I agree, and it's not how I'd play it. But he has been extremely busy and stuff, and I can understand him playing it this way taking that into account?

It's not an absolute for me, it's just trying to make the situation make sense.

---------- Post automerged at 07:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:37 PM ----------

7 more minutes and I'm hammering.

Last chance to say something, folks.

---------- Post automerged at 07:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:43 PM ----------

Ash, checks tonight. Feel free to ignore me, by the way. Goes without saying.

Kalas, Cheddar or Jwlk.

Re-read day one in light of stuff that's happened, and I'm uneasy.

---------- Post automerged at 07:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:48 PM ----------

HAMMERTIME

Night has begun. Don't post!

 

Day has begun.

Moscone says Lungs and CheddarTrek are dead.

 

Well, Lungs is likely the Court pick. Cheddar was scummy, but not enough to warrant a kill by the court, and now I'm assuming she wasn't scum at all.

 

Makes you wonder why the coven chose to go after her. She was suspicious enough to garner a couple votes, so normally you'd expect the witches to leave her around to help misdirect the lynch. Therefore, something must have made her a big enough target to go after despite the scummy vibes she gave some people.

I'm thinking that we might have a scumquisitor and that CheddarTrek checked Holy on Night 3. So if that's the case, let's check to see who voted for her yesterday: guljons and Eidolonic. Eidolonic put a vote on her to goad her into answering his question, but then guljons jumped right on, calling her a potential lynch target when she had one vote, and that one only to get her to post. He said he was willing to switch, but he never did. It's not much to go on, I know, but it's better than the largely lousy readwalls we saw on Day 4.

So, for now:

Vote: guljons

 

Sup guys. I found a Coven member. Kalas is guilty. On that note.

Lynch vote: Kalas

 

Calm down there speed racer. You have to consider that there a number of possible explanations, one in particular being that Cheddar could have been the Martyr. It would make a lot more sense and even explain her overall passiveness. Didn't want to make a target of herself and die before she could make use of her role. Feel free to correct me on this, but I don't believe a Martyr sacrifice is announced in thread, so it's a distinct possibility.

 

Cool, I like this. I switched to No Lynch so that Kalas doesn't get hammered, might as well have some time to talk. I'll vote for Kalas in a few days. And we might as well be disecting Kala's posts.

 

Welp. Lynch is a go, I suppose.

Lynch Vote: Kalas

Though do make sure there's a slot or two left open so we can get some discussion in.

 

Well, this makes things simpler...

Rescind Vote: guljons

Vote: Kalas

So now the question is: do we hammer, or do we talk for a bit? I'd like to figure out why Cheddar was knocked off by the coven at least.

 

We definitely talk for a bit. We have almost 4 days, and while I don't think we need that much time, I definitely want to make sure EVERYONE has posted.

 

Oh, right, martyr. Forgot about that.

 

Yeah, I like that theory better. There were definitely a few good choices for a matyr save the last day.

 

It's definitely the preferable option - I'd rather have her be the Martyr than for the Inquisitor to be scum (though that's still a possibility, I suppose *shudders*).

 

Two thoughts:

1. Do not hammer Kalas super-early. You're sacrificing our discussion time if you do.

2. StrikerLee is Town. As per this. And it's pretty probable that CheddarTrek was too.

Lungs...not sure. I'd think he was Town Survivalist- since it's really likely the Court targeted him Night 3, I'm not sure the logic checks out for targeting him again Night Four. Which (if I'm right) would make him the Scum kill.

---------- Post automerged at 09:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:31 PM ----------

Well, three thoughts.

 

Er, why wouldn't the Court target Lungs a second time? He didn't post any tl;dr, read wall, etc. to validate himeslf- hell, he didn't post anything until the last couple hours- so it would make sense for them to hammer home the kill in case of Recluse/Gambler/Survivalist/etc. Since none of those roles are Holy, it would only make sense.

Also, StrikerLee. At this point, you're about as close to confirmed town as you're gonna get. I'd suggest you actually start posting content, rather than agreeing with everyone else and laying low. If you're town it's not really important that you live, just that town wins.

 

Because Survivalist -life literally has no powers, and kills would just bounce off Lovers who are Town anyways?

---------- Post automerged at 09:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:47 PM ----------

Also, if Castiel's Recluse RR is genuine that means a NK Night three would have gone through on Lungs. Gambler is immune on even Nights.

You really should read the game rules before spouting off about them, Menace.

 

I wasn't entirely sure which of the two immortal roles would have survived, so I just listed both. Pardon me. And besides that, your logic goes both ways. At this point, I think it's more likely that Court followed through than Coven targeting a vanilla/potentially immortal player.

 

All right, so here are the records of Kalas's lynch votes:
Day 1:
Kalas voted to lynch Klackerz. (6)*
*Only vote of the day
(6: bob99, Lungs, Uncle Stojil, Geabe, Kalas, and thebrute7)
The town has lynched Geabe (16)!
(16: jwlk, KaiDASH, coleam, Ollie, StrikerLee, Moridin, Sesc, Klackerz, Seratin, Sirion, Fenraellis, castiel, Eidolonic, Lutris, Uncle Stojil, and Bill Door)


Day 2:
Kalas voted to lynch Mishie. (2)
(2: Eidolonic, and Kalas)
Kalas removed their lynch vote on Mishie. (5)
(5: Eidolonic, Seratin, CheddarTrek, thebrute7, and StrikerLee)
Kalas voted to lynch Klackerz. (10)
(10: Lungs, Moridin, Eidolonic, Bill Door, CheddarTrek, Sirion, Uncle Stojil, StrikerLee, Seratin, and Kalas)
The town has lynched Klackerz (15)!
(15: Lungs, Moridin, Eidolonic, Bill Door, CheddarTrek, Sirion, Uncle Stojil, StrikerLee, Seratin, Kalas, Ollie, Aurion, castiel, Lutris, and jwlk)

Day 3:
Kalas voted to lynch StrikerLee. (8)*
*Only vote of the day I could find.
(8: Ollie, guljons, thebrute7, Lutris, Ashaya, Aekiel, Eidolonic, and Kalas)
The town has lynched castiel!

Day 4:
Didn't find a lynch vote in the logs. Correct me if I'm wrong though.
The town has lynched Lutris!

Ok, here is what I think. On Day 1 Kalas voted for Klackerz and stuck with it. So I would say that I was wrong about Klackerz and he was town. And he didn't join the bandwagon on Gaebe. So that makes it more likely that Gaebe was coven or potential jw.

On Day 2 Kalas put an early vote on mishie and stuck to it. I would say that Mishie was town and was a coven kill that night. Then Kalas changed the votes to Klackerz, which would make sense if he was town.

Day 3 Kalas voted for Strikerlee. With that and his scumread on StrikerLee I would say Striker is town.

Day 4, Kalas didn't vote.

 

it's nice that we finally have scum, Kalas I'll convince everyone to hammer someone else if you reveal one scumbuddy each day.

Trust me, other people are in on this too!