Lucky, could you please post some more actual content? You've really not said much of any significance.

 

@Rubicon
That says unsure. the scum comes from scum-reading.

 

/me fucking sighs

I'm not wording myself well at all.

blab's post "Luckylee's first two post didn't mesh well" felt like shitty reasoning/scummish. I threw a lynch vote on you, not realizing you had responded. Which was my bad.

When blab explained himself, here,

It made more sense as to why you gave a scum read, i.e. not targeting me since I'm a easy target.

As for Zennith, well his ability is now useless unless he can convince someone to give him gold. Between Ika and Citrus, I'd say Ika is more scummy.

Considering Zennith can't use his ability anymore, his claim kinda makes sense as someone town trying to survive. I'm assuming scum has to be among,

Sloth
Ika
Nermut(he's been annoying lurky)

 

Unvote: Luckylee
Vote: Maiden

Pressure vote.

---------- Post automerged at 12:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:23 AM ----------

Maiden, give me your top 3 scum reads w/ reasons.

 

I'm no Irene, but I'm very close to calling it now.

Scum is Zeitgeist/Zennith/Sloth/??? with Titus as the Serial Killer/Third Party. Only thing I'm not completely sure of is which of Citrus and ika is scum.

Citrus, ika, present your cases. I'll view them in the morning. G'night and good game.

 

@Titus:
Case on Sloth has to wait for a bit, I'm not getting it done now, and it isn't pressing. I don't really understand what you're townreading him for, so can you refute fontisian's case + what I have in 177? (also outstanding question there, Rubicon)

---------- Post automerged at 02:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:38 AM ----------

can you explain the serial killer read?

---------- Post automerged at 02:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:40 AM ----------

hmm, immunity from being jailed is the only indication I see

 

Ok, sorry, just saw the thread was open again and getting caught up.

@Custer
Couple of IRL Games and one forum game that died halfway through. This was at least 6-7 years ago, with the forum game being older than that. I've also been reading the games on here for the last few months.

@Sloth
The first part, scum mentoring:
You responded to pretty much every part of fonti's readwall there, except for that. Every irrelevant part, except for that one accusation, which had more merit than some of the other things you answered. To me, it seemed like you were trying to sweep it under the rug. The fact that your response was primarily aggressive doesn't exactly fill me with confidence.

Yes, I was throwing out random questions. I wanted to see some talking, and maybe see if anyone posted anything odd about another person. Few people were on, and I was bored. Seemed like something to pass some time.

I didn't think you thought fonti was scum; I didn't want to hear your opinion on someone that was tunneling on you. Revenge votes and attacking people that are aggroing on you is a waste of time in most cases, from what I've seen here. I don't understand how that is a scumslip.

---------- Post automerged at 07:18 ---------- Previous post was at 07:13 ----------

@Sloth
Forgot to mention your comment about ika. Not sure why she responded so quickly to my prod.

 

I'm kind of annoyed that my first correct scum-call (In the history of ever) finally happens and people jump on me saying I'm still scummy.

That aside: The Jail mechanic is pretty weird and I'm a bit confused for now but I think I understand how it works for the most part.

Scum Reads: Honestly, I still see Citrus as the sleeper mafia that's sliding beneath the radar. I'm also not 100% convinced on Rubicon, even though everyone else has kind of just dropped him from their lists because he's playing smart. Scum can be smart too.

Ika is weird but null in my book, as is Custer and Luckylee.

Fontisian and Titus are both town to me as they are proactively hunting scum so I'm happy about that.

I'm not sure what to make of blab's huge ass walls of text but it's annoying honestly.

The rest are klind of in hiding really.

No Lynch vote right now as I want to see more first.

P.S. This game is way off from my schedule. I woke up to like 9 new pages, holy crap. Hopefully I can stay in this.

 

@Zennith
Why isn't your vote on me?
In #199 I'm apparently your top scumread, but no vote. What gives?

 

Also, the interview is definitely ika. How do I know, "tibit". If you're trying to say TIDBIT ika, it's spelled with a 'D'!

 

Nice, finally real reads, Riley.

I see only Titus and Citrus having you as scumread, and it weren't even their primary ones. And LuckyLee was annoyed at me for reading him as fourth-scummiest.
Why so sensitive? Goes for Lucky even more than you.

And show me 2 posts from me that are walls.

Do you agree with: "at least 1 scum in: Zennith, ika, Citrus"?

 

Sorry, that was supposed to be "Sloth's read walls".

I guess I'm sensitive because for the first time ever I called on correctly and I'm still scummy to some.

I already have and still do. Citrus is a sleeper Scum in my opinion. He's doing a fantastic recreation of his playstyle in DresdenMafia.

ika I'm unsure of as I've never played with ika before.

Zennith could still be scum but the Jail role seems pretty town so I'm willing to look more closely at others for now.

Question for anyone: What about my playstyle might have suggested Watcher, as is noted in the interview?

 

Vote Count 1.6
(8 to lynch)

Zennith (4): Titus, Titus, Citrus, Custer
ika (2): fontisian, blab
Irdiumstern (1): Sloth
Maiden (1): Rubicon
blab (1): Luckylee

Abstain (6): Zennith, ika, Irdiumstern, Riley Poole, Maiden, Nemrut

Nemrut has requested replacement. Searching for one now.

 

Uh, the interview doesn't say that?

 

Effective immediately, Moridin has replaced Nemrut.

 

There really isn't much about what I've done that makes me seem like the Watcher. The fact that he mentions watcher and then mentions being extra wary of me leads me to conclude that the person who stated this thinks I've done something that looks like I'm the watcher.

What exactly have I done?

---------- Post automerged at 09:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:38 AM ----------

This also confuses me because the mention that Mafia "Had" a permanent watcher and assumes that the Town has one too.

 

Hey guys, reading through now. One thing, do we know what Zeit's role was, exactly? i.e. is Wiretapper the same as Watcher?

 

I still don't see how that says that you are a watcher. Anyway, your second sentence is more to the point, it's more interesting that the author is sure that scum had a permanent watcher. I mean, I can see Zeits claim and Town Watcher~"Wiretrapper"=permanent watcher but I'm not sure and can see a Trapper role too.

 

Are you intentionally ignoring the inference between those two lines?

---------- Post automerged at 09:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:48 AM ----------

Or do I have to spell it out?

 

"Mafia had a permanent watcher" likely refers to Zeit. As such, the inference, if any, would be that you are a town watcher. Why would anyone admit to being wary of a town watcher?

Given the item on sale right now is kind of a watch thing too, I kind of doubt there'd be too many watchers running around. Permanent watcher (if that is indeed Zeit's role) isn't that out there for the mafia to have, surely? A fairly powerful role, sure, but not something that requires such a specific counter.