He means, how was it expected that Jibril would die, given that you thought Zennith was scum.


Riley, are you going to replace LochNess?

---------- Post automerged at 11:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:57 AM ----------

I was not visited, btw.

 

I've PMed LochNess and given them an ultimatum. I will let you know what happens regarding that. That being said, carry on.

 

I got visited last night. Same fluff as before about some shadow getting chased away by another shadow.

 

Dresden's action happens before the courts', doesn't it? So Jibril would still have been protected N1.

Aekiel's post makes me update my reads significantly toward Zennith being Dresden. I don't regret lynching him, though, it was still the best option at the time.

I need to think about this more, but I'm guessing either LochNess was targeted yesterday, one of the Red Court were targeted and decided to keep quiet, or the White King derped and didn't submit anything.

 

Hmm. I was afraid that he might've been, but the potential for Zennith to be scum and slaughter us while we kept him alive was pretty huge. No other options, really.

I think the most likely scenario (assuming LochNess wasn't visited, which would clearly change everything) is that both courts hit Bill Door. That would explain the strange flavor and the one visit - I think it's pretty unlikely that the leader of a scum faction just forgot. It's far from impossible (see Jibril :/), but that seems more likely.

If Sesc was right and Stojil was the Dresden (which, honestly, I think I probably at least possible, if not kinda likely), then we've gotten 2 vamps guaranteed, although for that to be the case they'd clearly have to be from different courts. I think Aekiel is on level, at least tentatively. I'm still not sure what to think about the rest, although I have a (completely unfounded) decent feeling about Cheddar as well.

Scum or otherwise, Rents and LochNess /never/ posting is becoming a serious liability. If something doesn't happen, one of them (probably Rents, because he's relatively quick to post if mentioned by name but silent otherwise; LochNess didn't feel scummy, just clearly not interested in playing) will get my vote for today.

 

I've not been as active as usual, this is true. I mainly reply when I'm asked questions or am mentioned, this is also true. this is mostly due to only being on DLP once a day though due to IRL stuff (work, school, other things) so I have a legitimate reason. I'm going to be more active through the end just due to solving some issues today so I have more time for mafia.

I think voting for a nonresponsive player isn't very nice so I think I'll Lynch: Rubicon instead since he has seemed the most vampirish to me through out the whole game. My guess is Red though, pretty sure font and Ched are white. And no I have no real basis, but my bizarre guesses are usually in the proper general direction.

Oh and I think the other Red was/is Nessie, but she hasn't said anything so far so eh.

again, total shots in the dark here but I tend to be a decent blind-fire-er

 

Honestly, I'd rather have LochNess replaced, if possible, rather than voted out. Inactivity can be a sign of scum, but it can also be a sign of RL commitments or problems, and I'd rather get reads on someone who's here and make my decision based on that.

Unfortunately, we lost at least one town last night, possibly two, both Dresden and Molly. To make things worse, neither of them gave any concrete reads to give us any ideas.

As things stand now, I'm not particularly happy with CheddarTrek. Cheddar, forgot to put this out there earlier, but this isn't what I asked. I was looking for reads on all the other players in connection to Fontisian or Zennith, at least one of whom is scum. Focus on links to Fontisian, since Aekiel's post bears out Zennith's version of the flavour (especially since I find Aekiel to be more or less town - you may have a different interpretation, and if so adjust your focus accordingly).

Rents, please try to come up with a more appropriate justification than 'bizarre guesses'. That's not helpful to anybody.

Castiel, what's your opinion on Bill Door's list of names given their posts in the interim?

Personally, I'm still okay with Typhon, I'm somewhat coming to the conclusion that Zennith was the Dresden after all (though, again, we didn't really have a choice and he certainly didn't make it easy to believe him), and Jibril was a trueclaim. Now that the Rubicon check isn't going to materialise, I'm going to be keeping a closer eye on him (though he has cleaned up his posting recently, that's still not indicative of towniness). Castiel has been okay since Day 1, not nearly as much discussion from him outside of the Zennith issue. Rents needs to, if he can't be more active, make his posts count for more than 'blind fire'.

Sesc and Aekiel seem townish to me, and for the love of everything Riley get either LochNess or a replacement in here asap, please.

---------- Post automerged at 12:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:32 PM ----------

Honestly, I'd rather have LochNess replaced, if possible, rather than voted out. Inactivity can be a sign of scum, but it can also be a sign of RL commitments or problems, and I'd rather get reads on someone who's here and make my decision based on that.

Unfortunately, we lost at least one town last night, possibly two, both Dresden and Molly. To make things worse, neither of them gave any concrete reads to give us any ideas.

