No. He would betray them nevertheless. He was a coward.

 

I dislike Peter as much as the next guy, but it's pretty stupid to deny that he was as close to the other three as any of them were. That is why the nature of his betrayal was so terrible, exactly because he was one of them.

And there is no reason for young!Peter to be an asshole, a traitor, or a terrible person. Yet, anyway. Cowardly, maybe. But even this is taken way disproportionately by ff writers.

 

Lol, that fucking 'English' accent at the end of the video.

 

Did not check the site, but just looking at the actors...I cannot tell who's who aside from Lily and Remus. I only get Remus because of the mention earlier in the thread. That is not a good thing. If I cannot pick Snape or Pettigrew easily from this group then the casting is doing a piss-poor job.

 

I think you use the term "Casting" wrong. I think this is a group of friends/fans, who wanted to make a movie. So they choose rolls they fit best, which is not much to go on.

 

Reminds me of all the people who try to write Mcgonagall with a Scottish accent. God is at jarring because it sounds nothing like how anybody I know talks.

 

The guy talking about it - with the glasses - I thought was going to be James Potter, looks sort of like what we know about James... current James sounds weird.

Thought Remus's actor was going to be Sirius's.

And Snape looks too normal.

 

The movie is going to take place in the Marauder's 6th year so they said there was going to be minimum James/Lily shipiness. The actors (James and Snape) are going to use wigs. I think it's going to be 45 minutes or so.

I don't think they are going to unwatchably bad, but they are still amateurs with a low budget. Snape, at least, looked rather good actually, from the script reading they uploaded, though Lily was eh.

 

Like I said before, the simple fact there will probably be neither Slash nor modern American muggle shit means it will by default be better than at least 90% of every Marauder Fic out there. Personally, I'm not that interested in the actors as opposed to the Story: for all we know, it could be a damned good one.

 

But how much influence would muggle culture have in Hogwarts, especially with purebloods or even halfbloods?

 

Here's hoping WB shuts them down before they produce a piece of shit so terrible it permanently stains the HP brand by association.

 

Well nobody stopped the Very Potter Musical, so I'm not sure if they'll stop this.

 

The Very Potter Musical falls into the category of parody, which is a protected class of speech (thus how books like Barry Trotter can be sold). This is just straight up copyright infringement.

 

Eh, you're right. I just really dislike the AVPM.