How come?

 

I dislikes Quank's focus on the massclaiming plan, and so far, he hasn't talked about much else.

Agent Q just feels town to me, but there are a few things I'm a bit suspicious of, so I'm barely townreading him. For now, I still believe he's town, though.

 

OMG Rubicon is back from the beyond.

Hai Rubicon. So...who's bad?

---------- Post automerged at 09:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:11 PM ----------

oh just saw the lucky tags

 

Elaborate?


Rubicon, what are your impressions now that you've had some time to catch up/digest it all?

 

9.Hello, I am doing very well. I have mostly just read bits and pieces of the filler games. The only thing that really stood out to me was the game where I believe Citrus was the sole Mafia out of 7 people, and that he seemed very confused/annoyed about it.

14.I'm not really sure what you mean. Could you give me a bit more explanation?

1.Penguin seems like the choice. It seems like the closer to the godfather role from the original, which from what I understand is a pretty big deal.

@Atum
I don't really have a huge knowledge of the forums.
Sloth seems pretty dangerous for a couple of reasons. I keep seeing his name pop up around in peoples posts asking for his opinion. This coupled with his signature means that he is most likley a good player.
Citrus seems like a fairly confident player as well, he keeps seeming to stick out in my mind for some reason. It's probably cause he insta-voted me.

Everyone else I'm not sure of. I don't see a lot of explanations for the votes so I don't know why everyone is doing what they are. Once I ignored most of the... differences of opinions(?) in Lyrium and TerRaine's posts they also seem pretty competent.
Sorry, It feels like I copied your answers.

Also
@Zenzao Bane is one of the most intelligent individuals in the Bat-verse. As far as I remember he is the only one to single-handedly figure out who batman was by himself, and he was able to make a serum that allowed him huge amounts of strength. Although it seems like in all the live action movies his character isn't nearly as smart.

 

Sure, I can always clarify. The pink and bold is the part I was referring to. You refer to town as "they" which set off some semantics level bells in my head.

What would you think of someone who in referring to town phrased it as "they" and therefore excluded themselves from the group? Or perhaps I'm reading far more into it the neccessary, just want to hear your thoughts.

Oh and welcome to DLP mafia, its the best there was and the best there ever will be.

 

To me, some of the things you've said have been rolefishy or doubtcasting.

---------- Post automerged at 09:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:38 PM ----------

Also, it would be nice if Fishy Justice would post.

 

Thanks for the welcome. Everyone has been pretty friendly thus far.

I think that, that person probably slipped up in that they are not part of that group. I can see what you mean.
When I answered your question I actually took a step back and did a side by side of the games. I just referred to everything as they(GDP, Town , Mafia) or in the case of The Riddler "he".
I'll try to put myself in it more when I answer from now on. That should make things clearer.

 

What is the GDP?

 

What *is* doubtcasting?

 

The Gothem Department Police... What else would it be called?
Ya, I fucked that up should have been GCPD.

 

You do know they were removed from the 17 person game, right?

 

Because I'm a lazy fart. And I haven't played mafia in a while, and I'm bad. Point is it takes effort and I'm running low on effort. I've been considering replacing out, but I didn't. For what it's worth, I'm a little sorry about that. Just a bit though.

The relevant question answers are something like:
I didn't read the original, and I don't really care to. As for this game, town has a lot of info roles. I doubt Bane was chosen in this case. Less players, and a trimmed down roster would really hurt the loudness that is Bane. The lack of any vig's makes Penguin more dangerous. Might get lucky with Cat woman, though.

Dangerous: Penguin because of our info gathering powers. Riddler because one off scummies scare me. I feel like interactions between teams are some of the best scum hunting tools. Or one of the only ones I know how to use(A little bit, anyway). We'll go with that.

Ter is reading town-ish for me. Lyr is slightly townish. Lots of laundry though.

I don't like Riley playing all defensive. QQ has rubbed me the wrong way. Sloth's "last hour" thingy is objectively terrible and I don't feel there's been enough yelling about that. Hear me Sloth? Objectively terrible! T e r r i b l e. Terrible. And you should probably know better, which is the point.

I want to yell at fluffy for wasting a pressure vote on a non-entity, but I've done the the same thing. Not the best plan to pressure people for simply being absent. It usually doesn't accomplish much. It's also very easy and risk free to do. Maybe if they've barely posted, but a no post is likely going to be replaced, or have a good reason. I have neither, but shh.

Honestly, I've just skimmed and I'm tired. I suppose I will put forth sufficient effort, tomorrow.

