How was it horrifically stupid? The stuff at the beginning of the day stemmed from a misunderstanding on how the Gravedigger check worked. I was under the impression that a JW would return Town when checked by anything before joining the Coven, but Mori said that he checked JW. I didn't actually think jwlk was Coven - I just thought Mori was scum slipping up.

My questioning of your rolereveal was justified. There wasn't much sense to it (you weren't an obvious target), it came right after the previously revealed "Bishop" died, and you weren't backed up by the Nun.

My support of the Kalas lynch was justified: you were worried about him being the Pauper, but since I'm the Pauper, I knew he wasn't. Also, at that point, I had no idea how many people were left on the Court, so lynching the known EW was the better choice in my eyes.

Or was it the plan I came up with? The only problem with that was that no one trusted my role reveal. From my perspective, there was zero risk at all. If the Twilight Pagan revealed, then I get lynched and TP activates. No one dies. We then would get all Elder+Junior witch identities the next night, while you have Angel protection. Sure, the Court gets an extra kill, but I'd sacrifice one person to learn the identities of every remaining scum. If no Twilight Pagan, then we continued with the existing plan (disband the Court or lynch the revealed scum).

I think that covers just about all of my posts yesterday.

 

See, there's just way too many ifs there. And my plan was objectively better.

Besides that, I think I said all that needs to be said about that plan yesterday.

It almost sounds reasonable now that you've had a while to stew on it, though!

 

Alright, Lynch: Kalas but I'm not going to throw my vote up there right now. We want to get some discussion in before we hammer right? Right.

 

Well this sucks.
Thanks for the 16 hour day yesterday, didn't even get to post.
All I can say- angels did something right tonight and we didn't take the risk.

Why would I kill you Aurion? You are already used and don't have nothing new to offer.

 

I advise a period of deep contemplation if you can't guess why murdering prominent Town players is a good idea.

Fair point on the whole, though.

 

Well there some other prominent Town players I would like to kill.

 

I don't suppose I could convince you to do us all a favor and bump off KaiDASH. :v

 

I've posted fairly consistently since I've arrived. I mean, I've been in here what... several hours, and definitely posted at least 4 times. I'll try to post more so you can get a read on me.

You're definitely in my radar. At first you seemed somewhat desperate/spastic, now you've posted that you don't mind being lynched. That flip flop makes me somewhat suspicious.
At the time, you had not fleshed out your plan well. I got the feeling that it was rushed. That made me suspicious.
It's completely possible that you're just a complete derp town, but we'll see how other people post and the reads I can get on them.

People who I think are town:
Aurion and Gambit. I don't think Bill is a JW, but I'm open to it. I think Sirion is more likely.

 

Not prominent Town, but it'd be really nice of you!

---------- Post automerged at 04:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:01 PM ----------

Uh, Rick, Mori just said Bill's a JW. You mean coleam?

 

Probably I'm getting the hang of who's who.

 

Or maybe you meant bob. I do agree that JW!Siri is a fairly strong possibility.

Also eeeeeerrrrr, Rick, Ollie and I are Townfirmed. I don't think we qualify for coleam's questions.

 

why do you think I'm jw Aurion? I defended Ollie the other night pretty strongly.

 

I feel like Menace is town. That's about it. He's posting somewhat regularly, and his posting style doesn't give me a lot of scum vibes. I'm considering almost everyone except confirmed town for JW until I see more posts.

Once I see Bob and Bill post more, I'll make a decision about them.

 

bob: I'm nowhere close to 100% hence why you're in the last group:

Not supergreat posts on the whole, and the Jwlk lynch actually kinda worked for scum so revealing Ollie as holy actually would kind of work. (admittedly this is wine)

I also didn't like this post at all in particular. Or...really much of anything you said yesterday tbqh.

If it makes you feel any better, you're the least Witch-y of the four listed in the last group. But I don't have enough to rule you out.

--

Rick: BILL IS DEAD HE WON'T BE POSTING ANY MORE. ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT COLEAM?

---------- Post automerged at 04:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:22 PM ----------

ebwop*: kind of work so long as the JWs didn't think Ollie is Bishop. Like I said, wine. Not damning at all, just hmmworthy.

 

yes... I am. Sorry. Long day.

 

If I had to power-rank my last group it'd probably go Siri-Rick-Menace-bob.

Sirion's not an active scumread, but he's been shading on the scummy side of null for me pretty much the whole game.

I'd lol like hell if Rick and/or Taure were JWs (for the record, my Taure read is essentially null, I'd like him to post more).

 

You forgot my Aurion. I am also confirmed town.

In any event, If I had to say, I think that Sirion would be my preferred lynch choice (after kalas/guljons obviously). Sirion's posts have rubbed me the wrong way the whole game, but since I never had anything remotely concrete to say about it...

 

It was in reference to Rick saying Ollie and I are his townreads, not a general statement. >_>

 

This game has had many people having townreads on confirmed town players.
Go figure.

 

Honestly, I think that, if the Midnight Pagan is still alive and town, now is the time to use your ability. We lynch Kalas, skip the nightphase, lynch guljons, ensuring that if there are any spies alive, they join coven without having a chance to be killed, reveal remaining witches, town wins.

Now is the time if you live.

---------- Post automerged at 02:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:20 PM ----------

I meant Twilight pagan, sorry.