Aurion makes a good point about Lungs.

 

Okay, awake now, but I do need to leave for uni soon so I'll have to keep this short. From what I can see, it's amusing that not only are people lynching me because of the same reason why they thought I was town on day 1, because I asked questions of people and wanted to get reactions. It's just that apparently most people didn't bother to read everything in the the thread and assumed the worst, probably because I phrased things badly and I was playing with a few misunderstandings about some of the game mechanics.

Anyway, here's a question for Kaidash and Lungs: Although yes I do feel that a lynch vote CAN be used to pressure somebody into answering questions, but now, people that have been acting scummy all game, like thebrute7 and strikerlee1 are able to join a bandwagon and just use the excuse of "I'm just pressuring him". Considering I've already explained why I thought it was a good idea, and dropped it due to other peoples opinions, care to explain guys?

And Stojil, I'm sad to say this but this is how Ashaya tries to play town, she screws around and posts nonsense, and whenever people accuse her of being useless, she just screams out that we'll regret lynching her and that she's a really important role. The best part is when she rages on IRC, since for some reason she always gets night killed early when she has fun roles...

Also, it's interesting that some people like Lutris have been very active in IRC, but still can't find the time to post in the thread...

 

Hence crappy player.

And it's also terribly easy to hide behind that as scum.

Aekiel, what do you think of mishie?

 

This right here is exactly the reason people are suspicious of you. It's not our job to assume that you are a town member, you need to convince us that, and so far you haven't even come close.

 

People I want to hear more from:

Castiel
Menace
LochNess
Aekiel
Platypus_Assassin

Give me your top 3 scum reads, and if you haven't, vote for the top one.

 

Alright, it does make more sense and I did misread the post before so that was my bad.

 

thebrute7, since you came by but missed it:

Please, tell me where you get this from.

(Subtle) white-knighting will not go unpunished.

 

These two pretty much go hand in hand, so I might as well kill two birds with one stone.

These are my top three scum reads so far:

1. Ashaya- She pretty much solidified her spot as my number one suspect with that god awful post about trolling and regret.

2. Lungs- He's been almost as bad as Ashaya in terms of posting lots and lots of nothing, so he'll take this spot.

3. Mishie- His plan was pretty damn terrible, and even though it reeks of derpy town, I'm not going to discount the possibility of equally derpy scum.

You'll notice I didn't include StrikerLee in my list of suspects, and that's for one simple reason that's already been brought up: He's like Mishie, but multiplied by a million. He derped so hard that I just know he can't be scum because no self-respecting Coven would let him dig himself a hole as deep as he has.

Or maybe he's just the Omni of this game. >.>

So, in regards to jwlk's post: I'm... not sure. I'm tempted to cite Seratin, for obvious reasons, but I refuse to believe Ashaya would be that stupid. And Seratin himself has struck me as pretty town so far, so eh. At this point, I'd probably go with Lungs, because of the scummy vibes I'm getting from him and the exchange between the two of them earlier.

Oh, also: Deadline Lynch Vote: Ashaya

Thought I'd already done that.

 

Don't count out the possibility that scumbuddies are throwing him under the bus to throw suspicion off of them, mind you. But I'm inclined to agree that he's more likely to be derping town than scum. Probably.

 

Hi Seratin.

How does your opinion change if I tell you I have no need to be told who is in the court.

 

If you were to say that I'd say that it has no affect on my opinion at all. That would be implying that you're on the court and while being on the court is a good thing for members of the town, it's also a good thing for scum.

Knowing who is on the court doesn't make you innocent, Kai.

 

If I were scum and on the court, why would I want anyone on my team to suggest a -town plan that nets my team useless information? Like, how does that forward my hypothetical scum plans in the slightest?

I think you've started at a place 'kai is scum' then lined up all the pieces in order to get yourself to that place.

Also you're chainsaw defending Lungs and Ashaya while downplaying their lack of everything, so that is a Thing too.

 

Not intentionally you wouldn't. Mishie could easily have derped and jumped the gun before being reigned back in.

You're right though, maybe I stared too hard in your direction and things saw things that weren't there. Maybe. Possibly. I still believe either you or Mishie, possibly both of you are scum. Nice image though. I've noticed stuff like that a lot in your posts, Kai. You know how to write a good one. Drop in a pic like that, some vet mafia lingo and try to connect dots that aren't there. Yeah. That's a Thing.

I really don't care either way about Lungs or Ashaya. Their posts have been empty and trollish. It doesn't help town one little bit. Pressure them as much as you like and if one of them cracks and turns out to be scum, I'll be happy out. Town +1.

I just want to remind people that pressuring someone who is dominating the conversation as much as you are is a good idea too. I've never liked people who try to steer town and it's nothing personal, but in this game, I've just got a bad feeling about you.

Again though, you could have the same about me and we'd go around in circles.

