Does anyone know what the current votecount is?

 

I believe 2 sloth 2 keld 1 sera

 

I mostly had the same progression as fluff towards the end of yesterday, i dont think it sounds like scumfluff at all, and i think it shows signs of background thinking which is one of the things i actively look for in townfluff.

Its like.
Idk he might be in my towncore

 

I can dig it. Let me go ISO him real fast, shouldn't take long lol.

 

Fluff reads genuine in his EOD for sure. Wow, glad I went back and looked at this.

I really should just go read EOD from a certain page now.

 

Can't say I'm quite there yet but I very much didn't have the same late d1 progression as tom so.

 

I think there's prior read in the case of Miner and just agreement in the case of Sloth.

As for the personality read, I am not the only one to have commented that Rhand doesn't put on an act, unlike players like tom. As such, knowing Rhand, it can be easier to see his desires, just not necessarily the motivations behind them. That said, I think in this case, I'm seeing both and he is just pure town.

 

I'd be interested in hearing why I am on this list with minimal if any comments about your read on me prior to this point.

 

Yeah, im not into going deep on the sloth defense.

Feels a little cftwr, but that read is always bad because townies that think theyre being read eith incorrect methods act in really similar ways.

Him talking about being aggressive like normal when im kinda... still waiting for him to get aggressive is noted i guess.

Think ill wait for rhand

 

No reason, really, other than gut. I essentially don't have a read on you at this point. I believe on earlier reads lists you were in a similar position. I'll make sure to go back and look at your posts when I get a chance and let you know what questions I have, if any.

 

Just based on this alone + my current POE

VOTE SERATIN

 

Vote: Keldeo

This works for me and I trust tom.

 

So I'm working on EOD stuff, but this is a random aside.

I went back further than EOD, and I ran across https://forums.darklordpotter.net/threads/mountainous-mafia-3-desperate-times-desperate-measures.39214/page-22#post-113185]this post[/url] (#539) from Miner about Seratin that I think would be a good basis for discussion about him today.

 

Ughhhhhhh well at least it links? Why do I do this

 

Having looked over the posts that cover the few hours prior to EOD...

I would say the following thoughts GTH:

- tom's switch to Umami reads rather organically, given his expressed feelings in #622 particularly
- Sloth's insistence to stay on Miner is a bit strange, as Rhand noted, but I'm not sure why that would matter if both Miner and Umami are town, so I'm not really sure what to make of that
- Keldeo's switch is perhaps the most notable -- he is the one that had the highest relative opinion of Umami so that seems strange that he would switch, but he does explain it throughout. Tonally with his "aaaaaa" posting near the absolute end it still reads genuine to me, because prior he did throw out a series of posts like he was willing to go along with consensus to get a lynch and had become increasingly more receptive to the arguments
- fluff indicates that Umami's lack of ability to commit anything is what drives his vote, and it reads believable

In general, the shift happened pretty quickly; most of the activity occurred less than an hour before the vote deadline, so the gamestate leading up to it is somewhat not predictive of where it progressed in that final hour I'd say, even if there were slight hints of it.

I'm thinking it's possible that the major influencers in EOD were actually mostly town, especially if Miner is town. There may have been one scum in there, but it's hard to say exactly who it might have been. Right now based on just the read of EOD alone I would guess Sloth or Keldeo.

 

I'm getting tired now; I don't think I can do ISOs because it'll be incoherent, lol. I'll be back tomorrow morning (hopefully)/early afternoon (possibly) (PST) for ISOs, interactions, and then of course EOD.

I also wanted to express my appreciation for playing this game with all of you. Definitely feeling a lot better by now, and I am for the most part enjoying this experience. I hope we can make an even more informed decision this time around.

See you all soon!

 

Ugh for pressure reasons, yes hes clearly scum choo choo no brakes

But generally dont rn

 

I had a virtual café night with friends and woke up late with a hangover lol.
I’ll read up when the painkiller kicks in.
It’s amazing how well that worked. You should all try it
--- Post automerged ---

Why?

It's a tone vs facts thing. I like his tone, he feels pure. But I don't trust that without having any meta on him.
What I don't like is that I keep disagreeing with him. His reads are mostly different from my own and that bugs me.

@M Plus 7 can you elaborate on why you have such a strong town read on tom?

I'm going to ISO Keldeo today. From my notes I also find myself disagreeing with some of the strong reads he voiced D1 and he somehow didn't leave a big impression on me.

Someone (forgot who) said that they want to see my town core. I think with this setup, I better hold most of my reads close to my chest now. It's gun delivery Night, and if we all give out readlists now, it becomes too easy to predict who won't shoot scum with the gun.
Full readlists should be given toMorrow, no toDay.
--- Post automerged ---
Am I the only European here?

 

Hi Rhand! Good to play with you again. I'm not a European, but I'm around for a little bit. (I think the only Europeans in this game are you and Seratin? I'm not sure where Waco is.)

I was the one who asked about your towncore. That's fine, that makes sense.

Vote Seratin

I think I prefer him between my counterwagons. I feel like the conviction in his first post toDay should have resulted in more follow-up at some point? Although it's probably not AI that he hasn't been here.
--- Post automerged ---
@Osieorb18 Talk to me about Seratin - do you have any thoughts on him outside of his first post today? He did a lot more yesterday that it would be cool to have your thoughts on.
--- Post automerged ---
I also don't particularly buy into the outrage being fake as part of that read. It seems a bit disproportionate to me, but Miner was his only major scumread iirc, so I guess I could buy that the emotion is genuine and he posted it in an impulsive/salty moment and it came out a little exaggerated.

I don't fully trust myself with the negative space read that I'm applying here, but /shrug.

@Seratin, I don't think we're lynching Miner today... could you tell me about who your top suspects are besides him, and why?
--- Post automerged ---

Mm, I don't fully grasp your read on how MP7 approaches the thread, so maybe that's what's holding me back. But I don't get this read in the sense that I think mafia MP7 would know that he "should be" regretful that he pushed a villager, and therefore project regret into the thread. I could see his series of posts falling out of the combination of that (fake or real) regret and his (probably NAI) level of engagement.

 

Seeking a replacement for Seratin.