Jeapordizer, Jeopardiser, agrgfjzgfhfrjfgg

Just... Call me Jeop, okay? x)

 

It could be worse. You wouldn't believe how many people call me Rubi. /shudders

Anyway, you scum?

 

So if he said yes, would you believe him Rubicon?

 

Well, the game's over, so yeah. No reason to lie at this point.

 

We should probably wait for Eido to confirm first. For all we know there might be another scum left, or if Riley was town there might be some way for town to still win it. It's not quite over yet.

 

No Rubicon, I'm not a scummy little scum.

 

phone post: please hold, that's a hammer - official post up tomorrow, i'm having some serious power/internet troubles related to storm

 

Day Five Ends!

The battle ends with a decisive stroke as a body drops to the floor and the halls of Hogwarts fall silent.

Gradually, when the roar of spellfire settles to silence, a cheer begins.

It picks up as more and more realise the truth.

The Death Eaters are dead!

Hogwarts is free!


Riley Poole has been lynched!

Riley Poole was Bellatrix Lestrange, a Death Eater.

He was a Mafia Goon.


Votals!

Riley Poole: (3) Bill Door, Jeopardizer, Rubicon

With 4 players remaining, it was 3 to hard lynch. There was no soft lynch.


Votes!

Does it really matter?

TOWN WINS!​

More like scum loses....​

Figured I'd post up the ending since Eido's having storm trouble. Hope you don't mind, dude. Anyway, town win, scum lose. Everyone in Obs laughed at you all. And they all lived happily ever after, until the end of their days. Oh wait, wrong fandom.

 

As Madam Pomfrey, the Mediwitch, I totally admit having screwed up at night-protection. *(Only one I feel I could have saved was AngelRick (because fontisian role-reveal upon death town-firmed him for me), but I was too lazy --')*

Thanks to Eidolonic for this game, it was fun and everything.
(Even if Scrimgeour wasn't at the Battle of Hogwarts and everything, even if it was the weakest argument anyone could have leveled ever it still bothered me a little )

What I learnt from this game: Lynch those lurkers, only good can come out of it. (/wink Republic21)

As for post-game comments...
I don't really know if it's because it's my first game on a forum, or my first with closed roster, or both, but I was thrown off. I didn't even consider a third faction until Stojil died.
Bill Door carried the town in the end.
I still don't know why Sacrifice wanted to be lynched.

Edit: Yes, I edited, felt it wasn't really that important now. (It's the part with *---*)

 

Wow, great job Bill Door, you really took over and are completely responsible for the town win.

Thanks Eido for the game, it was run really well, you were a great host.

 

Bill Door is a boss.

Also, I'd just like to say how freaking amazed I am you guys didn't lynch me. First my bizarre tunnel-vision on Fontisian, then refusing to post reads, then screwing up my claim, then completely changing my play style for the rest of the game XD

---------- Post automerged at 03:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:44 PM ----------

and yeah, Eid was a fantastic mod.

 

QT List

Town:
LochNess - Kingsley Shacklebolt: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/7syVitwPehm
Jeopardizer - Madam Pomfrey: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/GyPbss8k9mL
Bill Door - Harry Potter: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/kvs5H48CaXHb

Wetnurse - Remus Lupin: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/iwJaCDG3H5LvJ
AngelRick - Nymphadora Tonks: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/FwJ65QP52eEU
Mishie - Hermione Granger: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/V83hJGakPMMs

Fontisian - Neville Longbottom: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/9cttKLigKsY
Rubicon - Rufus Scrimgeour: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/FJ33g7XTNk3R
Sacrifice - Arthur Weasley: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/RZCnhdH8xTcK

Mafia: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/dJ4WLE7KNRC7M
Kalas - Lucius Malfoy: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/jWLy8vdKXY7SR
Riley Poole - Bellatri Lestrange: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/9amSCrpjKMAu
Republic21 - Peter Pettigrew: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/42JYDP3SPX3j

Neutral:
Uncle Stojil - Lord Voldemort: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/9BtEfCqsk9iZ

Observation: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/UJdf8MyQ6iT

 

I am not. Refusing to post your reads... It was idiotic on a cosmic level, but not really scummy, I felt. It's like this: if a very derpy town can do it, scums can do it too; if even a moron wouldn't do it, it was C'thulhu.

(The fontisian thing, well it's basically one of the only two way to play as town in the beginning no?)

I would have lynched you if you had continued, changing probably saved you in my eyes.

---------- Post automerged at 05:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:51 PM ----------

Reading Bellatrix QT atm, hilarious.

 

Dammit, Jeo. After all I did for you... you protected Bill on night 2. Shame on you.

 

Well if you died and revealed town: all the arguments against me fell flat; if you were revealed as scum (because of a town-nk or something), well I prefer scums to die than to protect them

(And I wanted to play a little and not just protect the same player over and over, mostly.)

---------- Post automerged at 06:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:02 PM ----------

Just finished reading the QTs. Yeah, Observers, I nearly lost the game for town. Not my proudest moment.

---------- Post automerged at 06:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:22 PM ----------

Just finished reading the QTs. Yeah, Observers, I nearly lost the game for town. Not my proudest moment.

 

After reading Bill Door's logic in his QT, looks like scum could have won if they'd just been willing to lynch each other. At a minimum, Kalas should have been sacrificed... that mishie wagon was just embarrassing.

My hesitation about lynching Republic21 was mostly just incredulity that an entire scum team could be that obvious about who they were protecting. :facepalm

 

Well that game was fun. Thanks for running it, Eido.

I thought we had lost it when Sacrifice flipped town. Sorry for going after you so hard, by the way.

Not really. By that stage there wasn't really any way for anyone else to be scum. And unless they came out and led the lynch against him I'd have suspected them of bussing.

 

I will admit that our scum reveal at the end there was a bit heavy handed due to the fac that Kens and I both thought there was enough votes on mishie to lynch him straight up, we both missed the rescind by Jeop hence why the obvious came to happen. At that point it was a bunch of flailing. I want to say that Bill did indeed play a good game. I congratulate him to show no hard feelings.



---------- Post automerged at 09:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:55 PM ----------

also, would totally play something like this again if Eido decided to do another

 

Seconded.

(10)

 

This was a pretty fun game until the last few days where there was a lot of inactivity.

This setup, in my opinion was a bit scum-sided because of the inclusion of an SK role. This puts pressure on town to lynch right at least once in the first 2 days to even have a shot of winning. And even in a world where town correctly lynched a tleast once in the first 2 days, it would have been 4-2-1 (V-S-N) or 5-3-0 (V-S-N) leaving town no room for error on lynches D3 onward.

Anyway, town really derped the first two days. If not for Stojil's N2 kill on LochNess, scum would have won.