I think scum Zenzao would have had more of a presence towards EoD1, especially when votes were flying and a vote on Jari could have flipped the wagons.

 

That's fair.

He seems much busier irl right now though, so I don't think that's that alignment indicative.

It feels like the third scum was in this void. No one interfered with the decision to not kill Jari, the closest to a strong defense of newcomb was me and Jan going for Jari, no one stood out as bussing, no one had extended interactions with Von or Newcomb early on. tl:dr I'm leaning towards lynch fluff.

 

What if he was just busy RL regardless of alignment?
--- Post automerged ---

That's rather a large assumption, babe.
--- Post automerged ---

The irony of you making this post when you haven't even really talked about any of your reads all game.

 

Vote count:

Invalid vote (1): Cobalt,

Not voting (8): Fonti, Ghouliani, Miner, Fluff, Jan, Fable, dC, Gemma,

With 9 alive it takes 7 to hard lynch.

 

He was present in thread 40 minutes before EoD (he posted), at which point Miner had the leading wagon, Newcomb was close behind, and anti-Jari posts were starting to appear. I think he's vote Jari or Miner here as scum.

 

Vote: Invalid vote
--- Post automerged ---

Ok.

What else?
--- Post automerged ---
As in, what do you think about any of his posts actually appearing in this game, rather than the ones not appearing?

 

I'll get back to you on that, but I also have a question for you.

Why did you push Newcomb at dayend before swapping to Jari at the last second, almost saving Newcomb, who you had previously pushing?

 

Zen's last post of the Day was before there was a wagon on Jari, and when Miner seemed very likely to be lynched. I can see that as a cop out vote Zen would want to make, when Von was already on Miner and supporting Newcomb, and Zen had those long ass analysis posts about Jan already.

 

Vaimes/Jan/Newcomb is a dream team for those players imo, I think at that point they set themselves up and start pocketing townies together. The way Newcomb and Jan both pushed on Gemma doesn't make sense coming from that team.
--- Post automerged ---

I agree with this.

 

(It's not an assumption, because they didn't kill Jari.)
--- Post automerged ---

I thought it was majority lynch, and preferred a lynch on Newcomb to a no lynch. I would have never done that as mafia, because I would have checked out the voting rules way before my partner was in danger.

I've explained this before.

 

Please explain this progression (all these posts were within 20 minutes of each other)

 

(There could have been reasons why they didn't want to kill Jari. The assumption was the interference thing.)

 

Bruh, please.

 

We've established that gemma is actually crazy person already.

 

Oh, okay then.

 

No, you can talk about it now please.

And, I have already talked about this. I didn't "almost save" Newcomb. I voted Jari when I knew that we didn't need my vote to lynch him.

 

...
--- Post automerged ---
By get back to you, I meant I needed to reread the posts.

 

Again like, look at my stance on Newcomb throughout the dayphase. If you had been keeping track of the game at all you wouldn't need to ask this.
--- Post automerged ---

Oh okay.

 

There are so many things I could say here.

 

By get back to

I'm just surprised, give that Newcomb and Jari were probably not scum together, and how certain she was that Newcomb was scum, why she would ever consider voting Jari there and risk saving Newcomb.