You take the compliments to the bank fonti.

 

Have a wolf game where you're painfully obviously a wolf for me to compare this game to, and I'll have you higher!

I read her opening posts and just strongly felt that 'this is not the same alignment she was in the office' ping.

 

She was townread in the office initially though.

Food for thought.

 

I agree with 90-93% of this, have a town read ok hand.

 

@Eidolonic
I would appreciate a Nego focused thing before eod, if you have the time.

 

@Citrus - Wouldn't mind hearing you actually run through your Miner town read; am in a position where it's a little harder to actually read him myself so you going into it would help.

Woooooooo finally an EidoPost.

@Eido - Alright so have no disagreements with the Newcomb/M7/Jan reads, I'm more confident on Stanari & Gemma than you are which is fine, I can run you through them if you need but I think you're confident /enough/ they're town that it's probably not needed.

I'm not where you are on Vaimes & Tsaiah, the former I'm not going to discuss until I actually spend time ISO'ing him and see if our read disagreement is big enough for it.

But with Tsaiah, have you read her scum play anywhere other than The Office game? She was scum in Hydra #6 and posted some early stuff, want to take a look at that and compare it to here? I just remember having used similar reasoning you have here before and being burnt by it before realising that she's just scum. In fact in Hydra Game 6 I may have actually just flat out said "She's acting different/happier than the Office Game so I've got a weak town read on her", so would be super cautious with that sort of reasoning, at least re; the strength of it.

Can def follow your Kai read & reasoning, same goes with NothingHappening, you're sort of considering the same type of worlds I am at the moment / play that scum are doing from the looks of it which is awesome.

There's /something/ small from Fontisian that I saw that bumped her up a fair bit in my reads from more a ~weak scum read~ to more of a null, nullishtown if anything one, doesn't look like you've noticed it and I'm not sure it's something I want discussed anyway so meh. Really would love your Citrus ISO thoughts when you're done that, is a read that I feel decent about but a lot of people are disagreeing with me on.

Miners a mess of a one for me to talk about but really like that you brought up the Kami type comparison since that's a lot of where my heads being going to as a "Is it possible he's just town and it's a grudge-scum read/push" which is very tilting to even contemplate when I'm dumping a shit-ton of time into this game and it also makes it much harder to determine whether he's town or just scum using it as something to push/do.

Would agree with Fenwick just being a hit here most of the time, look forward to you dumping your own reasoning post on him though, am considering just lynching there today despite the replacement tbqh.

Meeting time for me for a few hours.

 

@Regfan
Sure,wont be for a bit though and is gonna be abbreviated as I'm sleeping soon

 

Yeah I've been thinking about this. It's kinda gauche to lynch a slot that's subbed out and pending replacement, but if the thread consensus is we're just gonna lynch the slot no matter what, might as well not make someone try to catch up.

Kinda leaning towards not lynching the slot, tbf. I mean for one thing it just kills momentum for D1, it's kind of a mess in the (admittedly unlikely) event it's a miss, that slot can always be Vig shot tonight, etc.

 

Can people stop misgendering Beru please it's actually a little tilting.
--- Post automerged ---

Reg. Just ignore him. He's one player out of 15.

 

Can people call people by their DLP usernames please it's actually a little really tilting.

 

I'm not in love with this.

 

Why?

 

Lucky you!

(It's not really comparable for a few reasons, sadly.)
--- Post automerged ---

This is a nice read, I think.

The energy is absolutely different but I think it's within her capability to fake a burst of it.

 

Smiles, what would be the wolf motivation for Nego to come at me like that? Like he's essentially saying, "Newcomb your wolf read on me is bad because I'm a better wolf than you're assuming and if I were a wolf I wouldn't have made such an obviously wolfy post."

Just, like, pure pride? Because as a tactical stance it's not an amazing one.
--- Post automerged ---
I'm having a pretty intense smilefires -> this game :: SR -> The Office, someone talk me out of it.
--- Post automerged ---
Wait, derp, I meant Cuth, not SR.

 

We're not killing the fen slot, outside of like a panic lynch at eod. I mean, I get it, I thought about saying "fuck it, let's kill the empty slot" after Eido's post, but we don't know if it's a provable pr and we have other decent lynches.

 

Can you unwrap that?

 

Yeah. He kind of pulled the words out of my brain. I'm happy that he doesn't want to lynch Nego, too.
--- Post automerged ---
I still want to lynch him, though, lmao.

 

If it's for tonal reasons, I didn't mean it to be that harsh and I do apologize for that aspect. Otherwise, tough (directed at Newcomb)

 

Eido, why do you not apply an isolation read to Miner?

 

Nod. Just from a "Who do I think flips scum the most here" angle, it's that slot and then a distance before anyone else. Also the Cuth with NH is something that I had contemplated previously too, also swirled around a Fenwicked/Bears/Kai/NH type scum team in my head a bit as an ezgameezlyfe type one.

I know <3. Is just hard to completely do so. Especially when I'm looking in a specific pool of players for scum and to leave my vote on when I leave for the day phase in ~3 hours and he's in there and I"m having to try and work out if he's scum here or just badtown. But yeah, I'm probably leaving it on one of the names above (Fenwicked/Bears/Kai/NH), am really not reading Bears posts in the same light you are here.