 

Since apparently I have no content, I'm going to be the King of Candid Posting D:

Since I am town!Lungs and town!Lungs is super legit and stuff. >_>

READWALL1.0

Eidolonic

I have le heavy town read on Eidolorrrrrrnic. I've had the pleasure of playing several games with him, and he is super transparent scum. Blah. It's just something I'm 100% metacertain of. D:

Ollie

Ollie's main problem is that he derps as town and derps as scum so we can't get anything but a nullread from him. This is proven fact. That being said, I do not like a lot of what he's said. >_>

Sesc

I'm not okay with sesc in this game. There's a whole bunch of things that he's said which are minor scumtells, but he's a smart guy and generally, bigass scumtells are badly logick'd out stuff that derpy scum does, and if he's scum he wouldn't do that stuff I think etc.

The problem is that there's subtle connection building in a whole lot of his posts and that's badshit.jpg. Like I'm not sure if he's trying to warn the elder witches of his fellow members or something, but I'm super unsatisfied with the general tone which does NOT read like previous incarnations of town!sesc.

Lungs

I am super cool, so I'm in forest green and...

Brown.



Seratin

I am surprisingly okay with a lot of the things that Seratin says, but mostly because it looks like he's accidentally whiteknighting me through texas and massacres and stuff. (ehehe I'm so witty!)

I dislike how he's grouped me with Ash, but I think this is a null thing because town doesn't want to be grouped with potential scum and scum doesn't want to be grouped at all.

What I don't like - why he's not a 70/30 town/scum read for me, or better, is because he seems to be looking for easy targets for his wrath. And honestly, things like the whole Mishie debacle was so bad it probably wasn't a scum slip, but I might be drunk on the wine here.

Sirion

I am 70/30 on Sirion being town because of magic raisins. If you go through the list of magic raisins of why I might think so, and take into account that I'm only 85% idiot, you might be able to work out why, but it has something to do with exactly how he went after Klackerz.

Maybe I'm being forcefed the wine and successful gambit was successful, but like, I'm not so sure about my previous read on him.

Mishie

I was okay with him until obvious derp. I already discussed it at length when I was reading Serachinius, but I'm like, rereading the text of his post atm. Assuming it's not prepared (I think Mishie's smarter than posting something like that if it were prepared), there are some mildly unproblematic things with it.

This isn't phrased as weirdly as people seem to think, lending more credence to scum!sesc, actually, because once he jumped onto it, everyone else bandjumped onto that shit like it was the hot shit or something. I must admit that I autothought that he was scum for a moment. But if you read it, it's not super incriminating, I think.

Bold are mine. The grammar is super town here. So stuff. I might have to revise my read on Seratin or something. But this is Wall 1.0 and it's super overdue anyway.

bob99

This post is super town, but he really doesn't have enough content to judge, imo.

Klackerz

I am like, 100% sure he is scum. This is not legit. I've explained my reasoning, and it seems that people don't fucking agree. And I'm sort of annoyed at the whole super ungood aura he has. And I think we should lynch him. My lynch vote is still on him. And if I don't lynch him, I hope to god that court kills him or something.



Menace

His posting is super ironic because HE of all people is accusing me of empty posting. Well at least I post, bro >_> I am not so satisfied with the sloppy Ashaya voting. Ashaya's meta is, like, trolling and regret (lol), but I have yet to see anyone actually justify a whole bunch of votes, and he's like, super representative of the people who haven't done so.

So this isn't really a specific read because not enough to read specifically. Because content is ++, guys. And I have content. And I hate all of you for making me do this D: WHY DO I PLAY THIS GAME? WHY DO I LOVE THIS GAME?



CheddarTrek

I am good with cheddar this game because she candidposts. Like, none of the posts look prepared at all, which is generally a scum things, unless you're lungs, but I'm like naturally scummy anyway.

Town-Null. Bah.

StrikerLee

StrikerLee is in two colors because I think he's town but I'm super unsatisfied with his posts.

Like, I would be k with someone offing him because the level of derp is just over 9000. D:

Like, the way he posts reminds me of warlockollie, which makes me think that there's actually a chance he might be a junior witch.

But like, if he had teammates, posting like that would be something that would not be allowed and stuff, so I don't even know, man.



Lutris

It walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, speaks japanese like a duck, so it's probably town!lutris.

But there are some non-duck things that Lutris has performed in. Like, disappearing. Ducks don't disappear. Geddinhere and like, explain yourself, sir D:

Bill Door

Other than magicbagging, there are some substantially town raisins in his posting habits which I like. Some of this stuff reminds me of town!lungs when I was starting out and stuff.

Castiel

Fucking post, dude. D:

LochNess

Post more, you sea monster! D:

jwlk

Town jwlk, for whatever the hell this is worth because jwlk is good enough so that early day jwlk is unreadable.

I like his grammar, but he knows how to doctor it, etc. I like his post content, but he definitely knows how to doctor THAT. D:

And reading his post was part of the reason I'm making this read wall.

