually asleep, how could he have made this post?

That's right.

He couldn't have.

He is pretending to be asleep because he thinks that sleeping is a townie thing to do. He is mafia.

 

@Newcomb before you go

Why was I your check?

Feels a lot like confirming something everyone already knew instead of narrowing down the rest of the super important PoE we’re now muddling through.

I mean I get that it reassures the PoE but it did nothing for me, heh.

 

Wait.

Could I be confirm biasing on tom?

Hm.

No, I don't think so.

He did that really scummy thing that scum do because of their scum alignment.

Yeah.

 

Hey, Gemma?

Can you do me a favor?

 

He didn't check you. He is mafia, pretending to be the Priest.

The real Priest is Stanari.

I know this because I am her Acolyte.

This makes me confirmed town.
--- Post automerged ---

Only if it involves apples.

 

Okay sure.

Take an apple, put it in your hands, and go play in traffic. Adults are speaking.