Hmm. That is a point point, but if it's the last witch they may not have wanted to reveal that they are all alone now.

 

---------- Post automerged at 10:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:19 PM ----------

Part one: Font is scum.

 

Bill, let's say you were lynched...who would you kill on death?

 

Assuming Poly is the witch. Isn't it better to have Klackerz judge again or out himself as scum?

 

Nope. Lynching reveals motivations, if you want to lynch Poly, you vote for him. Period. Relying on Klackerz is an easy way to avoid blame/not show motivations. You should know this Titus :|

 

While we wait for ika's case, every townie in this small town in the middle of a nebulous space\time continuum:

Let's assume that I am the Gravedigger and a Villager Peasant and that these results are accurate:
Rubicon, Witch, Gambler
Citrus, Witch, Jester

And that we know this to be true:
Blab, Holy
Riley, Holy

1. In a remaining scum team of two, who do you want to lynch and in what order? Briefly explain why.

2. Based on your beautiful, enlightening posts in the game thus far...why should you not be toDay's lynch?

 

I agree. Yet there is a chance that Blab checked Poly, thus giving him an extra life, so it would be akin to the Citrus lynch yesterday.

 

3. If there is only one witch left as our ika posits then does 1. change in any way? Why?

---------- Post automerged at 11:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:37 PM ----------

Lucky, if you were lynched who would you give your life to? Not it.

If you were judge lynched, how would you feel about that?

 

Oh I can confirm Riley's holy status. Not that I think anyone doubted it at this point.

 

ALL THE FOLLOWING IS FROM FONT:

1) forgot to tell what jester trick to use, jester was scum so it becomes moot.
2) this looks pro-town on a glance, but further evidence shows that it was only a ploy for him to waste his time checking due to knowlage of witch trick used
3) again, looks pro-town at a glance. but the underlines is not pro-town for day one. Imagin if we sent it to blab and he blew up only because we agreed on it.

Bomb: Now looking at the bomb as well, lets see how scums could optimize it (this will play slightly into how titus is town case)

So titus sent bomb to her merly based of her thinking of she was scum. A witch would of sent it to maybe an ally or hold onto it. It would of been more optimal for titus as witch!bomb to not even make it obvious she was bomb. She would of been better as gambler IMO. So going by day 2 ideal if bomb still existed, it would of been passed to blab and blown him up b/c of holy. The witch then can go out and kill ridly who is the other holy. The counter is font is somehow inquationer but really? he would either have to go double kill or have a scum buddy atm. So odds are its not possible. Also ridly has had no real post that give off manipulation.

1) allow me to answer, your scum. A scum knows all other scums (in this setup at least) So whats best way

1) pointless agression, this is also a perfect place to maye apply a vote and pressure
2) now why is that? this was way before the "do not lynch newbie dicussion"
3) claims im town, ummmmm reason?
4) pointless question that has an obvious answer

1) shes being lazy (how lazy are you when your scum, i know i am, cirtus was, rubi more or less was)

the bolded: all moot, vira is confirmed town by lyrim

translation: I am not part of the town. I have to manipulate town to lynch each other.

Bolded: so apparently voting font=you are shit

Hard to exactly explain, but maybe titus can?

1) unsure what that means
2) i need something to do, whats her real evidence? Could it be I'm scum and I know everyone else is town?
3) deflecting a scum!tell of hers
4) excuses to be lazy
5) 4 roles? ummmmm, witches have 4 roles. Knowing font she prob had entire list figured out sooner. She subconsciously said 4 b/c 4 witches=4 roles known
6) anyone is lynchable actualy (maybe except holys unless if you delibertly play against town-wincon)
7) unsure
8) ask rubi (confirmed scum). Now why would font even consider that? Wht would font even ask anyone?

Bolded: basic knowlage that shes apprentic now based off POE of everyone elses claims. Also this implies that klackers is town and are unaligned. The only way she could have that confidence is as scum.

underlined: Coaching a newbie (remember witches dont have day-chat)

1+bolded) this shows how "easy" he is as a lynch, this implies that atum is town. Her attacks on him are near half-hearted as well. It also ties back into the coaching/talking to poly

italicized+underlined: holy, cant lynch

bolded: Again, another implication of not being town

underlined: oh i dunno, maybe b/c your a witch and you want them to play sub-optimal?

