I obviously can't exactly tell you why, but I honestly honestly believe it.

 

Notice: If the conversation's good and stuff, I can extend the lynch voting for up to 12 hours or so.

There is 48 hours in each day, but I'm willing to allow up to 60 for Day 1.

 

For the sake of having a fun game I'm opposed to that. It could be too good for town.

 

And in the list of scummiest posts so far, this one shoots straight to the top.

---------- Post automerged at 10:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:42 PM ----------

That said, I'm against extending deadlines on principle, and as much as I'd love the town to have an extra advantage like that, it doesn't make it very fun for those playing scum. It also means I know when the day is going to end every day, which is good for me since I have a work-sleep schedule that changes every week.

 

We'll see what happens. I just don't like cutting off discussion immediately at a certain point, but I highly doubt there will be large posting traffic by the time it draws to the deadline.

/me shrugs.

 

You would think so, but like I said I'm worried about the quality of the game.

 

So you say his post is scummy Aekiel, then proceed to make the exact same post just worded nicely and longer.

Ooookay.

 

Alright, he's probably scum who is going to eat my pancreas, but I'm going to throw Aekiel a bone.

Vote Mayor: Aekiel

I do like playing with him, despite the fact that he has a tendency to be 95% evil if he survives the first night.

 

It wasn't so much what he said, because I agree with it, as the way he said it. He held himself apart from the town. Then again, it may just be that there's no way to say 'I don't want deadline extensions' without seeming scummy. It certainly seems that way when I try varying the words some.

 

Aekiel and Aziraphale, since the mayor vote is down to you two:

How would you use the Asylum ability?
Do you think that your role is valuable enough to deserve a second life?

Also, one of the main reasons as to why I voted for Aziraphale over Aekiel, is that Aekiel's main reasoning for him not being scum is that he's almost always town. In all honesty that doesn't mean anything and he's just as likely to be scum as say, Ashaya.

 

I don't find Gambit's post scummy given what I've been told enough times in #mafia while trying to design the Lord of the Rings game- keep it fair enough for all sides. Expanding the day just to suit our purposes is perhaps only a slight inconvenience toward the scum, but still.

It could also benefit them, but only if they could get a scum as Mayor, and for the moment I don't have any pings off my scumdar from Aekial who is in the lead for the position right now so that's kind of a moot point.

 

When reading Ollie's post, it sounds super scummy but I don't think any scum is going to make that big of a slip up day one. I think he is town and just wants to keep the game fair.

Like Jangel said, Aziraphale saying that the town would be making a big mistake not going for him just doesn't make sense. He doesn't know the other candidates roles and it isn't like there is only going to be one role that is good for the Mayor position. Ont hat note.

Rescend Mayor Vote

 

I'd use the Asylum ability in either of two ways, depending on the circumstances: First, to put those I think are scum (or whom I'm persuaded are scum through good argument) into the Asylum for everyone to vote on. Second, I'd put in those who we need more proof of innocence/guilt (because the Asylum acts as a roleblock). If somebody had claimed as the Aekiel (lol), for instance, but was still under suspicion of being scum, I would place them in the Asylum so that we can see whether the true Aekiel (LOL) would use his ability or not.

Actually, I haven't said that in a good few games. I know the laws of probability as well as anyone else. Just because I've been town/scum before doesn't mean I'm town/scum this time.

 

Mayor vote: Aekiel

Meh, everyone is scum to me but it might as well be Aekiel as Mayor. I think Aekiel is smarter than Azi and my logic is this.

Vote for idiot,
If Town
Idiot Mayor,
If Scum,
Has teammates anyways.

Vote for someone smart,
If Town,
Smart Mayor.
If Scum,
Has teammates anyways.

 

Sacrifice, Dresden 2 >_>

Just saying.

And with that, I'm off for the remainder of today.

 

[Mayor Vote]

Note: I am sorry I never clarified this, but this is a Plurality Vote rather than a Majority Vote (it makes far more sense, etc).

Azira - 4 || Azira, Jangel, Gambit, Mishie
Aekiel - 9 || Aekiel, Republic, Zenzao, Seratin, Ashaya, Taure, Fishy Justice, Kensington, SmileofTheKill
Vesvius - 1 || Vesvius

No Vote Yet - 7: Stojil, Snowflake, jwlk, Fenraellis, Kalas, LochNess

This is as of Post #75.

[Post Or I Will Replace Your Ass]

Fenraellis, jwlk, Republic.

D8

 

Wow just noticed I put Rescend not Rescind. But I can't edit that. So maybe that's why you didn't count it Lungs, but:
Rescind Mayor Vote

 

Hey I posted! I was just busy yesterday :l

Like I said, Aekiel and Azir are the only two candidates When town, Ollie plays oddly. And Ashaya threw herself of the market pretty quickly... I don't remember her EVER doing that before, even when it was sure she wasn't going to win.

Doesn't matter who I vote at this point, but I am now wary of Aekiel because Ashaya voted for him >_>

 

If it makes you feel any better, you're not the only one that think that it's a bit odd that Ashaya swapped her vote to Aekiel so quickly.

 

Lungs, wtf? I posted, and voted. I just didn't have any further comments to make, as of yet.