Ah, my bad. I got the maths wrong. Still doesn't change what I think we should do.

As far as I know that's the main power of a godfather. But I think that there are versions where they have an extra ability like NK immunity, though that seems unlikely given that I had that power and there don't seem to be any town NKs.

 

I have a question Bill, did you know who your powered town mates were/are? This is a yes or no as I don't want any who might still be alive to be targeted.

 

I have to say, i find it hilarious that you still find me scummy Jeo considering the fact that I was the second person on the Kalas/Kensington bandwagon, and that Republic has been trying to get me lynched for two days, and that's still ignoring the fact that all three people that Bill accused of being a scum team voted for me...

Bill being HP does make sense, since not only would it explain why he's been playing so aggressive this game, but why there was no death last night. And Riley's role claim is just adorable, because there's absolutely no way that a scum would jump onto a bandwagon that's about to hammer one of them to make himself look better.

As such:
Lynch Vote: Republic

 

No, I didn't.

 

Yes I've been trying to lynch you, and guess why? because you're scummy. I was voting for you way before Kalas did, and fuck if that means I'm scum too. He saw a wagon other than his own, and went for it.
The fact that you voted for him also means nothing for the same reason, since it was the only one other than your own.
I still want to lynch you, in fact. You are way too smug about the fact that someone other than you will probably be lynched.

As for Bill and Riley's claims, eh. I don't think claiming actually contributes anything, since there's no way to know if they're lying or not without lynching. Bill could well be Harry Potter, or he just took the opportunity of whatever happened at Night to secure himself as town. His vote hopping is also another thing that has me twitchy. Riley says he's Luna. I want to believe him, since I haven't gotten scum vibes from him, but I also wanted to believe Stojil, and we all know how that turned out.

I've hinted at my role before, because this isn't the first time I've almost gotten lynched, but it doesn't seem like I did a good job. I don't want to go ahead and say it, because I dislike mass roleclaims in mafia games.

 

Here's the thing Republic, I've looked through your posts, and your only reasoning for me being scum is that Jeopardiser defended me once and that I haven't posted as much as some people. And about the "throwing lynch votes and accusations abound" thing that you mentioned, looking through my posts, I can only see 2 where I've made any accusations about anybody, one was due to rubicons rage boner for fontisan, which was due to him being derpy, and Riley for reasons that I outlined and cbf copying over, which he actually explained very well and in a very towny way, which is very different to how he's been reacting lately.

tl;dr The reasoning behind why I'm scummy that Republic has given is vague and bad, and can be summed up as "I dun like him cause he doesn't post to much, and because he keeps accusing people of being scum instead of being nice to people". Also, I love the fact that you're still trying to pass of the towniest person in this game as scum, whilst backing Riley.

 

I love the fact that you‘re trying to put words in my mouth. Try harder.

 

That better for you Republic? Because going through all of your posts, this is the only time that you've given reasons for why you think I'm scum. Feel free to quote any other info that I may have missed though.

 

So it's the last day right? (just checking, sometimes days appears or disappears from my memory, better be careful)

Republic21, if you have something to say to defend yourself from mishie last post, do it now. If you wait too much we can't have time to argue/whatever and so might just lynch you even if it's the best defense in the world. (Posting at the last moment can even be constructed as a scum tactic to force town into a maybe-not wise choice, I feel.)

And your lasts posts don't seem too good either:

#291: No one died? Succesful protection, or something else?

It feels like you are role fishing. (imho)

You say that you voted for mishie even before Kalas? Well I'm pretty sure scums try to not always vote at the same time for the same person. So that argument doesn't carry much weight on his own.

And in the post mishie quoted: Riley Poole and Kalas are, respectively, a town and a null read.

For the moment, your case doesn't look good.

 

Vote: Riley Poole

While I agree that Republic21 looks scummy as hell, I'm not sold that mishie is town either. But I'm pretty much convinced Riley Poole is scum for his behavior around the Kalas/Kens lynch. I'm also concerned that there may only be 2 scum in this game, in which case arguments like "they're both equally scum" would be dangerous. So on the whole I'd rather go with Riley Poole today and lynch his partner (probably Republic21) tomorrow.

 

My internet has been down since yesterday. I only had internet for like five minutes yesterday. I am now at an internet cafe because I knew I had to reply at some point.

True. By that logic, me or Riley are not scum. So either you believe that, or you don't. Which is it?

