Fishy has the right of it. Your very question seems to be operating under the assumption that Rents should be lynched for a derp regardless of whether or not he is scum.

 

Moderator Note:

I unfortunately need to replace TMNTurtwig due to an undisclosed moderation mistake.

Sending PM to the people on replacement list, first response gets the slot.

Sorry for the inconvenience, especially to TMNTurtwig, as it is not his fault.

 

Is everyone asleep? It's been hours since the last post

 

To be honest it was my first post and it was well into day. So I didn't want to say some random out of game thing and throw a vote around. So yeah, I decided to mentioned one interesting thing I thought about.

If there is a 3 player scum team, then it's possible. And I would guess it's a Serial Killer kind of role, when you have to kill everyone. After first night the picture should become more clear in this regard.

 

Caesar! Who would you be worried about the most, as scum, this game?

---------- Post automerged at 07:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:56 AM ----------

Thats really unfortunate TMNT. Guaranteed spot in any game I run if you want it.

 

Font. She's a tricksy wench. Also Vira for much the same reason. Beyond that? I can't think of anyone who's a nightmare as scum.

Also. I'd like to note that Luckylee has been pinging my scumdar. Nothing major, but it reminds me of Smile in BSM. With that in mind:

Vote Player: Luckylee

 

If only TMNT needs to be replaced, because of a moderation mistake, can we assume that he is working alone? It would stand to reason, if he was scum, then more people would know about this mistake and what it was, and would need replacing.

Of course, it could be that Eido got to him, before he could say anything to others, if he was scum. But from just my perspective, if TMNTurtwig was scum and there was a mistake, that obliges a replacing of a player, then all game would be rebooted.

I guess this is a bit of Mod-gaming, that was talked about before, about making assumptions about what the Mod would do in certain situations and what kind of setup this is.
But anyway I feel, this is something to consider.

 

Interesting, but assumptions like that are detrimental to town, no?

 

I think considering stuff like that is sorta like meta-gaming in RP... albeit this is acceptable just... feels unclean. Eido needs to replace someone, maybe because of the game, maybe because they had a few drinks IRL and they're fucking, we don't know and while it matters, there are too many possibilities.

I was, it was night in the US where I know a large proportion of people on the forum (and probably the game) are, plus morning in Europe so people would be sleeping/going to work/busy. There are going to be lulls and lulz every day but not at the same time.

Oh and Lucky isn't doing anything that interesting, although his attitude could be nooby or could be defensive, not really sure, so Unvote

 

Well, this is dead.

fontisian: tell me about Lungs

Vira: what do you think of Sacrifice?

Fishy: who would worry you most as scum?

 

Sacrifice seems town, in the six posts he's posted so far. He's active, at least.

 

Mod Note:

Effective immediately, Sesc replaces TMNTurtwig.

 

More questions.

Sesc: gut impressions of guljons and Fishy please.

Wetnurse: what do you think of Kalas?

 

Cool, Sesc is an active very contributing player, no matter what his faction, so this will add to the game :3

Sesc: You're a pretty veteran player, what's your feeling on Vira this game, and as far as meta, how do you think it compares to her first day most games?

 

Clearly TMNT. He's going to be replaced and get a clean bill and I kid.

Font. She's built some town cred, and is experienced and influential.*

Kalas has a lot of experience and has a habit of flying under the radar.

Vira has been quiet. I'm not sure how I feel about that.

*This is a fairly good lesson from the DLP3 game I forgot to mention. I was lost a lot in that game, and as I result I trusted the opinions of others most of the time. In my own words, I "followed Sesc like a lost puppy." Sesc was scum. The lesson here is to consider what is said, but make your own conclusions. Don't get lazy and follow someone because you think they're smarter than you.

Speaking of Sesc...hi Sesc. You're totally evil and I hate you. :awesome

 

Sesc is probably scum.

 

Townies have ended day early before (See Moridin in Mini Mafia 3). The system is riskier towards endgame, when one vote on a townie can let scum hammer.

He's fairly active. I do know his playstyle very well, so it's difficult to me to comment on it. I don't like the way he buddied me and Fishy. I doubt he's a third party, because his activity level risks a night kill, and I don't think he shares a qt with Lucky. Overall, null with a slight town lean.

This was weird, in that it's a softball question to guljons after I pressured him and might just be distancing. A Rents/guljons scumteam is something to keep in mind. So Rents, why did you ask that question?

What about Luckylee's play reminds you of Smile's in BSM?

Sesc: What is your favorite type of fish?

 

I... yeah kinda haha. I love questions though!

 

Font, I asked because I haven't seen him say much and I'm not familiar with his play style. Also I wanted to see what /anyone/ thinks about it, and figured to just check with the guy I probably am least familiar with.