I'm not a clone, you know, I do have different opinions to him. Also, I agreed with him that she's scum, not that I'd want to lynch her. I'm arguing for her survival because my entire reason for suspecting her is that I think she's in contact with someone else. If she's not Tessariel, and she's not in contact with the Blackstaff (which she's not), then she would be a St. Giles member. At least that's how I'm reading it.

Therefore it is in our best interests to let the Knights have a go at her. Just think of the potential rewards of having a former Denarian working on our side. We'd know who Nicodemus is at the least, and Thorned Namshiel if he hasn't been careful and concealed his identity for just such a situation.

---------- Post automerged at 11:36 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:35 PM ----------

We don't get anything if we kill her now. This is worth the risk, god damn it, because we'd be effectively eliminating an entire scum faction as well as adding to our own number in one fell swoop.

 

Dammit, I can confirm she's not St. Giles because I'm one of them. That means she's Denarian if all you're going off of is communication, which means we have a confirmed scum to eliminate rather then let her screw us!

 

Heh, this should be interesting.

 

I'm not going to night kill Ashaya if she's not lynched because:

1) That would crap on the plan of purifying her if she's a Denarian.
2) I think she's a scum role with night protection.
3) Even if she's Marcone, don't you think that roleblocker scum will target her so she can't launch her revenge kill that pierces everything?

I just thought of point 3. Doesn't this make roleclaiming Marcone completely useless? Sure, we don't know night priority with certainty but it's impossible that my night kill acts before the roleblocking powers.

 

Aekiel plan is sound. Let the Knights check Ashaya and let lynch Kalas. Stojil nk's some other person that he suspects. We take a risk, but there is a good Polish proverb for this: Who doesn't risk, doesn't eat. I say: let us take this risk.

 

If you kill her during the night what's the point of the Knights targeting her? For God's sake Stojil, this could be a game winner for us. This is worth the risk.

---------- Post automerged at 11:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:43 PM ----------

Oh wait, read that wrong. Never mind. Thanks, Stojil.

 

I'm neither overwhelmed nor holding back, personally I think I've made some good points. I don't think I've not posted any less often than I did in Warlock although my word count might be lower since I've been using a kindle instead of a computer. I've been trying to just modify my writing style to make every comment as direct as possible so that I still communicate the same thoughts despite using fewer words.

In terms of meta, I absolutely have no problem with it and think that if someone isn't keeping track of their own meta and playing accordingly then its their own fault that there's a noticeable difference between their town and scum play.

---------- Post automerged at 07:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:44 PM ----------

Stojil if you think she's scum please nk her. If Aekiel's right then she'll survive your nk and be turned although your nk will be wasted. If aekiel's wrong and she's still scum then she probably won't get lynched tomorrow either and then that's two nights instead of one with her being able to use her action.

 

I think this simply means she was lying about not checking her QT and about being Marcone. But whatever, man. Hoping for the best:

Rescind vote
Deadline Lynch: Kalas

Knights purify Ashaya and I'll post who my target is going to be before night starts.

---------- Post automerged at 12:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:50 AM ----------

Wait... would she survive my night kill even if she's purified?

Riley, I think we need you.

 

Well, it's been a good game. I swear, if Ashaya doesn't save the rest of the town after this... to my other member, good luck. (And yeah, I'm kind of predicting my own death in the night or two ahead now)

Here's the only flavor text from our QT that I can give to try and back-up my claim, so Knights, kindly do your duty and purify the fuck out of Ashaya tonight!

Rescind vote.

Deadline lynch: Kalas.

 

I don't think I've posted any less*

 

Fuck it. Let's GO ALREADY!

Rescind Vote

Lynch Vote: Kalas

My god, the bandwagon keeps jumping around today...

 

After the cleansing, she wouldn't be a Denarian anymore, technically. Does she keep her two night kills immunity?

 

Alright, I missed something... why the hell did zen just claim?

 

Because Aekiel thought Ashaya could be possible St. Giles due to her not complaining about boredom like she usually does.

 

To confirm that Ash isn't St. Giles. If Aekial is right that she's in communication with someone, its got to be another Denarian as the only other option, and we won't keep dicking around and waste our lynch or NK on her, but hope the Knights do their job.

 

I wish I hadn't started the qt quoting now. I think I'll ban it in Doctor Who Hunt.

 

Zennith started it.

---------- Post automerged at 01:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 AM ----------

Riley, answer my question instead of thumbing posts up!!!

:awesome

Pretty please?

 

Kalas: 2(13)
EternityLost (deadline)
Snowflake (deadline)
Castiel (deadline)
Aziraphale (deadline)
LochNess (deadline)
Franki (deadline)
Custer
Aekiel (deadline)
Lindsey (deadline)
SneakThief (deadline)
Uncle Stojil (deadline)
Zenzao (deadline)
EvanTide

Ashaya: 0(2)
Moridin (deadline)
SmileoftheKill (deadline)
Draconian139 (deadline)


Draconian139: 0(1)
Ashaya (deadline)

Have not voted: 6/24
Gambit (CommanderBond)
klackerz
Kalas
Vesvius
Kensington
Moridin

On the topic of quoting QTs. I had a small conniption and calmed down to realize that it was ok due to the limited amounts of communication. Hopefully people will try to keep it to a minimum. Also

2 HOURS LEFT IN THE DAY. YOU HAVE ENOUGH VOTES TO LYNCH KALAS AT 9pm EST(US). If you wish to hurry this up, change you vote to a regular vote and I will start the night early otherwise, you have 1 hour and 55 minutes as of this post.

 

Rescind Vote

Vote Player: Riley Poole

Yous trollin'. [And yes, in case you can't tell, this is a joke.]

 

But, I voted.

---------- Post automerged at 07:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:08 PM ----------

Oh, I voted and I didn't vote. I'm awesome.