The third party debate is pointless. Stop it.

 

I agree because the flavor text strongly implies that Possom was a mafia kill.

"Shot between the eyes" would suggest a mob hit.

 

Unvote, Vote: ika

L-3, I think

 

1. ika has ties to Zeit
2. ika hasn't got a single post showing any townmotivation
3. ika hasn't voiced many opinions about other players
The ones he did
(3: hint at killing role?
4: PR also? Amnesiac?) are not exactly pro-town.
3. ika claims to be overwhelmed (balancing thread and jailchat and scumchat maybe?)
4. at least one of (Zennith, ika, Citrus) is not town. I refuse to believe in something that can become a 4-player mason.

@Citrus+Zennith:
show me something that makes you think that ika isn't scum

@Moridin: your questions are answered in thread. Tell me something that stops you from voting ika (or just vote ika)

@ika: give reads

 

blab, what's your read on Custer

 

I think Ika is very likely scum.

---------- Post automerged at 07:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:19 PM ----------

Either him or Citrus, but not likely both.

 

There seems to be thing assumption 1 scum in Zennith -- ika -- Citrus. What fuels this assumption?

 

Titus: What's stopping you from commuting every Night? 1 gold seems like a low price to pay for that ability.

 

Tbh, I hadn't looked at him yet.
Opening posts looks good, still waiting on the case on Zennith.

Don't like.

I'm fairly confident in my scumreads (ika, sloth) so him calling them scum is a plus. If just on out of (Zennith/Sloth(Citrus/ika)) turns out scum I can imagine scum!custer sheeping his scumreads here. Like the attitude, though.

SK stuff was meh, too much focus on it, but he was asked several questions about it.

Conclusion: slightly on the scummish side of null, depends on flips, really. I need to see more.


@Titus
4. at least one of (Zennith, ika, Citrus) is not town. I refuse to believe in something that can become a 4-player mason.

 

blab: Are you still going to analyze Sloth's opening post?

 

yes, I need to study, though, ( and I don't want people to forget about lynching ika), so it'll take a bit

 

Vote Count 1.7
(8 to lynch)

ika (5): fontisian, blab, Titus, Maiden, Rubicon
Zennith (2): Custer, Titus
Irdiumstern (1): Sloth
blab (1): Luckylee
Riley Poole (1): Citrus

Abstain (5): Zennith, ika, Irdiumstern, Riley Poole, Moridin

 

I don't have enough gold to commute every night. So I have to use it on the nights that scum are most likely to kill me.

If ika would have told me that Zennith was going to jail me, I wouldn't have commuted at all.

---------- Post automerged at 04:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:44 PM ----------

What's the four player mason? I finished a game where there were three players in a mod defined neighborhood where all three happened to be town. There were conditions that all players had to be alive in that game for the neighborhood to actually use its dayvig. So I wouldn't rule out all three of them being town.

http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/outside-magic/mafia/520113-social-engineering-mafia-ii-game-over

That being said, I don't feel comfortable with ika or Zennith but I'm not ruling out the possibility that all three are town.

 

???

that game has like 27 players, and it's 3 players (that's 1 less than 4). I maintain that something that can turn into a 3 player mason (mod defined neighborhood where all three happened to be town and know they are town) with an invite and protect ability to confirmed townies is OP.

But whatever, ika is scummy independently from that.

 

I've been super busy lately and not keeping up on the game too well, my bad.

So… either Maiden town slipped hard, or she is a derp like me. Somewhat doubting she a derpy scum.

blab, I didn't get defensive, at the time I thought your reasoning was shitty and it annoyed me.

Titus brought up a really good point, we've been way to stuck on the jail thing/Zennith/Ika/Citrus. I think we should just lynch Ika and get out of it.

---------- Post automerged at 08:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:01 PM ----------

Forgot to do this, Lynch Vote blab

 

Hey Lucky, are you scum?

 

Nope.
/10chars

 

Then why are you encouraging an ika lynch while voting for blab?

 

Why blab this time?

 

Because I'm not fucking paying attention.

Unvote

Lynch Vote Ika

>.> just woke up.