Whatever scum there are are in this list:

Castiel
Zennith
Typhon
Jibril
Rents
NobelFiction

Discuss this theory.

 

Honestly, I'm not too sure about Rubicon, but I suppose we should get an answer on that front tomorrow. Jibril could well be scum playing us all (and I certainly won't stop considering it), but at this point I'm inclined to accept his claim. Typhon similarly seems relatively pro-town to me, but not enough to justify marking him down as non-scum.

Beyond that, I'm sorry CheddarTrek (and welcome to the game!), but I'm going to have to put off clearing you just yet. NobelFiction hasn't posted enough to justify anything but wariness. So could you please read through and give your impressions on the others, especially in connection to Fontisian or Zennith?

The only person I'd credibly be willing to write off as town is... actually, I'm not sure there's anyone I wouldn't suspect. Certain players like Bill Door, Typhon, Sesc and Aekiel seem pro-town to me, but at this stage in the game I'd much rather be cautious, especially since both the days we've had so far have been more or less focused on a single issue, and as such aren't nearly as fruitful in terms of readability.

That said, it's not particularly helpful to say "I SUSPECT EVERYONE", so I'll be going through the thread again, especially day one, keeping in mind that either Fontisian or Zennith is scum, and I'll post back with something more concrete.

Also, I could have sworn it was night. <_<

 

It's called Twilight, it lasts between the lynch time the night period, allows a little after lynch talk. ususally it's included in games with role-reveal on death to allow players to discuss the results of the lynch and what to do next. In this game I included it because I felt with how little extra talk there was I'd add time in the day for people to respond a bit more.

 

]I'm ending day a little early since I will be busy for a while. Night phase starts in 15 min. Please don not post adlfte that time.

---------- Post automerged 03-10-2013 at 07:24 PM ---------- Previous post was 03-09-2013 at 06:44 PM ----------

Night 2 has ended

There was a shrill cry in the night. The town awoke to the sound of death and murder. BillDoor lies in cold blood, dead as a door nail. However there was a trail of blood also leading away from the group. Did someone else die in the night, no one remembers anybody else being there. Today will be a tense day.

LiveList:

1. Castiel
2. Zennith
3. Moridin
4. CheddarTrek
5. Rubicon
6. Jibril
7. LochNess
8. Sesc
9. Rents
10. Aekiel
11. Typhon
With 11 alive, you need 6 to lynch.

Day 2 has begun

 

I completely dropped the ball on this one - I forgot about the time difference and did not check anyone. But, I also did not get any nightly visit so, Zennith's story checks so far.

 

I'm very confused. How is fontisian alive?

 

Riley forgot to remove my name from the livelist. I'm dead.

 

Right now, you're more like an undead

 

Jibril, what do you mean by "Zennith's story checks out so far"?

---------- Post automerged at 06:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:10 PM ----------

Anyway:

Lynch: Zennith

I think we can safely assume Zennith was targeted during the night. Since he didn't die, and Bill Door did instead, it seems very likely that Zennith is White Court.

(There is the question of why Bill Door didn't mention being visited during the night yesterday; but since the two courts alternate priority each night, it's possible the White Court tainted Bill Door before Zennith was killed.)

 

Yeah, sorry about that, I've removed Fontisian, I copied an old live list and completely forgot. I've edited the post to show the correct information.

 

The way I see it,

a) The Red Court attacked Zennith, but he managed to taint Bill Door first and so Bill Door died.

b) The Red Court attacked Bill Door, as
i) Zennith is Red Court.
ii) they were not sure if Zennith was Dresden or not, and didn't want to risk a possible missed kill if he protected himself.

So yeah, Zennith's story doesn't check out.

That said, we can eliminate a) if someone still alive was tainted tonight. If nobody was, it's likely Bill Door was tainted/killed - though that admittedly doesn't make a) a certainty, it does increase its chances.

 

I don't know what to tell you - I did my end of the deal and protected Jibril. Didn't expect to be alive on this day.

---------- Post automerged at 11:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:31 PM ----------

Also, they may have just not bothered with me, knowing that I'm gonna get lynched today - why waste a kill? I protected jibril, and I'm pretty pissed we got nothing out of it.

 

What I'm finding interesting is 'trail of blood leading away from the group', which looks like it might be lending credence to a) (the White King being injured in the attack, or some such).

Riley, are you able to post any clarifications to that effect?

 

I am pretty much 100% sure now Zennith is scum, and most probably White Court from the flavor. Molly checked him as non-human. (and seriously if Jibril was fake!molly, the real one would have come forward by now) I did not like how we lynched fontisian yesterday even though we had Zennith all but confirmed as scum, and I am not going to make this mistake again.

And for those who might have missed it, see post #172. Zennith story doesn't check out.

The only defenses he has offered are "I am Dresden", which we can not check and this,

When flavor was his argument of having us lynch fontisian.

So yeah,

Lynch: Zennith

Also, Jibril: What the fuck is wrong with you? Just put the check in in the day if you won't have time to do so in night. :\

 

So, umm... Shit. The flavor is implying that a pawn took a hit, I think; maybe Bill Door was just tainted, but I thought he was a little suspicious. I especially didn't like his "list of scum", and not just because I was on it. Umbrella statements like that tend to make people focus on them, and ignore the other people out there. It felt like a scum tactic to me.

That said, Bill Door's death could just as easily be an attempt to save somebody his list. There's no real way of knowing. That said, I think I'm in agreement with the others: as distasteful as it is to kill someone who has come forward as a Dresden claimant, I'm gonna tentatively say Zennith has my vote. Too early to actually cast it, though. I'm curious to get a little better read on everybody when I get some time, but that won't bet for another 15 hours or so, so this is mostly just a post saying I'm still around.