Umami Smart

 

you forgot to italicize

 

Fonti Scum

 

Because she not have smart Gravedigger plan like Umami?

 

Hi Dels

Do you agree we kill Manasi / Shadow / Cobalt and probably kill 2-3 scum?

 

That's 100% false.
--- Post automerged ---
Like a really really bad take.

 

Maybe. My three to kill was Manasi / Shadow / Fluff but I'll admit Cobalt could actually be scum.
--- Post automerged ---
Okay so thanks to Fluff I just realized the flaw in Umami's plan which is that the gravedigger could just be scum and then they won't say anything either way.

 

Because the gravedigger could be a witch.
--- Post automerged ---

Justify your shit.

 

Grave digger is a holy role?
--- Post automerged ---
So cannot be a witch...

 

Pretty sure only the priest is holy

 

Oh misread. Thought the first 5 roles were holy. Didn't see the information disclaimer. You right

 

Umami still town lol.
--- Post automerged ---
Cobalt>fluff>shadow>dels>manasi>gemma

 

Four options here.

GD can be either villager or witch. Jarizok can be either villager or witch.

Also, Jarizok can be the GD as well as being a villager or witch, since we didn't get a claim from him.

Villa GD, villa Jarizok: I say just stay quiet. No one's really worldbuilding off Jarizok being a hit currently and utility of potentially getting a D3 lynch check's pretty solid.

Villa GD, witch Jarizok: I'd say out. First, by having an out/not out dichotomy between the result, we get a soft confirm Jari was a villager if no one says anything. Second, outing Jari was a witch gives us a hard info point as it guarantees at least one witch between Jarizok and the GD.

Witch GD, villa Jari: Probably not outing if we go with the above. Can kind of fuck us D3 although they can't claim Jari was a witch.

Witch GD, witch Jari: Can lie and stay silent to confuse worldbuilding, but there are several ways that lie can bite them in the ass.

Independent of all that, if you're the GD and Jarizok was the Priest, you need to out. It sucks, since it tells witches a lot, but it's too potentially damaging to not have town know that, considering.

If you're the GD and you choose to out and your result is that Jari was a villager, don't out his role unless he was specifically the Priest.

If we talk it over and the consensus is that GD needs to claim regardless of result, we can always smoke them out by having everyone hardclaim not GD and brute force it down to either outing the role, or confirming we have either "Jari was GD" or "GD is a witch."

And yeah, there's really no point dancing around it since if I could confirm Jari town I'd have already done so -

I'm a defensive role, so I can't say if it was an angel shot or my role that tanked the hit.

 

Basically all of our top suspects fit as wolves whether they're with Jari or not so you're not wrong that our wordlbuilding isn't particularly revolutionized by Jari's allignment
--- Post automerged ---
(Except I think I'm really not a wolf if Jari was. Just saying)

 

Well that makes jari more likely witch by an amount
--- Post automerged ---
Like, here:
Cobalt>fluff>jari>shadow>dels>manasi>gemma
--- Post automerged ---
Might be overcorrecting.

 

I think we should lynch Shadow and then gravedigger outs d3, because if Shadow Jari is w/w or v/v then the wagons dont really matter, but if Shadow is wolf and Jari villa or vice versa then we actually have something.


But going purely off reads, I'd kill Manasi > Cobalt > Shadow > Fluff right now.

 

Yeah wouldn't change a whole lot for me.

Maybe switch gemma and dels if hes a witch
--- Post automerged ---
What's the deal on manasi? I've got her, like, scummy side of null and don't remember a case?

 

Who hasn't posted yet today?
--- Post automerged ---
Just Mp7 and manasi or anyone else?

 

MP7 is super town btw

 

I forget who I’m voting.

Unvote, vote Manasi