As things stand now, I'm not particularly happy with CheddarTrek. Cheddar, forgot to put this out there earlier, but this isn't what I asked. I was looking for reads on all the other players in connection to Fontisian or Zennith, at least one of whom is scum. Focus on links to Fontisian, since Aekiel's post bears out Zennith's version of the flavour (especially since I find Aekiel to be more or less town - you may have a different interpretation, and if so adjust your focus accordingly).

Rents, please try to come up with a more appropriate justification than 'bizarre guesses'. That's not helpful to anybody.

Castiel, what's your opinion on Bill Door's list of names given their posts in the interim?

Personally, I'm still okay with Typhon, I'm somewhat coming to the conclusion that Zennith was the Dresden after all (though, again, we didn't really have a choice and he certainly didn't make it easy to believe him), and Jibril was a trueclaim. Now that the Rubicon check isn't going to materialise, I'm going to be keeping a closer eye on him (though he has cleaned up his posting recently, that's still not indicative of towniness). Castiel has been okay since Day 1, not nearly as much discussion from him outside of the Zennith issue. Rents needs to, if he can't be more active, make his posts count for more than 'blind fire'.

Sesc and Aekiel seem townish to me, and for the love of everything Riley get either LochNess or a replacement in here asap, please.

---------- Post automerged at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:33 PM ----------

... not entirely sure how that happened.

 

First off, sorry for not posting much, I was busy with another game (Survivor DLP) but the challenge is mostly done now.

Let's see.

Castiel
Zennith
Typhon
Jibril
Rents
NobelFiction

I know I am town. Logic says Zennith and Jibril were town.

Assuming Bill Door was shot because of this list, one or more of Typhon, Rents or Cheddar (Nobelfiction) is/are scum.

Rents doesn't exactly come off as scum, just weird, I don't know if that is good or bad.

I have been getting a solid town feeling from Typhon so far.

Cheddar, I don't have a good read on.

Riley, can we get a little extension in the day due to inactivity? We are nowhere near an acceptable lynch target.

 

My scum list is currently:

Rents - His posts have been off, for what little he's posted. Can't point to anything specific though.

CheddarTrek - Her post immediately after Jibril's death pinged really heavily on my scumdar, along with a couple of other, minor things.

Sesc - Only scum if Zennith was town, which I give a 50/50 chance now.

If I had to vote for one right now it would probably be CheddarTrek. So I will.

Lynch: CheddarTrek

 

Moridin's latest post is interesting.

Question for everyone: What do you think of Moridin? What do you think of Typhon?

Moridin, could you explain why you think Typhon is town? You've mentioned him exactly twice during this game, the first time just to say he seemed town and then later that you were "still okay" with him (but without any reasoning).

Typhon, what do you think of Moridin?

 

A bit of WINE and a bit of 'this reads like scum trying to appear town but barely restraining glee' (I fall for that one a lot when I'm scum).

 

Blame Stojil (or Eido). One of them introduced the term. WINE refers to Wine In Front of Me, from the Princess Bride (Youtube it).

 

Moridin has seemed pretty town-ish to me so far. Honestly, along with Aekiel and /maybe/ Sesc, I'm getting more of a town feel than scum.

That said, chances are high that one of them could well be scum, in which case I'd say that Sesc is most suspicious, then Moridin, then Aekiel, the justification behind that being that Sesc was trying a bit /too/ hard to vilify Zennith (in my opinion), and Aekiel is a replacement, which means the original player dropped out. Not exactly ironclad, but it's all I have for a deciding factor between him and Moridin.

On the subject of Bill Door's list, I'm not entirely sure that correct guesses have anything to do with why he died. In fact, it could be the opposite; if I were a scum court and a list like that was posted with none of my members on it, I'd have done my best to kill them instantly so it looked like I was afraid. Now, it might've been more straightforward than that, but I'm wary for using the list as a pattern for lynching.

Since I'm making a giant post anyways, I'll go on to say that I feel a bit better about Castiel and Rubicon than I did, but I'm still wary of them, particularly Rubicon. He was another major player in the Zennith witch hunt (admittedly, I felt the necessity too), and he rubbed me wrong earlier. Both of them ear watching, I think.

I felt better about Cheddar until these last few posts; I could justify lynching her this round too, I think. Her or Rents, who I might just be being irrational about, but is being neither very helpful nor allaying my suspicions.


Meh. More posting, people.

 

meh I'm in favor of lynching Ched, once Rubicon is gone, but I'm apparently weird and suspicious... which is different from usual how? Anyways, I've got my lynch where it's going.

 

You have had 48 hours. No lynch.

Night phases begins