I don't really know. I don'tthink Fable is the right answer, but the problem is not being able to definitively rule him or fluff out.

So, miner, you can look through Day 1 again, and see if you can do that, or if you see something in dc and gemma I'm missing.

Wrt gemma though, I think the only thing that could be considered scummy from her is the swap at eod, but that kind of erratic vote change is something that's must more consistent with her town mentality. I don't think she dunks Von and Newcomb as much as she did, only to trash that credit at eod while clearing knowing it wouldn't save Newcomb. That would have to be a move specifically designed to fool me, which seems pointless, when she could instead convince everyone. I think her slot should be the most clear, honestly.

I was kind of tinfoiling dc, tbh, but the way he just responded to Fable was hella town.

 

I remember being super sketched out about some of the Newcomb-fluff interactions d1.

I'll try to pull up quotes

 

My body is ready.

 

ftr if ghoul is wrong you always lynch me is f5 because I don't see you not lynching me in f3.

 

I probably wouldn't and I will also probably make it to f3 anyway because my life sucks.

This is not a plot to ensure one of us is nightkilled before f3.

 

Vote count:

Fable (1): Ghouliani,

Ghouliani (1): Fonti,

Not voting (5): Miner, Fable, Fluff, Prophylaxis, dC,

With 7 alive it takes 6 to hard lynch.




Prophylaxis is subbing in for Gemma! Wish him welcome!!

 

Hey Proph.

 

hi proph your predecessor has earned your slot my undying loyalty so expect me to do nothing but follow you around until one of us dies

 

Hey guys.

If someone doesn't mind can they give me cliff notes of what has happened thus far? Would greatly appreciate it.

I'll start reading this game.. sometime tonight and provide my thoughts.

 

You have brushed aside all suspicion on you all game thusly:

1. I voted for a scum because reasons.
2. The kill that happened last night makes no sense? I am innocent because reasons.

 

It's tough being the best.

 

Well, I am sold. I'm not moving my vote. Dome of thunder.

 

This strikes me as a very bad idea.

OTOH I tried a quick spot of game assessment and got "it's fluff by process of elimination" which indicates my scumdar is still broken, so carry on I guess.

 

My process of elimination doesn't have it narrowed down to just one person, but it's close enough.

I gotta see Fable's card. Fonti would be who I strongly urge people to go for in the final three scenario if I am wrong. But you never narrow it down between the two unless one of them dies either today or tomorrow. My worst case scenario is on day five, you're still talking about Fluff and neither Fable nor Fonti have flipped. And then when you go after Fluff, either I have egg on my face or someone gets to pick between Fable and Fonti in the last round.

If I am wrong on this, the writing is on the wall and I'm being lynched tomorrow anyway. Go this route and its a lot more likely we don't have to play this out any further. If I am wrong though, I am warning you that this game is going to final three. And that sucks for all involved.

 

OK gonna try to read myself since no one responded to my request on cliffs

Should hopefully have some opinions on the game by the end of tonight.

 

Cliffs:

1. Miner is not a lynch to be considered. Although I have a theory that there was a deep wolf on day one, Miner and Gemma's votes on the two scums were both solid. Miner's vote came early and stayed as suspicion built on Newcomb for real. Bussing a partner d1 in a manner that gains you possibly the most amount of credit only makes it strange when you never get murdered. I have rarely seen that work in a game where you have several mislynches to work with. Miner is town.

2. Gemma slot pushed on both Newcomb and Vaimes on day one, and was the driving force behind initial heavy suspicions on Newcomb, even if their vote did waver later. Gemma slot is town.

3. DC, well I tried to remember why he was safe town, and I guess it's just a very old read of mine because I came up with bubkis. And he has a lot of posts, so I will have to do some digging to justify this read again. I have DC as town because of a quite persuasive thing Gemma posted which I would still agree with if I could remember what it was.

4. Fluff is town because I posted a big analysis saying why earlier this phase.

5. I am town because if I were any bigger, I'd be a city.

6. Fonti is town because she has put the most effort into investigating anyone out of everyone. Other than the blip of trying to lynch the watcher over Newcomb, and not having solid reads on anyone, generally townie. Just not townie enough to be safe town in my book.

7. Fable is town because reasons that are so obvious that it literally makes you stupid to question them. And I am stupid, so I question them.

Outcome of the rounds:
Newcomb day one, scum. All the relevant activity this game happened here. Jari was forced to claim here.
Tammy night one, town. Jari not dying has been chalked up to avoiding protection or not believing Jari due to forum meta of fakeclaims.
Vaimes day two, scum
Jari night two, town watcher
Jan day three, town
Cobalt night three, town

 

Thanks man, appreciate it.

Still trudging through but should have something up in the next couple of hours.

 

I don't mean to sound flippant about DC slot, I have no scum read on him and I am not backing off the town read. I formed it early and it was one of my strongest reads for a long time, and I have not seen anything since which would justify changing it.

My brain is just made of swiss cheese, and I work around that. I should do the due diligence and re-read him right now, but I am sick as a dog and I don't think I'm going ISO crawling again this phase.

 

Vote count:

Fable (1): Ghouliani,

Ghouliani (1): Fonti,

Not voting (5): Miner, Fable, Fluff, Prophylaxis, dC,

With 7 alive it takes 6 to hard lynch.

 

Okay I really tried to get through this but I had unexpected stuff crop up.

Will be around and speed-reading tomorrow morning before deadline if anyone wants to bounce reads or talk with me or something while I'm catching up.

@Sooh - possible we can get like, a 24 hour deadline extension to accommodate my replacing in? Didn't want to have to do this but today got away from me. TIA.