I worked out what bothers me about this. Lucky doesn't get deferential/apologetic when he's town. In his town games in micro #2 and dresden casefiles 2 he was very belligerent or whatever about everything. Here and in WH3 he's more reserved and apparently lacking confidence.

Scumread on lucky based on meta shiz.

---------- Post automerged at 10:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:53 AM ----------

Cool beans.

 

The biggest piece of evidence I have for a Lyrium/Snowvon alliance of some kind is here. Too meta.

Not just B&T blab. Come on, dig harder and you'll see it.

What evidence Titus?

 

I won't lie, I'm not feeling too confident this game as I haven't played in a while. So I've been a bit more polite than usual. But I am town :|

 

Also reads:


In order from Towniest to Scummiest


Blab
Lucky
fonti
Rubicon
Citrus
Ika
Bill Door
Vira
klackerz
Titus
Polysmous
Atum
Lyrium
Snowvon


Vote: Snowvon

I feel like a solid 80% of Snowvon's post is either riding on what Lyrium said or what Fontisian said.

Other than that, no real notes for now.

Also the Cat/Dog question was meant to route out those who choose to be a leader or a follower.

Those that actually played, thanks.

 

What were your conclusions from the cat/dog thingy?

---------- Post automerged at 02:20 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:20 PM ----------

and which Snowvon post are you referring to?

 

Vote Count 1.3
(8 to lynch, 10 for supermajority)

Polysemous (3): Titus, Luckylee, ika
Atum (2): Bill Door, Rubicon
Titus (2): blab, Polysemous
Luckylee (1): Citrus
Citrus (1): Snowvon
Vira (1): fontisian
Snowvon (1): Riley Poole

Abstain (4): klackerz, Vira, Atum, Lyrium

Deadline is around 48 hours from now.

 

The ones who chose to answer, chose cat. (Lyrium) Note the placement.

And all of them for the most part.

---------- Post automerged at 10:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:30 AM ----------

Ika was basically null as he chose Nyan cat.

 

Precisely what makes you uneasy. Scum tend to buddy me, have arguments that have no content or ridiculous, or try to distract me with inane facts. Town have put together conversations that allow me to solve the game in my own way. It doesn'tmatter that you've said I could be scum but it does matter that you are letting me solve the game since you are wrong, the depth of logic you posess as well.

---------- Post automerged at 07:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:33 AM ----------

You mean that fonti essentially wants to waste a check to determine if info trick was not used. Ugh.

Witch trick, if I am understanding, should be obvious if set tonight. Lynch trick is obvious at lynching. N1 results aren't absolute but are likely valid if no one dies tonight. So why waste the check at all?

---------- Post automerged at 07:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:37 AM ----------

Riley, the cat/dog question had to many confounding variables. Personality is one of the few things meta is good for. I am not much of a follower despite picking the popular answer. Do your homework.

Also, it worries me why you even need to know who the leaders will be so early.

---------- Post automerged at 07:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:41 AM ----------

Snowvon moves tovtownread due to the synergy we've been having. This will be reinvestigated later if I am wrong but synergy D1 means I am not lynching him or passing him the bomb.

Ika is town due his request for the bomb. I doubt scum would be so bol. Second, his trolling. Third, his idgaf nature. Is it 100% go to the wall town. No but Rubi asked for a choice.

Luckylee moves to null. He has more content but I don't care for the self-vouch.

Scum is almost certainly in Fonti, Poly and Riley. Vira, Citrus, Rubicon and Atum I need more interaction with.

 

It wasn't a need to know question, it was a curiosity question. It just so happens that my opinion on game so far and the answer to the question correlate.

You really shouldn't be worried about "leaders". I'm not. I'm more worried that you think I'm stupid enough to really need that.

 

I am not Riley. Anyone reading the thread can see that's the purpose to your cats/dogs question. It's not stupid to need leader information as scum. You would want to know who you could piss off and live. This just tells me you are intellectually lazy, when you can skim games to find likely leaders and read dynamics.

 

Titus, you confirmed yourself to be the bomber in your first post. If scum haven't figured it out, they're idiots. The only way you could have known that you'd be receiving the bomb before pre-game ended is if you made the decision.

I'm probing to figure out if you're town, and I think you are.

I have zero fucks to give. Start being useful or die.

Polysemous is off the do not lynch list and into "I'm watching you" territory.

ika's town and needs to stop rolehinting. Just, please.

And what visible effect does no trick have?

 

Fonti, that may or may not have been true about me having the bomb pregame. That was a rare gambit to get the bomb in my hands. If it failed, no shits given.

No trick has no visible effects, but I don't see why any player makes themselves a vt willingly.

 

Because the other two tricks are shitty for town and a confirmed witch trick leads to scum shooting themselves to get an extra life and look towny.

Titus, unless Proph messed up the action order (and he implied that he didn't) you claimed bomber in your first post. OK? Lovely, moving on.

 

Hey Fonts, explain why you want to lynch Vira.

 

Not moving on. While I may be the bomber, that was a gambit to ensure the bomber would give me the bomb. Hence why I claimed it. No risk bc bomber cannot explode n0.

 

Ugh, fine Titus, whatever you want to say.

 

Fake edit- Didn't see your question, Posy. If someone is applying pressure and trying to drive some form of discussion, I think they're town. That is why I have a town read on Titus.

 

Citrus: Most of his posts have been about game mechanics and a random vote for LuckyLee. I am inclined to think he's a scum but also want to wait for him to be more active.

fontsian: fontsian is a little too aggressive for my taste trying too actively move a town towards her direction. From the comments here I get that it's very common for her to be like that. So I don't really want to lynch her yet.

Vira: Vira currently seems a little scummy. She's inactive( I know irony) and her posts are not that informative. Though I do agree with her scum read on Atum

Atum: Currently feeling like he's scum right now. He's also not contributing that much in his posts and it feels very scummy. Kinda like how I used to play scum

Riley; Riley is being derpy. cat/dog Really? I am inclined to vote for him just because of this.

Polysemous: I am kinda feeling ambivalent about him right now. Need more posts.

Snowvon: He has posted a lot and except for one post about Titus, he has not really said anything of substance. Leaning towards scum

Titus and blab: Not really enough to comment about them. Leaning towards town

Rubicon and Billdoor; As I said before, leaning towards town. They are actively posting a lot and trying to figure things out.

ika; His posting formats is weird but seems town right now.

Lyrium: I am kinda leaning towards town for Lyrium at the movement. Her posts before she claimed gd seems to fit towards town.

Anyway There are preliminary reads. Except it to change. I am leaning towards lynching Atum now. I really need to set up a google document.

Vote: Atum

Off Topic : @Atum: Your avatar is bad and you should feel bad. :_:

 

...HOW COULD YOU FORGET YOUR OTP, Klackerz?!

 

LOLLLLLL

I knew I forgot someone. But I never thought it was you.The question you have to ask now is, was it deliberate. xD

Anyway, I'll post in a few minutes. Let me review your posts