They could but generally scum need every kill they can get, particularly if Kai was scum and they were already one down. It's something to keep in mind and we shouldn't blindly 100% trust, but I think it's very unlikely.

 

Took the words out of my mouth. I would find soup more likely than survival.

Lump Bill Door

Lynch Font

During my initial read through, font provided nothing but questions. I don't see him being much use unless he can put some analysis there beyond color reads.

 

Eh, you know Lump voting is done. Proudboar/Probellum(mid game name changes are annoying) has it.

 

Ahah, sorry bout that. Put the name change request in like a week and a half ago. Anyway, as I've said, I've been suspicious of Fonti for awhile, but at the same time, I'm still wary of completely trusting Rubicon and Ruckyree.

I'll say that Wetnurse is coming off as Town to me. Stojil was as well, before the replacement, but I'll wait 'til Titus posts some more before trying to get a read off him.

Zeit is still a bit up in he air and could probably go either way.

 

Rubicon dear, why was Kai against the judge plan originally? It was because having a no-lynch kills all voting and all pressure, effectively wasting the day. The vigilante bit was just a side bonus. So tell me, in what world does town!Kai false claim judge to get "reactions" (with the full knowledge that the actually judge may accidently out themselves when they flip out at him), killing all the final voting shenanigans that almost always happen around deadline and are almost always informative and then not actually bother to comment of said reactions?

And "the oracle and clown will clear you soon?" Really? You think in a normal situation, the oracle would have come forward just to clear a town!KaiDASH.

Option 1: Of course Rubicon claimed pie. He knew the clown would out him the moment they came in the thread, and wanted to get a smidge of town credit by claiming that he was pied first.
Option 2: I cannot believe that Kai was town with his behavior. I just can't.

It makes as little sense as Kai actually being town. Both scenarios assume complete incompetence on the part of someone.

It was three fucking am. I am not going to stay up all fucking night just to argue asinine points with you and Rubicon.

How do you know the Spiritcaller shared it with you and it wasn't a normal angel protect? What was the point of not saying this earlier?

Luckylee, I fucking swear if you are the clown, you targeted Rubicon last night, you survived the night, and now you're openly lying to us to save an obvious scum, I will having nothing to do with you post game.

:facepalm I'm an idiot, and Wetnurse is on this shit. This is what we should do.

Titus, you don't know me and I like to have newbies on the site, so I'll keep this succinct. Look again. Because the things you are saying make no sense.

Soup? On day one when precisely no roles are confirmed and the only role they could really guess would be the judge? No. The fact that you lump voted Bill Door has me concerned that you haven't actually read the rules. Please fix that.

tl:dr The clown needs to claim now if they survived a kill.

 

No, if someone who isn't LuckyLee was targeted by the NK they should say so and that is all they should say.

 

Font, I did read through very quickly. I missed lump being permanent. I have never played with a lump before. I was saying I would buy soup bfore surviv, not hat soup necessarily happened. I wouldn't be shocked if the scums decided to cop hunt for a day if they are one down. Unlikely, but more plausible than survivor.

I also find your flip on Kai very odd. You said scum wouldn't claim judge and now you're arguing with Rubicon taking the position that Kai was scum in a flipless game.

Your post also seems like one giant rolefish.

 

I have the awful feeling that Luckylee is the clown and he lied about the protect but not about being targeted, so...

Soup is more likely that scum just deciding not to kill anyone, but it's still extremely unlikely.

Let me tell you what happened yesterday. I was about as sure tht Kai was scum as I have ever been before a lynch. Then he claimed judge, inviting a no lynch. Boom, confidence shattered. My reads based on Kai's scumminess were worthless, so I put together a short list in case Kai decided to kill me, but I couldn't find the time or the energy to go into detail. Then the judge killed Kai. Confidence restored. Kai was scum. Full stop. Do not pass go, do not collect $200.

 

Font, so you were doing guilt by association in a flipless game? How would you have been certain? You had the time to code in colors but lacked the time to put in a single sentence? You also replied explaining some of those reads.

Also, you are the one failing to read. Soup results in a kill if the scums guess right. Otherwise, I would have no problem believing Runylee was the NK without a cc to that end. Now, I just know that's probably the case.

 

Or you know, I I was the one who survived the NK. Fonts, your disbelief with Kai is ridiculous, and I can't see it from someone who has always been someone I've thought as of a strong town player. Combined with early game things (your supposed fake pressure on me to catch scum) and considering I was targeted I'm guessing scum are among the people I've talked about. Zeit, Fonti, Aekiel, and Proph. Also, no I'm not the clown, and I really shouldn't have revealed that it was the spiritcaller that protected me, shitty move on my part.

 

Guilt by association? Of course. It's one of my main tools. Coloring coding takes a couple seconds. If I were going to explain them, I would have to explain all of them, and I only had a few minutes.

:facepalm "Soup results in a kill if the scum guess right." And if they guess wrong, which is extremely likely this early in the game, they get nothing. Anyway, it wasn't a soup kill because a failed soupkill gives the message
"A Witch attempted to Soupkill Amelia the [incorrect role], but failed."

 

I meant to say you Ruckyree. That's what horrible sleep does.

I will be out for most of the afternoon.

 

Then I guess the scum team is Luckylee and Rubicon. Waiting on a responce from jwlk before I push it.

 

Ok just saw Font's reply. The discussion was why no NK. I could see the scum guessing at the cop. That is why I cannot be 100% certain Ruckyree was he nk. I just find it incredily likely that Ruckyree was the nk, as the spiritcaller would likely say otherwise. There is the chance of Oracle soup though. That's all.

---------- Post automerged at 07:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:53 AM ----------

Ugh. Why would you have to wait on a mod before pushing?

Why those two?

---------- Post automerged at 07:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:54 AM ----------

I am out for real this time. I plan on getting my av to work after I get back.

 

Yeah you can't, be it's what happened. Fonti is scum :/ So if Fonti is scum, she attacked Rubi and BD so they're probably town too. I'm town, and I'm assuming PB/Wetnurse are also town. I'm not really sure about blab/rents.

 

Well, I don't know about Fonti, but I'm waiting on an answer for if the person the Spiritcaller shares Protection with is informed they protected that way, or if they just get old they have Angel Protection and nothing else.

 

They aren't, you're only told if you survive the NK via protection. I just assume it was the Spiritcaller protecting me, and it was shitty move on my part.

 

Stop fucking saying shit about your roles, people.

Don't assume that someone has to be innocent just because Fonti attacked them at some point.

 

@LuckyLee
Dude, really?

YES


If nobody counters LuckyLee's protection claim, fontisian is scum unless the witches chose to not kill, because

No, why would he ever do that?


Aekiel and Zeitgeist haven't posted yet.

 

Because I have questions and I'm trying to make sure I'm not making false assumptions.

The fuck is oracle soup? There was clearly no soup last Night, as there was no souping message.

If you weren't told it was the Spiritcaller, why would you say that it was? That makes no sense.

---------- Post automerged at 11:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:59 AM ----------

Because he is a derp.

---------- Post automerged at 12:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:59 AM ----------

blab: How does saying that even make sense from a scum mindset? Damn it man, I thought you were one of the reasonable ones.