Riley seemed somewhat town-ish some time ago. Not so much for town reads as for the lack of scum reads. I will be the first to admit that I am not a very good judge of posts (and have admitted so in the past), and I was getting similar views from Stojil, so I have my reservations as to my own lack of scum-reads on Riley. I never defended him. I said that I personally didn't notice something he did that was scummy. If you did, good for you.

As for Mishie, what more is there to say? According to him, Bill Door is 105% Town, and anyone who disagrees or even takes the time to question him is automatically scum, and my behavior so far has been "OMG DONT LYNCH RILEY U GAIZ".
Sorry, that's not how it works.


Dunno when I'll have internet next. I'll try to log back in before Day ends (when is that, anyway?).

 

And that was what I was waiting for. Here is the thing:

If only one scum is still alive we are 5 towns against 1 scum, so even if we mislynch and someone dies tonight we are at 3towns/1scums tomorrow.
So if there is only 1 scum now, equally scummy is a thing.

The only thing your vote do? Divide everything, I'm the only one to not have voted yet and even if I vote Republic21, if nobody else change there is no lynch.
No lynch is so anti-town it hurts, right in my little heart.

You buy yourself a little security "blbablabla Republic21 tomorrow", but if we don't lynch and if scums manage to kill someone tonight? 3 towns, 2 scums tomorrow, easy enough for scums: they just bandwagon the first vote on a town.

Everything in your post is scummy, and the game is called "Battle of Hogwarts" but Scrimgeour didn't participate in it, he was long dead at that point.

If you are him, you are an inferi, if not, you are a Death Eater, either way you are scum.

---------- Post automerged at 06:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:42 AM ----------

And btw, because I don't know if I will be here later:

Lynch Vote : Republic21

For the moment he looks like a good bet, and I doubt I could rally a bandwagon against Rubicon today.

 

By my count there are only about four hours left in the day and Republic is one vote short of a lynch. Rubicon, can you switch, seeing as the Riley lynch has a very low chance of going through?

 

Yeah, I'll switch. Unless mishie or Republic21 switch there's no chance of Riley dying, sadly.

Rescind Vote
Vote: Republic21

You're right, I didn't think that part of the argument through. The core reason I want to lynch Riley is that my scumdar goes like this:

Riley Poole - scum
Republic21 - possibly scum
mishie - possibly scum

If we mislynch today it's over, so I'd rather not even risk mislynching today. That said, I did think through the rest of my vote, including whether it might cause a no-lynch, and concluded that since I'd back online before the deadline it wasn't a concern.

Take it up with Eid? I have no defense except to say the LV role made no sense to me either.

 

Day Four Ends!

The battle is waged. Night falls, and no dead bodies are seen.

Confusion is abound, until someone notices Buckbeak off to the side chewing on something.

A rat tail is hanging out of the side of his beak.


Republic21 has been lynched!

Republic21 was Peter Pettigrew, a Death Eater.

He was a Mafia Goon.


Votals!

Republic21: (4) Bill Door, Mishie, Jeopardizer, Rubicon
Bill Door: (1) Riley Poole

Abstaining: (1) Republic21

With 6 players remaining, it was 4 to hard lynch. There was no soft lynch.


Votes!

The day is short and I am busy. Go look yourself.

Night Four will end in 24 hours​

 

And then the Hobbit was raped in the face by a John Cena Dildo.

"Don't ever. CALL ME A NERD!", Vash screamed and the night fled.


Dawn of the Next Day.

 

Day Five Begins!

A new day starts with a piercing scream.

People are jostled awake, and congregate upon the noise.

Only to find a student face down on the floor, blood spreading out from a head of bushy brown hair.

Slightly sickened by the sight, they still must ready themselves for battle.


Mishie has been killed!


Mishie was Hermione Granger, a member of Dumbledore's Army.

She was Vanilla Town.


Livelist
Bill Door
Jeopardizer
Riley Poole
Rubicon

With 4 players remaining, it is 3 to hard lynch. There is no soft lynch.


72 Hours until Day Five ends.​

 

So it looks like I was right so far with the scum team. In that vein:

Lynch Vote: Riley Poole

 

Checking in.

Well, I wanted to wait a little and see what the others had to say about this but everyone is playing the silence-game so:

If Riley was innocent then mishie would have been scum, given what we know...

Lynch Vote : Riley Poole

My whole theory about Rubicon exists only because of his role-reveal, and even with that it's not that good.

 

If mishie is town then there's really no other conclusion. Hat's off to Bill Door if this is right.

The only other possibility is Jeapordizer... but if it is you, Jeapordizer, you deserve the win.

Vote: Riley Poole