not really?

what if lucky/pod slot got lynched day 1?
what if he just hit you all 3 nights consecutively?
what if rubicon targeted you and took away your dayvig?
what if my portal worked (and knew about it) and saved myself that night and basicly townfirmed myself?

there are so many different outcomes and that it all falls onto wording and snow asking. that im with teir on this, your arguing about wording.

imagin if teri sacced kalas n1, rubi vanlialied you and lucky killed teri?

what then?

 

Seriously, Ter, good job. I'd probably have lynched everyone before you had I lived.

 

The wish not giving full info benefitted the scum team as well, it led to misundertandings afterall. After we lynched Atum, based off of Von's wish most assumed only 1 member of the scumteam/a third party was left. Except for me and the scumteam. That's hardly only an advantage for me.

 

The moral of the story is don't make a serial killer that can also protect themselves at night. They'll never be lynched and they'll be night killed, so they always win. See: Brass and Tax.

 

One: Once he stops using his commute, he can't commute again. Ever. He must compulsively kill every night.

Two: I think that there are a lot of people in this game who can lay claim to overpowered roles. Take Snowvon for example.

 

Lucky, stop acting defensively. I'm not saying you didn't earn your win -__-
In fact, I'm damn impressed with you.

Doesn't change the fact that Snow (and Town) got cheated with his wish, if he did in fact word it as he says he did. Nothing you had available to you would have made it so that you wouldn't be revealed.

Btw, he asked for players who can't win with Town, meaning scum and you, not all 3rders and scum.

 

It's a wish. The PM said I could wish for anything. Anything.

Like, I don't think revealing the number of people who couldn't win with town is overpowered. It was revealed there were two scum (sort of) left and town still didn't lynch correctly.

So.

 

Thanks ^^ I have to say first time scum was fun

 

Uh, no.

The scumteam assumed it that the two referred to me and Terraine.

 

Rubicon's vanillizer was conditional upon them accepting the contract.

If they don't accept the contract, and they don't get a wish, they're not vanillized.

 

im goign to play devil's advoacate on this: that on my homesite we have proablle at least 20+ games with sk like that who does not win

if anything the sk here is weaker then brass and tax

 

It's hardly overpowered. I am on my own team and cannot be carried to victory by a teammate. A one for one trade is fair.

 

1. So? The moment a kill bounces once, scum would never try to shoot him again. Even the threat of a bounced kill is enough to get scum teams to shoot elsewhere, because why would they risk a shot on a commuter when they can kill other people. With no town vigs, you gave him effective immortality.

 

Lexicat, what would have happened if I made someone a witch?

 

If I hadn't played as careful as I had, or if Lyrium hadn't derped so much I'd of been fucked. You guys are arguing my role is op, but the minute I killed Fonti I was revealed. People not believing Lyrium was due to me and Raine attacking her, as well as her earlier bad play. Nothing else. Your argument that the game was stacked in my favor is bullshit Fonti, and it pisses me off.

It wasn't easy to win, and you claiming my ability is overpowered cheapens it. Fuck off, Fonti.

 

What power would I have gotten if I transmuted fonti?

 

You say that, but your kill on Rubicon night 1 failed, and who did you kill ngiht 2?

Rubicon.

So stop it.

 

the bolded is the fault, you assume nobody would ever do it again.

again your being too narrowminded on this imo and too butthurt. if anything he was our town vig (killed the scums)

we could jsut basicly argue this was reverse mafia

 

Another 1 shot day vig, but this one would have been usable privately, and not required you to post it in thread.

 

?

How? There was no way for you to get lynched and no way for you to get night killed? Congrats on winning a game that you couldn't lose, I guess?