Again, apparently voting font=your shit

red: she can explain it b/c she is scum, people have trouble figuing out titus as town, so what makes it so hard for font to do so?

bolded: survival

underlined: deflection

overall: one giant post of fluff

Snipped a bit here

Bold read: She never found scum, instead she was pushing on town. We could assume she might bus later but its only an ideal thing. Also again, indirect "im not town"

ANY TOWN SHOULD BE FINDING SCUM

underlined red: self-awareness

I stopped there on font b/c while i could keep going, its should be enough evidence to show. If you want to look though the rest go right ahead

Part 2 is coming up: Rubi+Cirtus similarities

feel free to start the polly votes btw.

 

1. Poly first. He may have an extra life. If there is a scum with an extra life, if Klackerz is town, he's dead. I'm not so sure who the second buddy is at this point. My guess is someone really in favor of the "we don't lynch newbies" well after it became clear it wasn't just about civility.

2.Read day 2. I'd rather not rehash at this point.

3. If there's only one scum left, they'd have to be double lived. A single scum would get two kills if they only had one life. So that would narrow the pool to Poly or Snowvon as well. A judge lynch ensures, hypothetically, if we're wrong about Poly there's not a chance of fucking over the game.

 

Also klackers 258 post confrims him as town alone.

It requires scums to be self aware enough to type that kind of post and i dont see that from scum!klackers

---------- Post automerged at 11:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:24 PM ----------

also nl that ends day early can allow judge to chose quicker

we just need klackers to confirm he locked in poly

---------- Post automerged at 11:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:25 PM ----------

kaidash case from earlier on font, word for word. we also knwo he did this from town mindset

---------- Post automerged at 11:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:28 PM ----------

Basicly implies hes not town either.

Also i ask everyone, how much use was the entire GD spec/talk overall?

 

Lyrium, my extra life would go to Ika, and tbh I don't mind being lynched, but at this point it's not as important to me as it would have been to save Blab.

 

Vote: basicly this late in game makes it to me unaligned, atum=town

italicized: nothing of used

underlined: unaligned with lyrim

bolded: So you know his role? I see it as either their both wtiches (rubi confirmed) or he role read it somewhere (tbh i never found it or looked for it)

bolded coaching him

Atum=town

bolded red one: scum slip to say font is not town?
bolded red 2: titus is unaligned with rubi. this further damns them that they are aligned.

underlined: coaching

---------- Post automerged at 11:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:42 PM ----------

also to add in the last post is really one giant thing off fluff and could be interpreted as scum coaching scum

why doesnt rubi jump at font for this as scum?

---------- Post automerged at 11:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:43 PM ----------

god damn it i dont have my cirtus notes....

well i can summerize it.

remember lyrims giant post of what cirtus and rubi did?

compare that to font as well. than do it with poly, see the similarities?

---------- Post automerged at 11:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:45 PM ----------

oh btw using this, we can POE just about everyone

i snipped the last part b/c it was an attempt at manipulation. if we go by what font said (I bus as scum) it would mean she was preping to bus later.

---------- Post automerged at 11:54 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:51 PM ----------

ok my brain is basicly dead but if this isnt compelling enough evidence i dunno what is.

so im going to wait on klacks for him to lock in poly and then we can all go no lynch.

Long story short: scum got the short end of the stick. If the game continues for some odd reason, well I'm going to have to look into this greatly and reset everything on my thoughts.

 

Basically imo...

Poly and Atum have to be among the last scum. I'd prefer to outright lynch so nobody can backpedal, but I'm willing to let Klack judge him.

Tbh me and Bill are probably the least likely NK targets due to our roles, so if the game isn't solved tonight the likely scum must be-

Atum, Titus, or as much as I hate to say or even think it, Ika. The rest are conf town or highly leaning town in Bills case.

 

@Luckylee, we can do psuedovoting then. :nod: We vote for whoever Klackerz lynches. These won't count as lynch votes but show accountability. If we're lucky the mods might even keep track.

Judge Vote: Poly
Vote: No Lynch

---------- Post automerged at 10:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:29 PM ----------

The only conftown I see is Riley. I have hard townreads on ika, Lyrium and Snowvon, but they are not confirmed.

 

Holy shit. Let's all allow Bill to dictate play. Brilliant. I'm willing to be lynched if you all Lynch Bill Door tomorrow when it's found out I am town.

 

Fair enough.

Judge Vote Poly

Poly, if you're town now is the time to defend yourself.

 

Yes, let's lynch the judge who just judged in our favor. /s

 

...Poly. No. No. Explain why Bill is scum right now. Town doesn't let itself get lynched unless they have an ability upon death they think is worth death. Explain and safe yourself if you're town, convince me.

---------- Post automerged at 01:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:39 AM ----------

And I mean a case or something with references not just minor doubtcasting.