1. DLP Flash Christmas Competition + Writing Marathon 2024!

    Competition topic: Magical New Year!

    Marathon goal? Crank out words!

    Check the marathon thread or competition thread for details.

    Dismiss Notice
  2. Hi there, Guest

    Only registered users can really experience what DLP has to offer. Many forums are only accessible if you have an account. Why don't you register?
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Introducing for your Perusing Pleasure

    New Thread Thursday
    +
    Shit Post Sunday

    READ ME
    Dismiss Notice

Questions about YOUR FANFIC that don't deserve their own thread...

Discussion in 'Fanfic Discussion' started by Ched, Aug 3, 2013.

  1. Ched

    Ched Da Trek Moderator DLP Supporter ⭐⭐

    Joined:
    Jan 6, 2009
    Messages:
    8,378
    Location:
    The South
    Every breath of freezing air shot painfully down his throat, chilling his lungs, before turning to mist the instant he breathed out.

    Or some variation?
     
  2. DC

    DC Groundskeeper

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2012
    Messages:
    304
    Just gonna pop in here and say thanks for the help. Thanks for the help!
     
  3. ScottPress

    ScottPress The Horny Sovereign –§ Prestigious §– DLP Supporter

    Joined:
    Apr 22, 2013
    Messages:
    131
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    The Holy Moose Empire
    High Score:
    6900
    You have a way with words, Ched :)

    @Zennith: if you want to pick up and old fic just for the sake of finishing it, I'd say let it rest and write something new, that will interest you and not feel like an obligatory exercise.
     
  4. Thyestean

    Thyestean Slug Club Member

    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2012
    Messages:
    188
    Location:
    成都
    In my opinion saying breathing in/out is clunky. It doesn't flow well. I think it would be better to set the scene without having to say if he is breathing in or out, but describe it well enough that we already know or have already pictured it (the dry pain in the throat, chilling stabs in the lungs, cracked lips, etc). We don't naturally think about breathing, it is actually quite annoying when you notice it. And you try to not think about it and let it fall into the background.
     
    Last edited: Jun 13, 2014
  5. Warlocke

    Warlocke Fourth Champion

    Joined:
    Sep 17, 2006
    Messages:
    3,053
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    The armpit of Ohio
    They make medication for that. :|
     
  6. Joe's Nemesis

    Joe's Nemesis High Score: 2,058 ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    Messages:
    1,192
    High Score:
    2,058
    Quick question: what is the proper way to punctuate this sentence?

    "He had no idea, which one was Harry."
    "He had no idea which one was Harry."

    My guess is the second one, and I'm pretty sure of it, but I'm fighting with my word processor. I normally just ignore it, but I thought I'd get DLP's input first.

    Of course, this entire line could probably be written better. So if you have something, have at it.

    (Scene—Voldemort is looking on at three Death Eaters, one of whom is Harry dressed up. They're on brooms so the scene is moving too fast for Voldemort to use Legilmency on each of them to find out.)
     
    Last edited: Jun 18, 2014
  7. Uncle Stojil

    Uncle Stojil Auror

    Joined:
    Apr 16, 2011
    Messages:
    654
    The second one for sure. As for alternatives, "He couldn't tell which one was Harry." comes to mind. It's almost the same, but it sounds better imo. If you want to switch it up more, and if the story's narrator allows it, you could use "Which one was Harry? He couldn't tell."
     
  8. EkulTeabag

    EkulTeabag Seventh Year

    Joined:
    Jul 8, 2013
    Messages:
    280
    Location:
    Sandy, England
    Well, if Voldemort is the viewpoint character for that, I'd say have the wording of the narration more sophisticated. "He couldn't tell which one was Harry" seems too common for an intelligent guy like Voldemort.
     
  9. Uncle Stojil

    Uncle Stojil Auror

    Joined:
    Apr 16, 2011
    Messages:
    654
    The fact it's "Harry" and not "Potter" seems to hint it isn't from Voldemort's point of view, though.
     
  10. Joe's Nemesis

    Joe's Nemesis High Score: 2,058 ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    Messages:
    1,192
    High Score:
    2,058
    It's Harry's POV. But through the Horcrux, he's been conversing with and feeling Voldemort's emotions. So while the POV might be a little more fluid, it's still ultimately being interpreted by Harry to the reader.
     
  11. DC

    DC Groundskeeper

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2012
    Messages:
    304
    I'm no expert, but shouldn't it be as follows?

    He had no idea which one Harry was.

    In case that's incorrect, can you explain the positioning of the 'was'?
     
  12. badboy1cdx

    badboy1cdx Muggle

    Joined:
    Jun 17, 2014
    Messages:
    3
    What about something like this:

    It wasn’t snowing, but it was cold enough to - the heavy mist that hung about his face as he almost painfully drew breaths gave testament to that. Regardless, the night’s sky was perfectly clear, the stars were out, and beams of moonlight filtered through the tree tops into the forest clearing where the Society of the Crossed Wands had gathered.

    Shrug, that's about the best I can come up with. I considered a heavy miasma of mist, but that sounded just a little too alliterative for me.
     
  13. Joe's Nemesis

    Joe's Nemesis High Score: 2,058 ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    Messages:
    1,192
    High Score:
    2,058
    After thinking it through a bit, here's my understanding. I fully admit that I'm not sure it's right.

    "Harry" is the "one" of the relative clause, "which one." Because of that, they are equivalent words/concepts: A = B.

    The "to be" verb is acting as an equal sign. A IS B; which one IS Harry. You wouldn't say A, B equals, or write it A, B is (was). In the same way, you shouldn't write, "which one Harry is (was)."
     
  14. DC

    DC Groundskeeper

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2012
    Messages:
    304
    I think I understand. Appreciate it.
     
