I don't know. I've learned to base my reads of Ashaya on her behaviour in the current game thread, since I can never get decent meta reads off her. It's possible she was just being bitchy, but as it is that post is the single most suspicious thing put up today, which is saying something when you consider Lungs' Kai vote and the Menace/Kalas/Jwlk argument.

As well as that, if you've got a suspicion, put a vote on it. It pressures people into answering even if the Judge doesn't lynch them, since they don't know who the Judge will pick.

 

How is that post more suspicious than Lungs' random fuckery? I was just being rude for shits and giggles.

And jwlk baby, don't be that way.

 

Ash always plays this way, scum or town, for the first day because she has the attention span of <mean things>

Scum read: jwlk, because he feels off and I don't know why but I think it may be rolethings

other scum read: menace because he's still being reactionary as fuck? but I've had tons of interactions with him out of mafia and he's no different so I can't really tell.

scumread 3: vira because what why is everything bandwagonny?

town read 1: para because I can't read para for shit, but he plays like he did in the games I've analyzed from him

town read 2: aek because he's trying and I think scum would be a little less enthusiastic and more lukewarm

null read: everyone else because lolwhatposts

 

It's god damn difficult to get a read on you when you're alternating between lurking and trolling. In this case your post just reads scummy as fuck to me, and we've lynched people on way less than this.

 

Hey, everyone has to have fun somehow. And I like playing like this, if I was being completely serious, you guys would be like OMG ASH IS TRYING, SHE'S SCUM. It has happened before. Much better this way.

But seriously, Lungs' posts are way worse than mine, I don't even want to know what he's smoking.

 

Ash brought up Lungs' posts, and I figure since we broke out the meta, I should weigh in with my damaged two cents.

If lungs was scum, he wouldn't post so much while drunk, nor would he derp about (lol this is me saying this) this much.

 

Ash knows about everything I possibly smoke. D:

There are one or two serious things in some of my posts D:

 

Care to elaborate on them?

 

reads and vague game theory stuff that aren't exactly invalid, though they might be phrased badly. :\

omg why are you aggroing on me, this is uncomfortable :\

 

Your scumreads are bullshit. Both Menace and Jwlk, with Vira on top? I could see the reasoning for Vira, but Menace and Jwlk came up with a good plan for a day one lynch that at the very least drops the suspect pool by one. You just read as scum trying to hide his lack of reads amongst popular opinion.

Don't think I didn't see your town read on me either. That won't stop me from suspecting you.

 

Yeah, this is bullshit. Lungs, regardless of what state of mind he was in at the time, has at least weighed in with his scum reads and some questions for others and such. You on the other hand have done nothing but urge people to give you the lump, vote to lynch KaiDASH because "fuck you", and then bullshitted your way out of my question, which you still have yet to answer.

If this is how you have fun playing, fine, but don't expect us to leave you alive to fuck with us.

But hey, you don't deserve all of my scorn. Gambit, since you're around to post, hit us with two people you'd like the judge to pick from tonight and why. No meta. Gut feelings are fine, but do your best to give us something close to concrete.

 

I'm inclined to side with lungs in this argument at the moment - I feel Ashaya has been particularly scummy, although I can't claim that I have a good 5 scumreads or anything of the like. Ash and Lungs have both been skeptical to me, and hey, I dunno. Maybe Menace is the other person I would say? I have no good reason for it, but there it is.


And Lump Vote Aekiel because hell, it worked last time.

 

OKAY SINCE I HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF THIS

No, I'm not asking to be replaced.

In order of postcount:

Lungs: hey how're you doing, you ready to play yet?

Menace: may I have your revised opinion on judges, if it's changed (ignore if it hasn't?). Also, talk to me about martyrdom - at what point in the game is it good to activate?

Kalas: tell me how a pope should play.

Aekiel: may either I have a 3 page essay on why OMGUS is bad or tell me when hard confirm on innocent/guilty in this game should reveal - pope/leeroy when hit; priest

stojil: how much should meta affect a judge d1 decision; if you were judge and given the choice between two equally scummy players, how would you make a decision?

ash: which roles should get lump?

jwlk: which scum role poses the largest threat to town and how should we neutralize their power? (if you have a role and an idea to do it that relies on them not knowing, use common sense)

para: how should the angels do post analysis? should they reveal in deadchat? not going to lie, I just want you to tell me everything that the angels should do. XD

kai: when should the oracle reveal?

guys I am running out of good questions :\

actually, a really good one

Gambit, Vira, Zennith, Castiel: why are you lurking?

 

At this point, I think we should go through with Judge lynch today because there's only a day left and all that good stuff. In the future though I'll probably try to steer clear of organized Judge lynches because it kills interest. Or maybe it's just DLP. Meh.

Anyway, in regards to the Martyr I think there's a few ways they could work their role. One way is for them to activate Day 1 and simultaneously save and townfirm someone, thus putting their role to good use and not risking getting NK'd and letting it go to waste. Another way to swing that role is lay low (though not nearly as low as some of the people in this thread) and activate when shit really starts hitting the fan. This method has a lot more risk involved than the first, but it can also do a lot more for town in the long run if all goes well.

But yeah, time is ticking. We should probably start zeroing in on a couple people for the Judge to off. I'd like them to have two solid targets to choose from when Day ends.

 

I think you mean night 1 for the martyr, Menace. Day 1 would be the lynch, which wouldn't townfirm anyone.

 

^

10characters

 

oh cute.

ashaya is doing that thing where she does nothing except vote for me.

a++ would read again

---------- Post automerged at 11:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:55 AM ----------

@lungs: when i tell them to

 

I wasn't exactly lurking I was waiting for some more posts before giving my reads (which I don't have many). And when I went to sleep this thread came alive like it was Christmas. >_>

Anyways, townreads: jwlk and menace (obvious reasons), Aekiel (because he is trying), Ash (because no one is backing her up in the Lump Vote)

I know the reasoning for Ash is flimsy at best but it feels right to me so I am sticking with it for now.

And since she is obviously not winning,

Rescind Lump Vote
Lump Vote: Para

Scumreads: Kai, because of every single post he has made.

And so, Deadline Lynch Vote: Kai

PS: This has nothing to do with the vote Kai cast against me. Just wanted to put it out there.

 

Castiel, stop agreeing with me, it's hard to be mean to you when you do that.

Yeah, I'm obviously not winning.

I don't know why you are voting for Para....Dovaekiin has seemed pretty town in his suspicion of me, so I'm going to

rescind lump vote
Lump vote: Dovaekiin

 

/assuming Soup pierces Angel protection

Pope is a fail safe role at best. At 4 or less players its either safe to call the game in witches favor (2 of 4 are scum), the one last remaining scum is obvious or dumb!town/smart!scum is in play explaining why the remaining witch is not immediately obvious.

Pope is only useful for that one, low probability endgame scenario. If the player decided to play for such a scenario they would need to be 'off' enough to warrant a priest check then transition into a more town role so when they reveal it will be believed.

Personally I feel the role should be played as vanilla. Throw out false clues if you want but be aggressive, needle anyone suspicious and allow information to go to the players that can use it.

Question for you Lungs. What's the best way for multiple scum to townfirm themselves Day 1?

hOnK