Don't we need to check if Stojil is revealed as scum tomorrow? We can't assume what Wetmurse is being truthful, he very well could be scum and this is all an elaborate scheme (I doubt it, but...). If we lynch Menace regularly, we won't get a role reveal, so what happens if Stojil and Menace are innocent? I don't want to lose two possible town players in a possible scum trick.

 

Here's a plan.

Day 2 : We lynch 1 between Stojil and Menace. If they survive, that basically townfirms me and scumfirms the 2 of them.
Night 2 P1 : the Irene commits whoever is left between Stojil and Menace to the Asylum.
Day 3a : If I'm still alive, we Asylum lynch whoever the Irene committed to the Asylum.
He'll flip scum. Either way, that's still a scumfirm.
Day 3b : I'm dead. Asylum lynch whoever the Irene committed to the Asylum.

 

And what if they die? It's a 50/50 chance, even if they're both scum. I don't see the point of lynching Menace until we get a role reveal on Stojil.

 

@Vira

If Day 3a scenario occurs and the lynched Asylum inmate flips town, the mayor can commit me and then the Moridin can kill me.

 

The Moridin can't kill the Jwlk, so what we'd have is 2 dead townies (probable in the case of Menace) in exchange for a revealed and quite alive Jwlk: you. Great plan.

I'm working on something and I'll post it as soon as Lungs answers some questions in my QT.

 

Wetnurse: Why did you check Menace and Stojil?

Vira: Even if Wetnurse is scum, Menace could also be scum. The way he reacted to Wetnurse's reveal leads me to believe that he is. Thus, I'm happy lynching him today.

 

To be honest I wasn't looking for scum when I checked both of them. Getting atleast 1 scum in 18 people has a very small chance of happening. I was more hoping that my check would return 2 innocent roles. Two innocent roles could have helped me filter the interactions between the players so that I could find atleast 1 scum on my N3 check.

They're both good players. If I could confirm both of them as town then I could easily piggyback their reads for my N3 check.

Lucky for town, they both checked guilty.

 

I am also happy lynching Menace today. He struck me as scummy.

Deadline Lynch Vote:Menace

@Stojil: If Wetnurse is jwlk, then why didn't the true townie role claim?

 

7 Hours til end of Day. Get in here, people.

Here are the current votals:

Lynch Votes:

Stojil- 2 [2+0] ; Wetnurse, Jon
Fontisian - 1 [1+0] ; Fenraellis, (Vira doesn't get a vote for being in the Asylum)
Riley - 1 [0+1] ; (DLV)Kalas
Rents - 2 [1+1] ; Menace, (DLV)Stojil (Both of my scum picking on the derp)
Menace - 2 [0+2] ; (DLV)Aziraphale, (DLV)Fontisian


Asylum Votes:

Asylum Shanking - Vira - 1 ; Aekiel
Asylum Stay in There - Vira - 2 ; Wetnurse, Aziraphale

---------- Post automerged at 00:58 ---------- Previous post was at 00:55 ----------

Update :

Stojil lynch doesn't seem to be getting traction so :

Rescind Lynch Vote
Lynch Vote : Menace

Lynch Votes:

Stojil- 1 [1+0] ; Jon
Fontisian - 1 [1+0] ; Fenraellis, (Vira doesn't get a vote for being in the Asylum)
Riley - 1 [0+1] ; (DLV)Kalas
Rents - 2 [1+1] ; Menace, (DLV)Stojil (Both of my scum picking on the derp)
Menace - 4 [1+3] ; (DLV)Aziraphale, (DLV)Fontisian, (DLV)klackerz, Wetnurse


Asylum Votes:

Asylum Shanking - Vira - 1 ; Aekiel
Asylum Stay in There - Vira - 2 ; Wetnurse, Aziraphale

---------- Post automerged at 00:59 ---------- Previous post was at 00:58 ----------

And I'm off to sleep...

 

We have 17 people alive, so 9 for hard lynching.

 

People who have yet to vote:

Fishy
Rents
Sesc
Caesar
Aekiel
Riley
Lucky

If you don't vote for someone, it'll just look bad on you.

 

Kill Vote Vira

 

lol, no explanation even given. Good job Lucky.

Now lynch vote someone.

 

1) Because Wetnurse is the Jwlk, as in the scum that needs roles, so the player whose role he's claiming figured this was an attempt to get an extra life, and possibly more if it pushed the players he fingered as scum to claim as well (the check result is pretty convenient in that sense). It's why I prefer not claiming despite being a provable townie.
2) Because Wetnurse is the Jwlk and the role he's claiming is in the OTP with him and the Eidolonic.
3) Because Wetnurse is the Jwlk and knows that Seratin was the role he's claiming because the Eidolonic got its power.

 

I've really tired of saying the same thing over and over. I'm still waiting for more post to decide on who to Lynch vote, but Deadline Lynch Menace until then.

 

Also possible but much less likely because it would make Wetnurse incredibly reckless:

4) Because Wetnurse is the Jwlk but the player whose role he's claiming believes they might be the Castiel.

 

Deadline Lynch Vote: Menace because none of my other choices will pan out at the moment.

I have a question for anyone beside Vira: do you see Vira's high rate of activity as scum attempting to stall a kill vote and re-enter game or an active townie who's just trying to play the game as best they can whilst under threat of death? Depending o

---------- Post automerged at 01:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:38 PM ----------

Depending on public opinion, I'll cast my vote.

* sorry for the merged posts, for some reason my computer decided that hitting backspace is akin to hitting enter.

 

If you are a proveable town role, go ahead and claim right now. If you don't you are 100% scum. Letting us follow down this road where we lynch Menace and asylum kill you when you KNOW you cannot be guilty is 100% stupid (and because you aren't stupid, thus we know that you are scum, caught in your lie). The jwlk gaining an extra life right now is definitely NOT impossible for us to overcome. Modkilling on Day 2 is nowhere near where the Ex-Mods want to be.

Thanks for playing but yeah, this post basically CONFIRMED you are scum.

 

I already said I could still be the Eidolonic, Azira, so it wouldn't be 100% townfirming, and my role isn't indispensable, so I don't think it would be worth of giving the Jwlk an extra-life. But if you plan to lynch Menace, then I will, because two alive townies are worth it.

And the point about a day 2 Modkill not being great for the Jwlk is both arguable and moot, considering that I'm 99% sure Wetnurse is the Jwlk and his plan was to get some free lunch to prey on.