First things first, Ampharos is a weak town lean aorn, all because of that one post but for the time being it's all I have to work with, and a decent start.

Where are you Cobalt?

 

I too am here.
--- Post automerged ---
It is indeed possible to lump a witch. That would be no bueno.

 

It’s only bad if they get away with it. :V

 

Expecting Cobalt to be around. Rookie mistake.
--- Post automerged ---

It’s never ideal. But sure, if it leads to us lynching them that’s ok-hand.
--- Post automerged ---
Should I have a read on Gemma Vaimes?

 

Uh, we actually want to lump a witch. You should know that, my dude.

For the new people, that's because we're having the priest check the lump target n1 and claiming d2 if they're scum. If the priest doesn't claim, we assume the lump is town. If the priest dies n1, the acolyte corrects us down the line.

The ideal world is lynching and lumping two witches d1, but just lumping one isn't bad.

 

This does ring a bell. :]

 

That actually doesn't sound bad at first glance.

So... vote to lynch your main suspect and vote to lump your second biggest suspect? I can get behind that.

 

Sure.

Whether or not it’s accurate is a different issue.

 

Thanks for nothing!

 

I’ll give you a better answer if you lump me!

 

...You’re a witch? Or are we just ignoring the Fonti plan that also happens to be the optimal play?

 

Like she gets credit for a play that’s existed since forever.
--- Post automerged ---
Honestly, I just want to be Lump once.

One time. Then we can go back to being optimal.

 

She’s the one that described it first this game. You’re just jelly.

 

All she did was change it from “lump a nullread” to “lump a scumread.”

 

Well i was waiting on vaimes but
--- Post automerged ---

Im actually fairly sure grape didnt know. And it very probably means hes just town (barring a scumteam of [new to witch hunt]/cobalt/anyone else who hasnt showed up)
--- Post automerged ---

Also dont think amy has it in her to come to this conclusion when she knows what we actually do.
So probably town (same caveat as grape)
--- Post automerged ---

Wolfvaimes mad townfonti is getting read as such for something NAI?

 

Eeeeehhhhh. Mebbe. I don’t mind voting Vaimes anyways.

Vote: Vaimes

 

That was not a read.
--- Post automerged ---
Also I’d expect town!Grape to want to have fun with the Lump mechanic, even if he didn’t want it himself.

Half of the fun of Day 1 is lump campaigns. :V
--- Post automerged ---
First off, there’s 0 chance I get lynched.

Second, if anyone is gonna scumread me, the absolute least you could do is let me have lump. Otherwise it’s probably never gonna happen.

 

Huh... Well that's a thing.

Fluff I'm not sure I agree based on my experience with Vaimes. He's definitely more relaxed as town. I think solid players in general and Vaimes in particular is more likely to make a contradictory post as town. But now it's pretty obvious there isn't any contradiction to his actions.

@Vaimes Lumping Gemma was RVS. Continuing it was because I haven't seen any reason to break it yet.

 

Didn't i lynch you day 1 last game?
--- Post automerged ---

Sup.

 

Tom, do you think Jari not remembering the check thing is towny for him?