Can everyone who is town reading muzjik please go over their reasoning for the read in as much detail as possible? I don't feel like anyone has really done that (if my memory is escaping me, links pls), and I think there have been several people town reading him "because silver was townie", but I don't know why they think silver was townie, either.

 

Newcomb summarized it best. That one post where Silver was talking about replacing out and he stressed the fact that if he was being run up we should tag him because we would want his claim. It aligns with town silver who rolled GD. He cared about us having that information, just in case.
--- Post automerged ---

I second this.

 

Yeah muz is whatever. Ive liked some posts/thoughts but eh.
Silver was fairly obviously town to me though why was anyone scumreading him?
--- Post automerged ---
Lynching someone else (shadow) and shooting manasi seems fine.
Think im ready for the Tom tries to live portion of the game

 

At this stage in the game, you should not be reading me off of a few predecessor posts. I've done more than enough to develop a read on.
--- Post automerged ---
And @Gemma, if you seriously think I'm partners with Manasi... men.

 

FWIW, I’m not a role that needs to claim, so it’s whatevs.

 

Men indeed.

 

Lynching someone else (shadow) and shooting manasi seems fine.
Think im ready for the Tom tries to live portion of the game

I know silver really well tho

 

I'm alive, I promise. Everything is kicking my ass right now.

Hopefully I'll have some time to real time with whoever is around throughout the day today whenever I'm not teaching. That's the plan anyway.

 

Don't worry Mplus I am here to fill you in on everything you need to know, wether you ask for it or not.

 

I laughed.

 

Town
Muz Font Dels Vaimes Gemma Cobalt M7 Newcomb (the latter 3 are weaker, granted)

PoE Pool
Tom Umami
Kai Fluff
Shadow

Scum
Manasi
--- Post automerged ---

The odds of her being fanatic (very low) are outweighed by the benefit of getting a flip on Shadow via gravedigger, imo. Because there's a lot to read off of Shadow's alignment.

That's just me.
--- Post automerged ---

Can you explain Kai to me please?
--- Post automerged ---

Not a partner read imo.

Eh, this is a meh read.
--- Post automerged ---

Manasi's Gemma push spews Gemma as town. Its not bussing.

 

Agreed about the Cobalt post

 

You're going to hate me, but Manasi's Dels interactions aren't necessarily clearing.

 

@Manasi

Please come lolcat. Dyachei believes in you.

 

Knowing Fonti is town makes Dels look better too though. I don't know why I'm so hung up on Dels, a *lot* of his posts are townie and he's also been super friendly all game. Maybe its just that scum tend to be nicer than townies? Lol. I'm not going to lie, Manasi's Dels stuff looks a little like high-level theater to me, but I'm going to shelve that and just call Dels town.
--- Post automerged ---

This is probably not a partner read either... I think? Its very awkward if so.
--- Post automerged ---

x
--- Post automerged ---

Snipped for readability, eh, maybe Kai's just town.
--- Post automerged ---

Guess I'm biased, but I don't think this post is ever w/w either.

 

There's also this @muzjik.

 

I'd agree with that.

For all of that to be true, it means the last two scum are two of {Tom, Umami, Fluff, Shadow}. You feel good about about that?

 

Lynch Tom

This gives me great joy.

 

Hi cobalt
--- Post automerged ---
Yeah gemma def not scum with manasi.
Which reminds me...
--- Post automerged ---
This makes a lot more sense with them being musketeers. Especially the bolded.

Kinda think I dont notice or push that as w/w if im scum with jari and knew about that, but yrmv

 

Except he wasn't being run up and it also aligns with scum!Silver who would have wanted people to think that he is town. I don't see any reason why mafia can't have that mindset and townreading someone for one post is really irresponsible.