So you were hoing to catch the newbies day 1 and then proceed... not to lynch them?

 

Consider this a thump.

---------- Post automerged at 11:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:22 PM ----------

New to the setup Titus, not new to the site. There's a difference.

 

Oh and Polysemous, the new guy. Kind of funny, his last post reminded me of a Michael Buble song. Still has some questions to answer, no?

 

Fonti, suppose arguendo...Poly typed "This is my first scum game so please be patient" or something really close to that, would you lynch him?

 

Troll Question: everyone's a newbie but you. what do?

Serious Question: what happens if all newbs are scum? play against win-con day 1?

Info: See why we don't care?

 

Oh good god Kai replaced Vira. Hey KaiDash. Long time. Did you recover from your games with Irene. XD

Hmm Rubicon voted for me. Cool. I still consider him town for now though.

My strongest scum read is still Atum. So keeping my vote on him for now.

I still don't know why fonti is considering me town. Hmm but Wtf . That's good for me right now until everyone decides she is scum and lynches me too which is looking more and more likely.

Who the fuck are the noobies anyway.

 

Ika, the fuzzy logic question works 99 times better and might hypotthetically happen someday.

Klackerz, Atum is semi new. Poly is totally new. The rest have varying degrees of exp.

 

Wait klackerz, you aren't a newbie? Damn, your post count so low I thought you must be one of those shy puppy newbies still learning how to bark.

 

No? What does that have to do with anything?

Ika, you're pissing me off. I would find scum and lynch them, obviously. That's an entirely different situation, and acting any differently would be an insult to the players. I may go a little easier on them, just to avoid crushing their poor newbie souls.

 

Fonti, if Poly unambigously, nontrolly claimed scum today, would you lynch him or would you play against wincon.

 

Hm.

This... feels reasonable I guess.

I can't say I'm fully convinced about this, since you could have made up this neatly fitting justification, but it's ok for now.

--

Titus / ika

Must you both be so obstinate about hypotheticals?

 

You know Fontisian, when Lucky and I have to say "scumhunt" to you, there's something off with the universe.

 

He said he had prior exp. My post count is low but that's cuz mafia post all the way.

---------- Post automerged at 08:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:32 PM ----------

I am the queen of hypotheticals. They determine boundaries and are one of the best scumhunting tools.

 

To be fair, there are four witches running amok, and it's veeery unlikely they're all newbies (given there's only one actual new!new person playing, yes?). Why not go after other scumreads and give new people at least a Day/Night cycle to have some fun?

Like, nobody's expecting you to be cushy and gentle with newbies for the entire game. Stop acting like that's the case. One person is very likely going to die toNight, regardless of who we lynch.

 

...

I would lynch him because he's the type of idiot I don't want around on this site anyway. Can we stop asking stupid questions?

Yes. That would be the fact that you and Lucky couldn't recognize scumhunting from me if I literally went out and speared a scum.

Damn, look at that doubt cast. Very subtle.

Reads, KaiDASH. Do you have them?

 

Lyrium: Meh I haven't played mafia in so long. So I've been taking it slow. Another reason is I am a little busy. Also discussing game related mechanics is not really my forte.

 

So Fontisian, considering you're kind of against lynching all the people I want to lynch. How about KaiDash? Replacements are some percentage high thought to be scum.

Why don't we give him a break from having to read through all that and lynch him?

Hai KaiDash, where does the coven meet?

---------- Post automerged at 11:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:36 PM ----------

Snowvon, I think we are agreed on not lynching Polysemous toDay for reasons of civility and the Stark sense of honor but next Day if he doesn't rise from his slumber....who knows?

 

Hey Lyrium, where am I voting right now?

 

Fonti, it's not about newbie status then. It's about the degree of evidence. Don't dress it up as civility as all players deserve civility, even one that blunders that bad. It is a matter of evidence.

Lyrium, I certainly didn't agree to not lynch Poly.

 

I don't actually agree with the assertion that everyone deserves civility. Most people deserve civility. Let's leave it at that.