  15. Sesc

    Sesc Slytherin at Heart Moderator

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2007
    Messages:
    6,216
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Blocksberg, Germany
    The topic is subject questions and indirect questions.


    That one is Harry.

    Subject = 'That one' ('Harry' is a predicative complement here, a property of the subject, like e.g. 'red'). This implies the question

    Which one is Harry?

    That's a subject question, because the question word is (about) the subject, not Harry. Read that way, the order is not inverted, like with all subject questions ('Who broke the window'? - 'Peter broke the window.'; subject = Peter).

    For indirect questions, you change the order back around ('Harry is 16' - 'How old is Harry?' - 'I don't know how old Harry is.'), but obviously, if you didn't change anything for the question, you don't change anything back:

    That one is Harry.
    Which one is Harry?
    I don't know which one is Harry.


    Now, the confusion here is that it's not a priori clear that the very first premise is the case. 'Harry' could be the subject, and the order could be inverted. In that case, the original sentence would be:

    Harry is that one.
    Which one is Harry?
    I don't know which one Harry is.


    Applying that to Voldemort:

    He had no idea which one was Harry.
    vs.
    He had no idea which one Harry was.

    is the difference of whether the answer to that indirect question is 'That one was Harry', or 'Harry was that one'. To me, the former ('I don't know which one is Harry') sounds more forced than the latter, but that's possibly because it's wrong in German. Digging through the web, I found the exact opposite opinion to mine, so you might prefer that one.
     
    DC
  16. Skeletaure

    Skeletaure Magical Core Enthusiast ~ Prestige ~ DLP Supporter

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2006
    Messages:
    2,842
    Location:
    United Kingdom
    High Score:
    13,152
    Random terminological digression:

    Example sentence:

    "I went to the shop."

    Subject: I
    Object: the shop

    Subject question: Who went to the shop? (I did)
    Object question: Where did you go? (To the shop)

    Subject questions are asked without auxiliaries, object questions require auxiliaries (in this case, "did"). This is complicated with the verb "to be", which is the exception and never uses auxiliaries. Nevertheless, you still have a distinction between subject and object question form:

    Example sentence:

    "She is 20."

    Subject question: "Who is twenty?" (She is)
    Object question: "How old is she?" (20).

    The object question uses the grammatical question form, which for "be" is a reversal of word order rather than auxiliary use. The subject question uses the affirmative form (compare: She is 20/Who is 20?).

    *Edit: it turns out this isn't always the case...

    "The chair is red"

    Subject question: What is red? (the chair)
    Object question: What colour is the chair? (red)*

    Indirect questions are something different.

    Indicative affirmation: You are 20.

    Direct question: How old are you?
    Indirect question: Can I ask how old you are?

    Direct questions use the grammatical form of questions, indirect questions use a "question phrase" with the affirmative form.

    ----------------

    To answer this particular query, it should be:

    "He had no idea which one Harry was."

    You can see this if you switch in another verb:

    "He had no idea how far Harry swam."

    With the verb swim it's clear what the order should be. The alternative is clearly wrong:

    "He had no idea how far swam Harry."
     
    Last edited: Jun 21, 2014
  17. DC

    DC Groundskeeper

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2012
    Messages:
    304
    Wow, thanks, both of you. Those examples at the end really cleared it up for me.

    I was initially hesitant to ask, but thanks for taking the time out to help me out.
     
  18. Skeletaure

    Skeletaure Magical Core Enthusiast ~ Prestige ~ DLP Supporter

    Joined:
    Mar 5, 2006
    Messages:
    2,842
    Location:
    United Kingdom
    High Score:
    13,152
    Discussing it on IRC, we've pinned down why it's so ambiguous, I think.

    "To be" has two functions in English: it attributes properties and affirms identities.

    Property: "The chair is red."
    Identity: "A chair is a thing you sit on."

    If you were talking about properties, you'd put the verb first. Consider:

    "He had no idea which one was red."

    The opposite -- "He had no idea which one red was" -- is clearly wrong. We're left wondering if Voldemort knows what the colour red is. English always takes the word order Subject-verb-object, except in certain questions. Subject: which one, verb: was, object: red.

    When it comes to identity, we have the reverse situation.

    "He has no idea what a chair is."

    Again, the reverse is clearly wrong: "He has no idea what is a chair." We still want SVO word order, because this is an affirmative statement. Subject: a chair, verb: is. The object, being unknown, is not part of the sentence, but would be "a thing you sit on" (from our example sentence above, "A chair is a thing you sit on."). "What" is simply a relative pronoun pointing to "chair".

    So the phrase "He had no idea which one was Harry" is incorrect because it treats "Harry" like a property that the things in question can possess. But it's not a property, it's an identity.
     
    Last edited: Jun 21, 2014
  19. DC

    DC Groundskeeper

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2012
    Messages:
    304
    Yeah, I saw that discussion. Gonna use it as a sort of rule of thumb now, until I come across an exception.
     
  20. Joe's Nemesis

    Joe's Nemesis High Score: 2,058 ~ Prestige ~

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    Messages:
    1,192
    High Score:
    2,058
    The problem with that, Taure, is that you're ignoring the fact that this is a dependent clause ending with a Predicate Nominative. Because it's that, rather than an accusative, you can't substitute just any other verb for "to be." Predicate nominatives can ONLY take verbs that make the first noun equal the second.

    So, you wouldn't say, "he had no idea how Harry, that one equals." Instead, you'd say, "He had no idea how that one equals Harry."

    The entire clause is determined by the idea that "Harry" is a predicate nominative.

    EDIT: and in your next post, it's the same issue. You're forgetting the relative pronoun and the following predicate nominative.
     
Loading...