 

The semantics thing is definitely a thing, with players that consciously think about what they're typing it'll appear the way they planned but when someone absent-mindedly rushes a post it definitely comes up different.

---------- Post automerged at 09:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:17 PM ----------

Welcome Lyrium to team town!

Town block so far: Schrodinger, TerRaine, Zenzao, Riley, Quanksor, Lyrium

---------- Post automerged at 09:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:18 PM ----------

I'd like Sloth to post a current read list

 

Oh, QQ was the one who voted me. Replace fluffy with QQ then. See? Tired.

 

I voted Schrodinger, not you, Fishy, and I don't like that you're making up scummy things to accuse me for.

---------- Post automerged at 10:20 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:20 PM ----------

Ninja'd by Fishy.

---------- Post automerged at 10:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:20 PM ----------

I would also like Sloth to post a read list, and hopefully to explain it this time.

 

Yes I do. The GCPD came up in my first post where I was comparing the 30 man game to the 17 man, in response to Lyrium's question.

 

Impressions and Such

Oh and thanks Quanksor (with two Qs I may need to give you a nickname) for the number stuff breakdown.

Town-side
Zenzao – I’ve never been in a scum game with Zen but I’ve been in a lot of games where he was a good guy and it feels as if its similar here.

Riley – There are players who play scummy as town and there are players who play townie as scum. Riley is the former. Also, Riley remember when you were mean to me in Survivor?

Snowvon – I’m not sure if this is what my heart desires or if this true but I need to think about this more and see how he progresses.

His fluffiness – Leans town due to thinking fluff posts are scum tells which he will learn is not always the case, it depends on the suspect.

Unclear or Waffles with Syrup
Aekiel – Only played in two games with Aekiel (Riley’s Dresden thing where he marked me as scum and CYS). In both he was town and a good player. Lean town and he responded to the role mechanics very helpfully.

Citrus – Citrus plays scummy as town except our first game (Dresden) where Citrus was like the uber town player. What happened to your game Citrus?

Sloth – Needs to talk more, clarify reads and such. Not sure how to read the everyone mass claim at the last hour theory which was a bit unthought out. More interactions needed to really see which way.

Schrodinger – He does have a foot in the mouth problem so waiting to see more of his interactions.

Atum – feels a little more town then scum but he’s a slippery one. Remember that time you did all that color coded stuff and you were still scum? Oh and only Riley could roll me as scum and we know RIley carries a grudge.

Quanksor – lots of mechanics discussion, what is your experience level again?

Ken Kraitos – it seems like he's totally newish but not baa sheep new which is interesting.


Scum-side
TerRaine – Have two theories on this one which I’ll keep to myself for now. Does she usually do the apostrophe things like ‘Cept and ‘S shortcuts? Kind of clipped tone\language. And the Bane obsession, as in we don’t even know if there is a Bane and already setting up the “don’t trust someone who comes forward claiming Bane is stalking them.”
There’s a second theory there but that is for my qt.

Other comments and concerns
Rubicon, replacements are 90% scum? True or false?
Remember that one time where you promised not to be scum and then you turned out to be a no-good gambler? Will you do us wrong like that again? It reminds me of that song on the radio, don't think I could forget...

Citrus, from what I understand Kentos Kraitos is a newbie. Like utter newborn and I am very very particular about players who vote the newbies or the confuzzled ducklings. You know the easy prey. I tunnel these players all over town.

His fluffiness, you switch votes from Quanksor to Schrodinger but still think the former is suspicious. Why switch votes? Why not tunnel a bit or question more?

Agent Q, I never asked a question about my playstyle. My playstyle is very close to my personality so if you hate on it you're basically hating on me and we can never be friends ever. In post #110 I commented on playstyle but never have I ever asked that question yet in this game. Read a bit more carefully. I’m actually surprised at your lack of reading those posts carefully but feeling the need to comment at length regarding what was obviously a girly fight with sprinkles on top.

Also I believe you’re agreeing with his fluffiness about Schrodinger? Wait another not reading carefully enough moment. Pray do tell what is it that distracts you from the basics of reading carefully?

Fishy, I kind of remember you from that one game where you like lurked or flaked but you were funnier than the other person who had no sense of humor or a silly bone.


I’ll keep this here and I think I’ll just refrain from trying to phone post votes as there are some issues.
Vote TerRaine

 

It's because, as I looked over Quank's posts, I remembered reading a few of his Town games where he acted similar, so I'm a bit less sure about my scum read on him.

However, Schrodinger was fluffposting and then giving excuses for not giving his opinions, which I find to be scummy.

So for me, both of them are on the scummier side, with Schro being a bit worse than Quank.

 

I was scum in that game...