Okay guys, I might be counterproductive!town!Lungs. Fuck all of you. lol.

guljons

Has disappeared. Come back!

thebrute7

Maybe he's a noob, but I don't like his bandwagonness. Like, everything he says is a bandwagon vote or something. And that's annoying. I'm not sure he's scum, but... talk more D:

Aekiel

Post more bro.

coleam

I don't like how he's echoing Klackerz. Like, I super don't like that. The way by which his posts are phrased are grammatically questionable, etc. He like, aggros hard on Mishie and talks about nothing else, which sort of tells me that he wants mishie dead for whatever reason, so either it's a bus (lol d2 bus wtf is this I don't even, don't laugh at me, Kai), or he's just trying to get him killed for whatever reason.

That annoys me. Getting random people who've derped get hit like that just means scum has more time, and time is life in mafia, etc.

Kalas

I like Kalas because he's scumhunting and the stuff he says is very analysis heavy and thought out. foreverscum!Krogan is right in that he'll become more and more dangerous if he lives so we should probably protect him or something.

BY THE POWER OF ANGELREACH (greyskull + demonreach + witchhunt's angels >_>), PROTECT someone. Maybe not Kalas, but please, one of my town reads or something.

Ashaya

Generic Ash is generic. I know she hasn't been playing much because TravelLer!Ash, but I'm a bit blargh about that. She could post better stuff than trolling. Makes me think of DE1 and DLPhunt, tbh.

Worst yet, she doesn't really have time to play so I can't really analyze her interest. That's how I metaread her and stuff.

Uncle Stojil

Despite the fact that Uncle Stolijili would be terribly fearsome scum (I think >_>), I think that we have nothing to fear from him! Nothing he will do will make us cry uncl- okay. That's just bad.

Like, there are a whole bunch of town!stojil things that I see; his attitude, his general annoying OMGUS (that stands for oh my god you suck, since none of you like jargon), etc.

Tbh, it's more of a nullread, but meta.

KaiDASH

Oh, I never know what to think of you, because I know you're capable of making me your fool, KaiBABY.

/me rolls.

Okay. Like, I'm okay with Kai this game because he encourages participation and player interest, which is a net ++ for town. Like, generally, he's more passive aggressive as scum.

Aurion

Allreplacementsarescum.jpg At the risk of sounding like a reverse-voting-issue sort of guy, I'd like to venture that Aurion's been playing super scummily ever since he came onto the scene. Maybe we're the Stanford Prison Experiment over here, but his postgrammar is making me raise my delicate chinkese eyebrows >_>

Moridin

I am not okay with Moridin this game. He usually performs as a competent town player, etc etc. I've given my reasons, and they might be D1ish and somewhat inept (on purpose?) but like, I'm nearly certain of the Klackerz/Moridin link.



Platypus_Assassin

Who? What? Post?

...

K guys.

I have been doing too much of



And not enough of



in this thread.

Bah.

 

amazing post is win, still not sure if I trust you, but I'll wait to kill you. The only time I wasn't obvious scum was when I was Thomas in Dresden 2, and that's because I was just a replacement and pushing Lara!Jon's agenda.

I think Lungs is right about most people in the above, and I have a few people I actually trust... so I'll

LYNCH BY THE DERP, FOR THE DERP, ON THE DERP: STRIKERLEE

 

Omg. I'm so sad he died. I loved Jacques. D:

 

That's more like it.

Rescind Vote.

Hey Menace, 3 Townreads? Non-Eid please since everyone is getting strong Town off him.

---------- Post automerged at 01:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:48 AM ----------

Also, what do you think of Lungs' wall? What do you think about the reverse-call on you not posting?

 

Wow Lungs. That was.. wow. Why couldn't you have posted like that in Dresden haha?

Anyway, just popping in before bed and I need to say a few things. Specifically about the mishie bandwagon. I challenged him on what I considered a very suspect 'plan' that couldn't be anything other then a bad scum play. There was some confusion on game mechanics, some misunderstandings but as of post #402 I'm sitting at a town read.

What concerns me is how fast a bandwagon built after I posted (and without the Striker derps I think it would be sitting near a majority) as that wasn't my intent at all. For now though

Rescind Vote

There's no good case right now for scum!mishie. Park those votes elsewhere.

StrikerLee: The way he's been going is assissted suicide. So you can look at it as a scum player trying for an all or nothing gamble or a town player derping like there's no tomorrow. Iirc somewhere in that mess Striker mentioned only playing because of his friend? That sound like a far likelier scenario to me then playing chicken with the Lynch vote.

Ashaya: Non post filler. And I haven't played enough games with her to have an early game meta read. What I do know is Ashaya comes alive late game, which.. could be good or bad depending on where the RNG fell. What I do know is there are a couple, better, Lynch candidates out there today.

Speaking of which:

Sesc, Moridin, klackerz

There have been multiple people commenting on your scumness. Looking back over your past posts what would you say were your biggest posted 'scumtells'? Try to avoid copy pasting other players posts if you can.