Set these 4 aside off mechanics:

Cobalt
Cuthalion
Fluffiness
Fontisian

And I'm left with:

Arapocalypse
Gira
Grapefruit
Nutella
Vaimes

I was gonna math out auto but soup kinda fucks with it so nevermind.

If it is indeed 9-1, we're doing pretty damn good lmao.

 

(If anyone's curious, ignoring soup and assuming 1 kill/night means players inside the PoE need one clear for auto, and players outside the PoE need 2)

 

Ohhh I had it backwards Ara wasn't the one that thought nutella was the check.

OK that's... interesting.

My new question becomes "why does scum!Ara bother to make this correction when she can just pretend to have also thought nutella was the check", though being overly helpful is certainly in her wolf playbook.

 

We assume we're working with 1 because fonti never makes that claim and risks being countered, which she would have to assume would happen. It would take an obscene boondoggle to get away with that otherwise.

Trying to look back...waco echoed Vaime's townread of Ara early on, had one interaction in #234 that was kind of neutral, and...that was it. I dunno, not a ton to go on, but I feel rather good about it not being Grapefruit or Vaimes.

 

Vaimes and Gira are super town.

 

Game should be extremely easy, I think.

 

Of the PoE before rereading.
Town
Gira
Vaimes/Amy
Ara
Nutella
Scum

Reading Lissa and waco.

 

Yeah, I'm also here.

Lots of "maybe it's just Ara" rattling through my brain rn.

 

We know the wolf is someone who picked up on Lissa being the priest (which is something I didn't do - but I also wasn't looking, lol).

Ara coming into today knowing Lissa was the priest and knowing who her check was is in fact pretty bad.

As mentioned above, my main/only concern with that line is "why out this information", but lord knows I've seen worse unforced errors.

 

The consensus is probably right and it's just Ara but I'm tunneled too deep and can't be unbiased at the moment.

 

Fine.

I still don't think he was Lissa's check though.

 

##Vote: Arapocalypse

Should be the 4th vote, by my count. Soft at 6, hard at 8.

 

He was. I promise. If you won't trust fonti on a mechanical level, trust me on a "I know Lissa" level.

 

Didn't even cross my mind to look for priest, yeah. I'm not playing the soup game at home, my QT is sad and barren.

There's this, again, not much but...Expressed dislike of grapefruit based on him moving onto Lyric as well.

 

If I were Lyric's partner I absolutely would have tried the "this is TWTBAW" defense.

Now I'm tunneling.

Oh well.

 

@Arapocalypse

Claim.

 

Don't worry if we don't hit maj, I can queue up whoever.

 

Vaimes and Nutella clear.

That was easy.

 

My only issue with Fonti's claim is that witches will know if she is not the Graverobber because they are notified when Graverobber triggers. I don't like the idea of witches having more info than us.

 

Let's save it for postgame.

Also doesn't matter how much the witches know if they're all dead.