iirc, this isn't what grape said about his read? He specifically maintained that what he had noticed at first was still suspicious + his only read from the whole situation was Waco v

Don't remember when that shifted to town on tom.

 

Yeah, that's pretty low probability, all things considered.

 

Ok sped-read up to here. Caught up. I'm around till the end of the day.
Anyone have any questions? Ping me, I'm here.

 

But you have never once actually explained how that is true. Just point to some wording or at least give me something so that I can better understand you.

@Osieorb18

 

It isnt i was wrong. He posted a few times then came back with a readslist ~12 hours later

Im quite certain he has though, and strongly discounting and scumreading cuth for coming up with a read on the fly remains absolutely ludicrous even if it were true here.
And as cuth says its not like he hasn't been reading the game and thinking about stuff in the interim so it's not

 

Is his argument really that out of 4 people on his wagon, one is statistically likely to be scum?

 

Osi's series of posts surrounding all of this is just the weirdest stuff ever. The biggest tunnel I've seen in a long time. I don't get it at all. If someone else does, please enlighten me.
--- Post automerged ---

What is your POE right now?

@Sloth
--- Post automerged ---

What is your POE right now?

@Sl

Oh shit, thanks for the correction guys.

Nonetheless yeah, I agree, but I really keep trying to see a townie world for this and ?????

 

These seems among the least profitable ways to currently be playing this interaction regardless

 

Yeah, it just doesn't make sense at all. The only thing that maybe does is Osi is a cornered scum and just is trying to WIFOM and avoid saying anything new? I really don't know.

 

For fear of falling for the carson daly bit tom was describing I think I'm happy with this level of disagreement for now. I think it is quite plausible that a town player is doing this. I don't think it's blatantly scummy. I think he's a scum player playing a B+ to A game that is overly leaning on scattershot questions to maintain presence and walls to garner town reads. I don't have a smoking gun to point to I just think he's been herding opinion and laying low.

 

I'll step away for just a handful or two of minutes here, I'll be back after.

 

It's possible I missed it, but what happened to you have Fluff 2nd from bottom in your reads?

 

If you track this down, let me know.

 

It's this one -

I don't think he was actually saying that you were still a scumlean or anything, but it matches what he said later about you being on the scummy side of null, I think?

 

I called some of them out in the moment as they happened.

First, 1019/1024 there was misrepresenting my progression on tom, through cherry-picking. Second, 1044, misrepresenting my case on Sloth (which I called out). Note: At this point I'm "miles less villager" than EVERY OTHER PLAYER IN THE THREAD, according to Cuthalion. A read which he has not discussed AT ALL prior to that point. A read that is based on thinking that I'm an easy mislynch. Third, 1055, misrepresenting my progression on tom again (which again, I called out). Then he handwaves away my explanation of my case on Sloth as irrelevant. Note, despite me being "miles less villager" than EVERY OTHER PLAYER IN THE THREAD, for about a page now, he still doesn't vote me until later. He then admits that he spent about 15 minutes on forming a read on me while actively posting in the thread, and that his justification after the fact for pushing my mislynch amounts to my reads having more depth than his. I can go on, but at this point I'm already at a stronger scumread on him than every other player in the thread, and unlike him, who is full of it, I actually am voting for my strongest scumread.

 

Godddamnit, stop posting you assholes.
I was wrong, didn't realize we made it to page 12. Just sped-read 50 posts.

@tom why are you shruglynching???

@M Plus 7 the reason why I asked your scumreads is because I generally don't PoE/Townhunt, I scumhunt. I...have not had luck connecting Osie to anyone in particular, but that could be lack of posts D1?
What post# were you linking to in #913? Link isn't working for me.

@Keldeo Seratin vote on #919 - why not fire?

 

Ok so it didnt happen in the background while pushing me for raisins.

So the transition just doesnt exist

Which makes grape _____

 

Different others. My second post is specifically referring to my reads of Grape and MP7, who to me could be strengthened based on the alignment of Seratin.

 

I... haven't... been... present?

 

Can we get a VC @Vaimes