Frankly I still have no idea about scum or not, tells are too early to really act upon. I think the idea for a judge lynch could be fine, seriously I think it was obvious people were only talking about day1 judge lynch. Beyond that makes no sense.

 

You missed my own and Castiel's Lump vote.

Also, don't vote for KaiDASH, vote for meeeee.

 

I'll follow half of your advice, Ash, since the game is picking up. Rescind Lump Vote and also, because lol Rescind Lynch Vote.

We'll see.

 

Lumpfriend Votals
Ash: (2) Ash, Castiel
Jwlk: (2) Jwlk, Uncle Stojil
KaiDASH: (2) Vira, KaiDASH
soundlyParanoid: (2) soundlyParanoid, Gambit
Dovaekiin: (1) Dovaekiin
Menace: (1) Menace

Abstaining: Kalas, Lungs, Zennith

This is a plurality vote.

Lynch Votals
Castiel: (1) KaiDASH
Jwlk: (0+1) Kalas
KaiDASH: (1) Ash
Kalas: (0+1) Jwlk
Lungs: (1) Menace

Abstaining: Castiel, Dovaekiin, Gambit, Lungs, soundlyParanoid, Uncle Stojil, Vira, Zennith

Bold indicates Deadline Vote. With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

 

Come on people, it's day one. Where's the enthusiasm? I guess we need to start interrogating people to get this thing going properly.

An open question for anyone wanting Lump: What type of player would you say should have Lump (yourself not being a valid answer)? I would say a player of middling ability would be more appropriate for Lump than a power player, because there's a decent chance the scum would target said power player if they had the added bonus of having two votes. If they aren't scum already, that is.

KaiDASH: Tell us why you specifically should get Lump. Also, why the hate against fake votes? We're effectively doing the same thing as lynching someone conventionally, only we're preventing the witches from getting their Last Gasp in at the same time.

Lungs: Why did you vote to give Lump to Kai? Explain your reasoning!

Menace: Would you advocate letting the Judge lynch anyone after day one (whether by intent or mistake) knowing that there's a chance he has died already?

Dovaekiin: Why are you so awesome?

---------- Post automerged at 07:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:40 PM ----------

ebwop: Eido, you missed my vote for myself.

 

I gave the lump to kai for the same reasons I voted against Lungs.

because he's kaidash and I'm a kaibot and he taught me everything I used to know about pokemon and mafia and I want his babies and I think me and para are going to doubleteam him.

uhh

yeah.

---------- Post automerged at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:01 PM ----------

Okay, since I want to sort of play and be helpful and stuff, I'm going to do a metaread of everyone here for judgescenarios.

this is more of a note to people who don't know the other players like I do, I guess. I'm not sure if the best course of action is to assume worlds in which certain people are judges - there are 13 worlds, and that's too much work for D1, but I do think that if you're judge, I have a pretty good read on your capabilities.

Okay,

this is a message to YOU, you, reading this:

Find 5 people you would be okay with hitting. Yes, 5. That way, we can see where people's scumdars intersect and shit.

I'll do my 5 later, my fingers hurt and i'm dealing with financial aid things for college

 

Fuck you too, Lungs. Fuck you too.

Spoiler

inb4 I'm Judge and kill you out of spite.

 

When has that ever happened Lungs? Most of my dlp games I've been scum. Or died early haha.

 

Your sig xD

Keep in mind metareads are sonetimes closer to impressionism than realism, but can sometimes be no less true.

---------- Post automerged at 04:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:34 PM ----------

Ebwop: menace im fucking with you, you're not bad at mafia - not great, but not bad

 

Lol Batmafia. First and BEST game.

Lump Vote: soundlyParanoid

Working on my list of 5. Its hard keeping town we'd be better off without off the list xP

 

I doubt anyone has already 5 scum-reads this early. If we had to make a list now, it would mostly be meta-based... no scumdars intersecting, really.

I can say I'm wary of the random Lump-votes floating around, but that's about it.

 

Oh no, I don't expect for people to have reads until we're in like, the last 24 hours of D1 at least. It's just a question that I don't want to forget at this point, and I guess I want to steer everyone towards scumhunting rather than loads of metapunches and metakicks and other metafighting about who should be lumpy

 

Nope. Not unless the NK bounces tonight or the Martyr sacrifices themselves or blah blah blah. I just thought it'd be a nifty little way to get the Judge some playing time and give us some peace of mind for the day's lynch.

Right now nobody really stands out to me as teh scumz, but if I had to name two people I'd say soundlyParanoid and Vira. The former because of a general gut feeling and a few off posts and the latter because hardlurk and she was scum last game so she must be scum this game.

Spoiler

#StrikerLogic

So Rescind Lynch Vote: Lungs and Deadline Lynch Vote: soundlyParanoid.

And, er.

Just saw this. You forgot the no homo.

... Right?

 

Right.

Oops.

But it's a robot anyway, so it doesn't matter ;3

 

Eh. I just want someone who I think is town to get it, middling or power player.

Menace is getting an eye waggle for naming someone most people here would barely know and claiming a "Gut" read on 'em. And then Using Meta for the other when I am inclined to think meta is bullshit as people play different games differently, regardless of faction.

JWLK and Kalas is... Interesting. But it could also be town aggroing on town. Hmmm.

I don't like the "pick five people to possibly judge lynch" thing since it really fucks with pressure and making people accountable to their opinions. I'd fully expect people to wave at five or so people and go "yeah sure they're fine." Ignoring the fact at best that is two townies grouped with 3 witches. And at worst it's an assured mislynch with little real accountability for opinions.\

 

Okay, we have 13 people

Say we mislynch 2 townies: that's 9 (because nightkills) - 6-3 is less comfortable but at that point it should be super obvious if none of them die? idk, I think we're a relatively competent playerlist.

by n3 if we haven't hammered a witch we probably deserve to lose >_>

given dlp's track record scum usually dies pretty quick, it's just townpower shenanigans that mess us up

that being said, I have the opposite read from menace and I think lump: para is a good option for us

 

That's the thing though. You're a new addition and you're leading in the lump vote, which is basically a popularity/meta contest. Your post about the Judge lynch thing also read like scum trying to casually shoot down something that could hurt them in the future. Like I said, gut feeling. Not as if there's anything more substantial to go on Day 1.

My vote on Vira was largely a joke. The second part of it at least. Hence the spoiler'd bit. I'd still be fine with her being the second target though, among a couple other people, because lurking is still bad mkay.

 

Menace, stop with the #strikerlogic

---------- Post automerged at 12:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:47 AM ----------

ebwop: jesus christ, I just reread that entire selection, you're smarter than this, dude, don't shit out of your mouth

---------- Post automerged at 12:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:48 AM ----------

ebwop2: oops, did I just admit that I wasn't following this thread really closely? D:

 

What are you talking about? Feel free to share with the class why you think I've been led so far astray, Lungsy boy.

 

I've been drinking, bad time.

Also I might be overreacting, coming to think of it.

Uh, go read the mafia guide with the multiple pieces of advice from like, 20 people about how to be protown :\