Nhhh. I'm thinking Kai is town, because Judge is the last role any scum would claim. The paranoid side of me is wondering he claimed judge for precisely that reason.

Kai: I would like you to kill one of Zeit and blab, preferably Zeit. If it absolutely has to be between me, Aekiel and Rubicon, I'd prefer Aekiel. Though, considering how off I was about you if you are the Judge, I'll redo my reads before deadline if I have the time.

But hey, whether you're scum or the judge, at least I was right about the desperation. Sigh.

If Kai is the judge and he judge lynches a townie, then there's a fair chance he'll survive the night. Why did you keep your vote on him?

For that matter, why did Bill Door fight the idea of a judge lynch and Proudboar vote for Kai? I can't wrap my head around it.

Votes are majority, not plurality. As long as we don't have 7 votes on someone, we'll no lynch.

 

Kai is set on 3 people specifically, he'll probably take our opinions but in the end we won't find out who he picks until the next day. I didn't take my vote off because I was pretty skeptical of his claim until you pointed out the real judge would kill him if he was lying.

 

Kai: Since there's a fair chance of you dying tonight (as scum or town), could you give me your reads before deadline?

Stojil: According to post 184, day ends in a bit less than 4 hours. What do you think of this?

 

Also why would he survive the night if he hits a townie, did I misread something?

 

Luckylee: Angel Protection

What do you mean by this?

 

Zeit's buddying with him earlier, Kai didn't wanna talk about it for reasons. He's probably dead tonight so I wanna know. I see no reason why Kai shouldn't tell us before it becomes impossible to find out, I'm interested in his thoughts on Zeit. But I didn't consider Angel protection, so I guess I can wait.

 

So, just a thought, but even if Kai isn't Judge and dies to Judge-kill, there's still the possibility (To us, I mean) that the Witches Soupkilled him and their NK. Despite how ridiculous and unlikely that sounds, even to me, it's still possible.

 

Yeah, I got that part. Why did you say "Tbh I didn't think you would avoid the Lynch"?

 

Also, Fonti, I meant that if I voted for Aek, it'd bring the count to 6 and if someone else Lynch Voted Aek w/o realizing there were already 6 on him, it'd bring us 7 and we'd have no clue as to what's up w/ Kai.

 

:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm :facepalm:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm :facepalm:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm :facepalm:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm :facepalm:facepalm:facepalm:facepalm

So scumslips, towny stuff, insight, things I could have missed, things you could have missed and connections you/others have don't add anything to the game. Good to know.

Rescind
Lynch: Prophylaxis

Are you being controversial for the sake of it or are you just being stupid? Or maybe even scum? This thing of not answering perfectly reasonable questions is bollocks.

jwlk got back to me. No lynch is indeed the way to go, now (there's almost nothing that can fuck it up and not terribly seriously anyway). As it is, I'm okay with everyone in that group (and with a whole other bunch). I'd have Aekiel lower in my priority if he hadn't just disappeared. Rubicon ahead of fontisian.

Will post again in a few. Shower time.

 

Because I didn't think he would, immed after his claim, PB voted for him so I assumed he would be lynched soon after.

 

I think you misunderstand how soup works - Soup resolves at night, and anybody killed with soup is revealed at the start of the next day. Also using soup disables the NK for that night.

My current reads are at the bottom of 205 - if anything changes before deadline based on things, I'll post an update. You can consider it my last will and testament for now though.

RE: Zeit buddying, I actually don't have anything alignment related about that, I just wanted to see if anyone would hit me when I dodged that question. For meta, me and Zeit have often had... disagreements in games previously, so maybe he wanted to short-circuit that by buddying me immediately. I don't think that it is a tell either way for town / scum.

 

Alright then.

In case I don't get the time to do my re-read and Kai decides to shoot me, my reads look like:

Fontisian
Proudboar
Uncle Stojil
Luckylee
Prophylaxis
Rubicon
Wetnurse
Rents
Bill Door
Aekiel
Blab
Zeitgeist

Kai isn't included for obvious reasons. There's a metric shit ton of yellow because I'm having heavy doubts.

 

Yes, good, good.

Now I get to laugh at you for putting your useless vote on me.

I'll answer questions that can't be replaced by you doing your actual homework.

 

Proph: Just answer the fucking question.

 

:facepalm

/no more words

 

@ Bill Door: Please explain your first post after Kai's claim, and your thoughts on everything since.

Why would he do that, though? If he's a witch, you'd think he'd prefer to be lynched. There's ... basically no way for the claim to make sense unless he's actually the Judge.

 

There is nothing to say.

 

Some vague hope that if he was convincing enough, we would switch over the lynch to Aekiel? It's more paranoia talking than anything.

 

I guess fontisian should be bumped higher on my list now that Kai is conftown, hmm.

fontisian, why blab in red?