I'm going to have trouble here myself because posts auto-merge and I'm so accustomed to spam-posting my replies as I catch up. I'll have to adjust somehow, but it will be difficult...
--- Post automerged ---

Why do you assert this exactly?
--- Post automerged ---

How is not paying attention to the thread a scumtell?

 

Because scum don’t need to solve the game and might get lazy or not read the thread as carefully as a villager would.

 

Why are you town reading Jan?

 

I liked his vibe.

 

I'm already pocketed.

I love you.

 

Are you using meta as the basis for this assessment?

 

I love you more!!!

 

Right before I started playing this game, I was doing this experimental solo game where I would just post by myself in one thread and say, “Cop is a bad role,” and that would be the whole game. I did that in hundreds of sold-out games all around the internet, because I wanted people to understand that Cop is a bad and not a good role.

Even after that one mash, we were still living in the shadow of Cop, and that was difficult. Especially for me. People would come up to me in postgame and say, "Hi, Newcomb, we are all aware that Cop is a good role," and I would have to tell them that it's actually bad. This happened all the time.

For many years, I tried to pay the Pope a million dollars to replace the word "Amen" with the phrase "Cop is a bad role," but the pope wouldn't do it because he liked the role so much. Everyone loved that role.

It all came to a head when Bill Clinton said in his State of the Union address that Cop was a better role than VT and both Republicans and Democrats gave him a half-hour standing ovation. We all sort of realized that we needed to create something big, or this role would come to define us. And then I got an idea.

 

Unvote, vote Stanari

 

Hello, Vaimes! Thanks! I think you all seem awesome too. Don't prove me wrong. Hahaha.

Are you asking me to vote for someone suspicious?

 

Oh my god.

 

Yes!

 

Well, this makes sense. Thanks.

In my experience I've actually seen the opposite argument; mafia members are informed of pertinent items by their teammates in scumchat whereas townies especially those who are behind in reading the thread and/or low on time can become inattentive.

 

Unvote

Vote: Nego

 

Does not compute.

Elaborate in any way possible?

 

Jan, Vaimes and M Plus 7 are town.

Stanari and Eido are frozen and therefore mafia together.

Game is so easy.

 

I would normally take this opportunity to say the threat of being legitimately pocketed by a member of the scum team is far outweighed by the benefit of townies openly working with each other, but...

I have a bit of PTSD from Game 9 still.

 

I feel like I can read Jan well.

He’s usually more prickly or stilted as scum.

Here he felt genuine and fluid and like a ray of sunshine.

 

RVS isn't my thing really. I'll suspect someone in due time.

 

Guide me to victory.