Anyway only reasons to lynch manasi instead of hunting her is
>hunter could be scum
>fonti could be scum and doesn't want manasis alignment revealed

First one is not a huge deal I guess. They either do what we say or they dont then we know hunter is scum for sure and can deal with that.

Second one... uh... fonti/muz/gemma/vaimes coven, jari priest, and 0 town musketeers?
Not a real thing lol
--- Post automerged ---

I should find you a silver scumgame so you can put this to bed...

 

No offense to Manasi, but I'm not entirely sure she would be capable of high-level theater given the rest of her play here.
--- Post automerged ---

No, people should actually talk about their reads.

 

She's a pretty decent video mafia player, but I would agree based on this game her forum game isn't as good.

 

My read, as few pages as he was here, is that silver could not have worked his way into the thread like that as scum. Hed be terrified here, especially with jari/manasi/[probably shadow]

He's, like, real bad as scum.
So bad.
This wasn't it
--- Post automerged ---

Think her main talents lie elsewhere than "high level theater" regardless of medium

 

What.
--- Post automerged ---

Meta sux
--- Post automerged ---
I appreciate the words, tho.

 

That possibility is essentially dadaism

 

What name did you play under on DM, by the way?

 

Let's not go overboard here making assumptions about how bad Manasi is at being a wolf... I don't think her posts were that bad, there was a combination of things that led to her being a consensus wolf here, partially the forum meta, partially being busy IRL, and partially lots of other people being very townread.

I don't have any point to make with this and we can still assume which interactions are or aren't w/w, I just don't feel comfortable necesarilly implying Manasi couldn't have been good enough to sneak anything in.

 

@Gemma
Here's scum silver in a 7 player game on mtgs.
https://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums...iable-cops-day-3-walking-the-beat?page=3#c123

You may now lock him in as town

 

I'd rather not say, sorry.

 

Alright, no worries.

 

Meta sux.

I appreciate the link tho.

 

Is everyone including Muz just going to ignore the time I also said I never saw much from Muz to make me rethink my read on his slot, or my INITIAL silver townread from the beginning of the game based on the fluff thing, or the fact that I said his resistance to the claim game was towny

Because the fact that you’ve both said I’m townreading him for one post is absolutely annoying honestly

 

I think the lack of a push on fluff d1 is notable, especially if shadow is scum.

 

Yeah, sorry, I think that's probably right. I could maybe see m plus 7 as scum.

 

I swear to fucking god if Fluff is scum I want you all to kiss my feet.

 

Eh, umami's thing about all the information roles being holy is probably just town.
--- Post automerged ---

I've been calling him potential scum since midway though Day 1, friend.

 

You can sit next to me and prop yours up too then.

 

I've got shadow>fluff as most likely. I'm town. Umami seems town