@Riley

Sloth vs TerRaine vs Quanksor. Opinions?

---------- Post automerged at 11:07 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:05 AM ----------

@Mathblade

Do you think Quanksor is potentially town because he looks different from FStrike or for other reasons?

 

TerRaine's reactions read too realistically to be faked in my opinion. I have been in her situation in the past and it sucks. I reacted fairly similarly, so for now benefit of the doubt with a removal of the scum lean.


Lyrium: We have a past, a lot of my reads are unfortunately somewhat unobjective but she seems suspicious to me now. The No Lynch thing did ping my gut a bit as does the fact that instead of stating up front that she'd prefer RL things go to mods in the QT but instead points it out as a scum tell. This seems a bit backtracky. I do want to point out I'm focusing on how she reacted, not on what she was reacting to. but the quick backing up, it's added a scum lean in my thoughts.

Quankor: Lurking really hard but does come in randomly to answer questions. Lurking at this stage is not really desirable but understandable with how long Day 1 is. Maybe push for more questions as well as pressure.

Pressure vote being set: Vote: Quanksor

I'll remove that if he comes in more often

 

Asked and answered previously. Doing two second summary of those posts.

Yes his play seems different from FStrike. Almost every if not every game he was scum on that site. He also was doing some discussion earlier that makes me think likely town.

 

Realized that said Sloth instead of Lyrium. Whoops.

Gotta re-tread the thread real quick. Brb.

---------- Post automerged at 01:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:16 PM ----------

Had to trawl back to page 11 (that's 7 pages) and 6 full days between his last post and now.

That's a huge problem. Either Sloth is a lurky townie or he's the SK. He's never silent when Scum.

 

Riley ():
Snowvon (1): Nemrut
Aekiel (1): Sloth
Citrus ():
Lyrium (2): Qgqqqqq, Mathblade
Sloth (2): Citrus, Zenzao
TerRaine (1):Aekiel,
Qgqqqqq ():
Rubicon (1): Lyrium
Nemrut (1): His fluffiness
Atum ():
His fluffiness (1): Atum
Quanksor (3): Rubicon, TerRaine, Riley
Mathblade ():
Zenzao (1): Quanksor
Fishy Justice ():
Kento Kraitos ():

Not Voting ( 3 ) Fishy Justice, Kento Kraitos, Snowvon

17 Alive, 9 to lynch

Mod notes:

 

My reason for asking is because this is why he initially pinged me as town. He's a little too...lackadasical? Whimsical? It's a quality I see in him OoG, but he was always relatively cautious in game and he was scum in every single FStrike game I saw him in.

But then he (like Sloth) hasn't posted something useful in ages

 

Could you post a link to one of these FS games?

 

http://www.fantasystrike.com/forums/index.php?threads/quickhunt-1.9774/

http://www.fantasystrike.com/forums/index.php?threads/polarity-hunt-game-5-town-wins.9484/

 

I always liked how we got the exact same scumteam in both of those games, and I still suspect the moderator might have fiddled with the roles a bit.

 

So now that you're here, Quank, any reads to give on anyone?

 

Working my way down the list, noticed the links.

 

Still working on my reads, but the end is in sight!

I just wanted to suggest something.



Q, avatar maybe?

---------- Post automerged at 16:12 ---------- Previous post was at 15:31 ----------

I've gone through six players (skipped Lyrium) and so far Sloth is my only scumread. I have some notes and can post them if people really want to see my brain flail around like a dying fish.

tl;dr'ing my QT junk: Sloth's head seems to be absent from the game. He has very few posts, and none of them make me want to townread him. His dump-and-dash posting style makes me sad. And his readslist in 212 bugs the shit out of me. He puts more pressure on Riley, his top townread, than all of his scumreads put together. His read on Lyrium reeks because she is beyond town and he should know that. His read on TerRaine feels like a weird cop-out he's setting aside to capitalize on later.

Vote: Sloth

 

So which players have you gone through?

---------- Post automerged at 04:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:13 PM ----------

Never mind, skipping Lyrium and you, you should have done up to Q.

---------- Post automerged at 04:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:15 PM ----------

Also,
Kalas, can you replace Schrodinger with MathBlade on the player list?

 

Townfirmed
Quanksor
I have mechanical info that this player is town.

Townish
Riley
Scumhunting, seems towny.

Qgqqqqq
Scumhunting, seems towny.

Rubicon
Pushing for my lynch, but in a towny way.

TerRaine
Asking a lot of questions and scumhunting.

His fluffiness
pursuing Nemrut for lack of content, scumhunting in general.

Mathblade
Replaced in on page 14, already beating a few players on post count. Seems extremely towny, but that may be a bit biased because she is saying I am town.

Citrus
Asking questions, being helpful. Seems towny

Slightly Townish
Sloth
5 posts, but they were full of actual content.

Kento Kraitos
Calling people out on tiny bits of speech, me included.

Lyrium
A bit agressive, but otherwise sort of towny.

Null
Atum
Keeps reiterating that he does not want to die D1, but not much else. I'm going to reserve judgement, and see what he does tomorrow.

Nemrut
5 posts overall, with only one post that actually says anything. Not enough material to get a vibe.

Snowvon
#162 is a bit weird. I could not see myself saying this as town, but that's just me.

Scummy
Aekiel
Claims that players are towny, then refuses to back up the claims at all because it "Gives too much info to scum".

Zenzao
Marked me as definite scum because I was looking for a mechanical solution. I don't want to assume he is scum just because of this, but it is unsettling

Extremely Scummy
Fishy Justice
Two whole posts, neither of them particularly helpful, and nothing before or after page 8. Could be scum or town, but either way he needs some votes.

Vote: Fishy Justice


I had a thing here reminding the mod about the playerlist, but I was ninja'd by fluffy

 

Quanksor, this is 162:

Are you talking about this maybe:

Or something else?

---------- Post automerged at 19:49 ---------- Previous post was at 19:07 ----------

Oh, almost forgot this.

Scum, scum, null, town, null, and town.

 

I meant #126, sorry

 

@Mathblade
#319 It might be a good idea to keep role names out of posts for now until two of the nuisances are dealt with.

Atum stated that Sloth and Citrus are the most dangerous players in the game a while back.

@Everyone
Whom do you think is the most dangerous?

@TerRaine & Lyrium
I believe this question may have been asked, but what are your opinions on Mathblade?

 

Seems like this wouldn't warrant a high scum-read, even if it does warrant a OMGUS vote. The extremely scummy category here feels very inappropriate, more like it was added afterwards then anything else - from this Fishy is more likely to deserve "Null" even if you do decide to vote for him.

---------- Post automerged at 01:57 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:56 AM ----------

Why am I scum, Snowy?

 

@Citrus A lot of people haven't posted much recently. It has been a slow game.

@Quanksor Thanks for posting reads and getting engaged. I am not quite sure why you have some limited posters as null and Fishy as scummy. Can you point to what specifically makes you think that way?

@Kento Yeah probably shouldn't have done that. I was trying to explain and couldn't think of another way without roles. And I think generally we should try to not mention too much about roles yeah until end game unless we get to a make it or break it situation.

IMO Citrus is dangerous to me because I struggle to read him. Sloth I think I can read him sometimes which is better than my Citrus reads. Sloth had a magnificent scum game a while back.

I am thinking that they have the most experience and can be a threat if they are scum. However the biggest threat will always be scum.

Oh and maybe my read explanations because in mid/late game I speak MathBlade-ese as much as I try to explain in English /attemptAtHumor

 

@Mathblade

Idk about everyone else, but I'm currently dying because Final Exams right now which thankfully only lasts another week give or take